arguing for what a group would do in a hypothetical situation. thats brilliant.The Boy Scouts took care of [FONT=arial,helvetica]all the maintenance and all the expenses at Balboa Park. The services that the Islamic Society are to do are [/FONT] offer lectures on Islam at Roxbury Community College and help develop an Islamic library there. Were such a sweetheart deal ever given to a Christian group, the ACLU would have a lawsuit filed before the ink was dry.[FONT=arial,helvetica]
[/FONT]
so the mosque is more than a mosque, will provide monthly lectures for 10 years, pay some $200,000, and maintain 2 parks as compensation.Community Relationships
The new center is directly adjacent to the Roxbury Community College (RCC) on a parcel of land that has been vacant for the past 40 years. As part of their agreement with the BRA for the purchase of the Roxbury property, the ISBCC will offer monthly lectures for the next ten years at RCC and will donate books to the college's library.
Both the city and the ISB hope the cultural center will attract Muslim businesses and residents to the Roxbury community, which could have an enormous impact on the area's economic situation. The center also agreed to maintain two local parks as a method of compensation to the city for setting aside the land. The center will also benefit the larger Boston community by providing a forum for interfaith dialogue and interactions with civic leaders.
now lets examine the compensation package the boy scouts provided, and what they received...
and to get to the heart of the issue with balboa park...he City has given the Scouts nearly seventy years of exclusive use of 18 acres of prime park property in city-owned Balboa Park for $1 per year and free use of an aquatic facility on city-owned Fiesta Island in Mission Bay through preferential leases.
link
so, the boyscouts were paying a total of $70 for exclusive use. these two cases couldn't be any less similar."While it may be legally acceptable for the Scouts to privately discriminate against so many boys and their families, it has never been acceptable for the City to bar those families from a public park.
same link as above