A few questions...cross post from OBOB

Status
Not open for further replies.

lux et lex

light and law
Jan 8, 2009
3,457
168
✟12,029.00
Faith
Anglican
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Democrat
Hello fellow Liberals. I'm going through a time of spiritual exploration, and any help or guidance would be greatly appreciated.

Hello everyone. Please let me know if I'm stepping on any feet. I don't want this thread to turn controversial or anything, I am exploring things, trying to find a faith path, and I have long been at least mildly interested in Catholicism. I nearly converted while I was a teen. Here's a brief back story.

I was raise in a split religion home. My father is a devout Catholic, and my mom is a Christmas/Easter Lutheran. The choice was made for us kids to be raise Lutheran so my mom could participate in my first communion/confirmation and sit in the front row of at my wedding. Yep, those were the deciding factors. My dad allowed this, as long as Catholicism would be part of my faith life. I grew up squarely between the two churches. I went to Sunday school and was confirmed ELCA Lutheran, but I predominately went to Mass with my dad.

This was well and good, but my father's parents made everything very scary for me. They would regularly mail me checks with "convert?" in the memo line; whenever I would visit them, they would take time to remind me to convert or I'd end up in hell. When I was five, we had just finished a meal at their house and my grandpa turned to my dad and said "Well, you better enjoy your family here, because you'll be alone in heaven while they're being tormented in hell". Those words burned in my mind. Both my parents sat me down and explained that grandpa didn't understand, and I wasn't necessarily going to hell. That did, however, kick off my further exploration of the Catholic church. Aside from an occasional Christmas, I haven't been back to the Lutheran church since 2000. I haven't regularly attended church since then, a lot has gone on in my life, and I've struggled to have a faith life. I talked with my father about converting, and where he said that would bring him great joy, it was something I really needed to think about, and think of the ramifications for my mother. I didn't understand this until both of his parents passed away.

I have never felt like less of a human at my grandparents' funerals. My dad was able to sit in the front row at my grandpa's funeral, while my mother and sibling sat in the third. At my grandma's funeral my sibling and I were both pallbearers, and weren't allowed to sit with the other 3. We had to sit in the 4th row. Unfortunately, the priest wouldn't allow my father to sit in the front row with his aunts and brother, he had to sit in the fourth row with his "Protestant family" (direct quote from the priest). I saw the hurt in my father, not only from losing his mother, but being banished from participating as a normal family member would.

I don't hate the Catholic Church at all, but there are a lot of things I don't understand. I've befriended a Catholic woman, and she's been teaching me a lot. She puts up with my questioning and is a good role model. I haven't made it to Mass with her yet (I work during the times it's offered) but I do go with her every week for her Adoration hour. Adoration is something I find fascinating. I enjoy going because it's peaceful, and I feel a deep connection to God while I'm there; which is something I've been lacking for a great while. Do most Catholic churches have Adoration? It's something I never had heard of until I met her.

I have a very soft spot for the Catholic church, mainly because I have a deep respect and admiration for my father. With some sadness, it's something that I don't think I could ever fully subscribe to, dogmatically (such as I am staunchly pro choice from a legal aspect (I'm an attorney) but am pro life when it comes to my own decisions. I am also pro human rights and equality (including but not limited to homosexual equality). Which is somewhat bittersweet to me, because I enjoy the Catholic church and feel like a stranger in a familiar place when I attend Mass due to the stares I get for not partaking in Communion.

Basically, I'm open to anyone's thoughts or commentary. Thanks for letting me intrude into your space. Peace be with you all.
 

KevinKuck

Catholic Left
Nov 14, 2011
76
3
✟15,211.00
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Hello fellow Liberals. I'm going through a time of spiritual exploration, and any help or guidance would be greatly appreciated.

Hello everyone. Please let me know if I'm stepping on any feet. I don't want this thread to turn controversial or anything, I am exploring things, trying to find a faith path, and I have long been at least mildly interested in Catholicism. I nearly converted while I was a teen. Here's a brief back story.

