I am agnostic, he is Christian .. we are pregnant!

T

terragena

Guest
Hey everyone! This is my very first post, and thanks in advance for any insight you can give.

I'm an agnostic and my husband is a Christian. This has never been a problem for us, in fact, we like the ways we have influenced each other. But this is less about our relationship and more about the fact that we are expecting our first baby!

We both agree there are a lot of good reasons to go to church when you have a baby. I don't have any problem with church, I'm quite comfortable, and I donate money, so I feel like I'm doing some good and not just loitering around. The only thing is that churches seem so judgmental, and I don't want my child to be around that.

My husband wanted to go to his old Baptist church, and I wanted to go Unitarian.. I think we're compromising with a Methodist church, but I was reading their platform and it troubled me. For one thing, they don't allow homosexuals to serve the church in any function. I like the idea of church daycare, but I don't want my children to spend a lot of time in a place where they will be taught they are better than other people.

I want my child to be able to choose their religion freely when they're old enough to know what they're doing, not to be brainwashed. And I don't want them to learn about science and politics in church. There are lots of things I want them exposed to, but some not so great things I've seen in churches that I'd like to avoid.

Is there anyone here who's done this kind of thing, or just wants to weigh in? Does the Methodist church sound like it might be right for us? I really don't know that much about churches, and my husband has only ever been to Baptist churches. Thank you....
 

Knight

Knight of the Cross
Apr 11, 2002
3,395
117
50
Indiana
Visit site
✟4,472.00
Faith
Calvinist
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
Congratulations on your baby. Prepare for a huge change. :)

Are you asking what kind of church you should go to?

I am sorry but church will mean nothing until you believe the gospel. Going to church does not make you a Christian. Repenting and placing faith in Christ for the forgiveness of sins is the only way.

I do not mean to make light of your situation. I can understand your difficulty but until you are in Christ church will never be anything more than a social club.
 
Upvote 0

Stinker

Senior Veteran
Sep 23, 2004
3,555
174
Overland Park, KS.
✟4,880.00
Faith
Christian Seeker
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Others
I am sorry, but I just do not see the two of you able to make a religious comprimise at this time. The gulf appears way too far. The only way (that I see) the two of you able to come together on this issue is to try to get him to see that not every word contained in our Bible is God breathed. (2Tim.3:16) Just the passages of scripture that can be proven to be are. These are the ones the Apostle Paul meant.

In other words, He would have to be led out of Fundamentalism to be a moderate Christian, or, you will have to become a fundamentalist.
 
Upvote 0

sandman

Senior Member
Aug 17, 2003
2,458
1,643
MI
✟121,866.00
Country
United States
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Divorced
Politics
US-Constitution
I have to agree with Stinker, the cuteness of that chasm between your beliefs will become not so cute later, and more of an issue that could result in serious conflicts.

I want my child to be able to choose their religion freely when they're old enough to know what they're doing, not to be brainwashed.
I have heard that statement made many times and to me it is illogical. You are dealing with your child’s life and by the time it is old enough to decide it may be to late. It’s like saying I don’t really want to expose my child to the dangers of playing in traffic, I will wait until my child is old enough to decide on it’s own …..by then it may be too late.
As a mother you are instinctively protective of your child. From birth you are teaching that child to talk …….then walk …you continually teach them everyday through stories rhymes and songs. You help them to grow in knowledge, and warn them of the dangers of hot stoves, and putting the cat in the dryer {well that might not be a bad idea} and yet you want to deprive them of the most important thing in life ………a spiritual walk ……something they will learn mostly through watching mom & dad.
I say give them a fighting chance and pick something….. Unitarian, Baptist …..something. They will decide when they are older, but at least then it will be an informed decision.
 
Upvote 0

Digit

Senior Veteran
Mar 4, 2007
3,364
215
Australia
✟12,570.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
Hey everyone! This is my very first post, and thanks in advance for any insight you can give.

