- Nov 25, 2017
- 1,017
- 1,362
- Country
- United States
- Faith
- Christian
- Marital Status
- Married
Posting this here so Catholics and Protestants can reply freely.
Fantastic... thank you for the link.Posting this here so Catholics and Protestants can reply freely.
Read the paper a while ago. I wish it had covered more of the response to Calvinism. As it is, I found some of the objections to Lutheranism inadequate to generalize to Reformed doctrine. For instance, the assertion that "faith with no works is not true faith" is no statement that an informed Calvinist would disagree with. The issue is not really justification by faith but the definition of salvation as process rather than a legal category.
Well, that's the coherence problem that Protestantism has in general. Because a tension is seen between faith and works, there's inevitably pressure to gravitate towards one to the exclusion of the other. The thing that completely upended me about Orthodoxy from the start was how that tension didn't exist, so that you end up with both being emphasized.I think it depends on the Protestants you run in to. in some of my Army chaplain training, I have met guys from the Calvinist line who would absolutely disagree and say true faith is completely apart from works (and of course others, who completely agree with your point).
Well, that's the coherence problem that Protestantism has in general. Because a tension is seen between faith and works, there's inevitably pressure to gravitate towards one to the exclusion of the other. The thing that completely upended me about Orthodoxy from the start was how that tension didn't exist, so that you end up with both being emphasized.