Perhaps I read it when I was not able to appreciate its full value. I always read a book at least three times before I dismiss it. I'll have to pick it up again
OK. Like I said, we all have different preferences...
Perhaps you would like his novel
The Napoleon of Notting Hill better maybe?...When asked in an interview what his ten favorite books were, Terry Pratchett listed that novel first,
For teaching me how to see the world. To Chesterton, even a quiet street was a world of fantasy and a street lamp more precious that a star (because there's a universe full of stars, compared to which street lamps are really uncommon.
Then again, Pratchett also likes
The Man Who Was Thursday, so maybe not....
I love the Classics from the medieval period up through the Victorian era, and I really enjoy Robert Frost. For modern authors I like Tom Clancy and Robert Liparulo.
Admittedly, I don't really read that many classics, so I cannot say much about that. No doubt that is something I am going to have to fix. The only "classics" I have really read are ones that are religious in nature (such as St. Augustine's
Confessions, though that example predates the medieval period, of course).
I love Tom Clancy as well, especially
Patriot Games. But I haven't heard of Robert Liparulo. Could you tell me a little more about him?
And since Chesterton wrote about everything you listed, let me just offer a few suggestions.
I love reading theology,
Plenty there, of course. You might enjoy
The Everlasting Man (which C.S. Lewis described as the book that helped him the most in becoming a Christian, and as the best popular defense of the Christian faith he was aware of). And, of course,
Orthodoxy. But there's plenty of others.
philosophy
St. Thomas Aquinas: The Dumb Ox would be a good book. It is considered by many leading Thomists (i.e., Etienne Gilson, Jacques Maritain, Anton C. Pegis, etc.) as the best book ever written on this philosopher
history,
The Everlasting Man would fall under that category as well, plus there's always
A Short History of England (best known as the history book without any dates in it, though in fact it has four. lol. But George Bernard Shaw thought highly of it)
social commentary, etc.
Plenty there as well, such as
What's Wrong with the World (as Michael Crichton pointed out:
Chesterton saw the implications of their vision of twentieth century society, and he predicted exactly what would come of it
Like I said, there are plenty of others, but....
OK, I'm done now. Heh.
(Sorry, I'm a big Chesterton fan, so....)