I was raise in a split religion home. My father is a devout Catholic, and my mom is a Christmas/Easter Lutheran. The choice was made for us kids to be raise Lutheran so my mom could participate in my first communion/confirmation and sit in the front row of at my wedding. Yep, those were the deciding factors. My dad allowed this, as long as Catholicism would be part of my faith life. I grew up squarely between the two churches. I went to Sunday school and was confirmed ELCA Lutheran, but I predominately went to Mass with my dad.

This was well and good, but my father's parents made everything very scary for me. They would regularly mail me checks with "convert?" in the memo line; whenever I would visit them, they would take time to remind me to convert or I'd end up in hell. When I was five, we had just finished a meal at their house and my grandpa turned to my dad and said "Well, you better enjoy your family here, because you'll be alone in heaven while they're being tormented in hell". Those words burned in my mind. Both my parents sat me down and explained that grandpa didn't understand, and I wasn't necessarily going to hell. That did, however, kick off my further exploration of the Catholic church. Aside from an occasional Christmas, I haven't been back to the Lutheran church since 2000. I haven't regularly attended church since then, a lot has gone on in my life, and I've struggled to have a faith life. I talked with my father about converting, and where he said that would bring him great joy, it was something I really needed to think about, and think of the ramifications for my mother. I didn't understand this until both of his parents passed away.

I have never felt like less of a human at my grandparents' funerals. My dad was able to sit in the front row at my grandpa's funeral, while my mother and sibling sat in the third. At my grandma's funeral my sibling and I were both pallbearers, and weren't allowed to sit with the other 3. We had to sit in the 4th row. Unfortunately, the priest wouldn't allow my father to sit in the front row with his aunts and brother, he had to sit in the fourth row with his "Protestant family" (direct quote from the priest). I saw the hurt in my father, not only from losing his mother, but being banished from participating as a normal family member would.

I don't hate the Catholic Church at all, but there are a lot of things I don't understand. I've befriended a Catholic woman, and she's been teaching me a lot. She puts up with my questioning and is a good role model. I haven't made it to Mass with her yet (I work during the times it's offered) but I do go with her every week for her Adoration hour. Adoration is something I find fascinating. I enjoy going because it's peaceful, and I feel a deep connection to God while I'm there; which is something I've been lacking for a great while. Do most Catholic churches have Adoration? It's something I never had heard of until I met her.

I have a very soft spot for the Catholic church, mainly because I have a deep respect and admiration for my father. With some sadness, it's something that I don't think I could ever fully subscribe to, dogmatically (such as I am staunchly pro choice from a legal aspect (I'm an attorney) but am pro life when it comes to my own decisions. I am also pro human rights and equality (including but not limited to homosexual equality). Which is somewhat bittersweet to me, because I enjoy the Catholic church and feel like a stranger in a familiar place when I attend Mass due to the stares I get for not partaking in Communion.

Basically, I'm open to anyone's thoughts or commentary. Thanks for letting me intrude into your space. Peace be with you all.

I also grew up in a family that was half Protestant, Half Catholic...but I guess we had more of an ecumenical thought process going on. I guess we saw each other as just different types of Christians, and the only time we "attacked" each other on these grounds, was in total jest.

As for adoration, most parishes do have it, but it seems to me it has been on the rise in recent years and when I was growing up in the 80s, I was completely unaware of it. It is only recently that I became aware of it myself (and I've been going to Mass since I was in the second grade).

I would suggest that you start going to Mass, but perhaps not just at one specific parish (if this is possible for you, not sure if your enviornment is urban or rural). Check out a few different parishes and see how you feel about your experiences. You might specifically look for parishes that self-designate themselves as "stewardship parishes" as they often are a little more social justice-equality oriented.

Peace to you!
 
Upvote 0

Rao

Candlecaster
Sep 24, 2009
175
12
✟7,862.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
I have a very soft spot for the Catholic church, mainly because I have a deep respect and admiration for my father. With some sadness, it's something that I don't think I could ever fully subscribe to, dogmatically (such as I am staunchly pro choice from a legal aspect (I'm an attorney) but am pro life when it comes to my own decisions. I am also pro human rights and equality (including but not limited to homosexual equality). Which is somewhat bittersweet to me, because I enjoy the Catholic church and feel like a stranger in a familiar place when I attend Mass due to the stares I get for not partaking in Communion.

I am a liberal catholic and let me tell you that it won't be easy at all if you want to remain honest to your true beliefs and conscience. In my experience there is always going to be someone who will threat you ("you're going to hell") or harass you ("you are not catholic, go away") if you openly speak up an opinion that opposes a dogma or one of the currently most relevant moral teachings of the Catholic Church, such as those you mention about being pro-choice or for gay rights. You may even be called a murderer (exact word used by our pastor during a Mass) if you are in favour of abortion or euthanasia for example, even tho you would never do or suggest them to anyone but just be from a legal point of view.

But in my opinion this is probably the same you would face in more or less every religious group. There is some sort of "comply or die" mentality everywhere, it seems... At least you should know that you're not alone, there are millions of people like you. It's just part of life's burden, that wherever you go you'll always find someone who will tell you to change and comply.

So perhaps you should do what your heart tells you more than what your mind tells you. If you your feelings are 100% sure then go ahead, otherwise don't rush it.

Probably the most correct way to proceed would be to go and talk to those ministers who will have to formally accept you into the Catholic Church (I don't actually know how it works to convert from your confession), and let them know where you stand in terms of feelings and ideas. But if you do that, I have the feeling that if you tell the whole truth, they won't let you convert, but I might be wrong. At least they allowed one of my atheist friends to be baptized/confirmed only for the sole purpose of having a catholic marriage with his catholic girlfriend, even tho he let the priest know squarely that he would have remained a non-believer.
 
Upvote 0

Diane_Windsor

Senior Contributor
Jun 29, 2004
10,162
495
✟27,907.00
Faith
Agnostic
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Others
I have never felt like less of a human at my grandparents' funerals. My dad was able to sit in the front row at my grandpa's funeral, while my mother and sibling sat in the third. At my grandma's funeral my sibling and I were both pallbearers, and weren't allowed to sit with the other 3. We had to sit in the 4th row. Unfortunately, the priest wouldn't allow my father to sit in the front row with his aunts and brother, he had to sit in the fourth row with his "Protestant family" (direct quote from the priest). I saw the hurt in my father, not only from losing his mother, but being banished from participating as a normal family member would.

:confused: Is there some theological reasoning the priest used to justify splitting up family members in mourning based upon their religious affiliation? I've never heard of that being done.
 
Upvote 0

Rao

Candlecaster
Sep 24, 2009
175
12
✟7,862.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
:confused: Is there some theological reasoning the priest used to justify splitting up family members in mourning based upon their religious affiliation? I've never heard of that being done.

Well, some people in the Catholic Church talk about the principle of "theological suspension of ethics", but as a liberal catholic I would be more inclined to believe in the "ethical suspension of theology" so go figure... :p
 
Upvote 0

lux et lex

light and law
Jan 8, 2009
3,457
168
✟12,029.00
Faith
Anglican
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Democrat
I have been exploring my views versus Catholicism and they mostly line up. The things I have the biggest problem with are "life" (I believe in natural birth to natural death as being life, where apparently it is conception to natural death) and homosexuality being a sin. Should these things really hold me back?

Here is something I wrote on my Catholic friend's status about how education and healthcare are important, but we must vote life anyway:

I can respect this. Although, as we've previously discussed (somewhat) this also makes me sad. Roe has been the law of the land for 39 years, most of which have been years with a republican president and a conservative Congress, and yet there has been no groundbreaking changes to speak of. Life, rather, abortion, has become a political football, and it will continue to be. It's a safe issue to take a stance against knowing full well no progress will be made due to those "liberal activist judges" (please note, Roe was passed by a relatively conservative court). Republican's pro life stances are more pro fetus, because they tend to be the biggest proponents of the death penalty, which is the antithesis to life. Also, unfortunately, they are opponents to basic human health care, which is an important aspect of life, and education, some of which is sexual education, which is important to lower the abortion rate overall. Know that I respect you deeply, but I can't come to the same conclusion as you, even though I would choose life personally, because of all the other social justice issues. We have a population currently which is badly in need of good education and basic healthcare. Please don't forget about them.
 
Upvote 0
Status
Not open for further replies.