I'm an agnostic and my husband is a Christian. This has never been a problem for us, in fact, we like the ways we have influenced each other. But this is less about our relationship and more about the fact that we are expecting our first baby!

We both agree there are a lot of good reasons to go to church when you have a baby. I don't have any problem with church, I'm quite comfortable, and I donate money, so I feel like I'm doing some good and not just loitering around. The only thing is that churches seem so judgmental, and I don't want my child to be around that.

My husband wanted to go to his old Baptist church, and I wanted to go Unitarian.. I think we're compromising with a Methodist church, but I was reading their platform and it troubled me. For one thing, they don't allow homosexuals to serve the church in any function. I like the idea of church daycare, but I don't want my children to spend a lot of time in a place where they will be taught they are better than other people.

I want my child to be able to choose their religion freely when they're old enough to know what they're doing, not to be brainwashed. And I don't want them to learn about science and politics in church. There are lots of things I want them exposed to, but some not so great things I've seen in churches that I'd like to avoid.

Is there anyone here who's done this kind of thing, or just wants to weigh in? Does the Methodist church sound like it might be right for us? I really don't know that much about churches, and my husband has only ever been to Baptist churches. Thank you....
Hello Terragena,

First up congratulations on your pregnancy and I hope you are both really looking forward to it all. Personally, it scares the heck outta me, which I guess is a fair sign I'm not ready for it. :p But for those that are, woot, yay and etc. :D

In regards to the difficulties of raising a child in a family of mixed belief, that's not really something I feel qualified to advise on. There is a forum here that is dedicated to those of unevenly yoked relationships, which you can find here. Perhaps you can ask your husband to post there as it is open to Christians only. He can ask for input and adive there and you can both read it.

Now, for my obligatory, "Have you considered Christianity for yourself?" speach. ;) If you have, or if you aren't really open to it, then skip this paragraph. First up I think I would consider what your husband believes and how it impacts you both, as he believes and is living life in the hope of an eternal destination for him and I think in a relationship there is nothing quite as hard as knowing your partner won't be there too. Without getting into the nature of Heaven and Hell, regardless of what the actual form of one is and isn't, we do know one is very desireable and one is not. It's fantastic that you are open at least to church and so forth, and it saddens me that you are put off by how other people live their lives in Christ. As with all things that are of man, there are good and bad. So you will likely find good churches and bad ones. I would recommend a Church of Christ, at least here in Aus we have specifc churches of that name, and they have a teaching that is focussed centrally on Jesus, and to be fair as long as He is the focus, I don't think you can go far wrong. In regards to not letting homosexuals serve in the church, this probably has more to do with politics than anything else, in that if they did they may be seen to be condoning, supporting or approving of their lifestyle. This they cannot do, if they are to stick to what the Bible says. We are told to love the sinner, just not the sin, so they are of course welcome in church, but not to represent the church. I hope that doesn't seem unfair to you, but as I said politcs can make these things very messy. Ok, this paragraph is ending up longer than I intended, so I will end it now, even though I have much more to say.

I will agree with some of the other posters, in that your relational beliefs may take on a less charming light as more things pop up in life. I don't want to preach doom and gloom ahead, as by and large there is just as an equal chance that things will work out fine, as there is that they will not. But I think you should be very sensitive to these possibilities, and don't let the sun go down on any issues that come up. The larger the distance grows between you in this area, the harder it will be to close it, and the more it could impact things.

In regards to your childs belief, I think that they will grow up believing exactly what they want to. ;) That may sound odd, and slightly chaotic, but God gave us free will to choose, and if we can deny Him, then we can deny our parents without any effort at all. I've read posts from people here who grew up in atheistic families, and turned Christian - in Christian families and are atheists and so on. I think the more you can expose your child to the Bible and the morals within, the better, the more you can highlight not to focus on those around them, but on the teachings within, the better. The Bible may seem like a weird book to turn to for these things sometimes, but it has a way of explaining complicated things in very simple langauage. It's all about relationships, and how we treat each other. I think if you do that, the rest will fall into place, and please do consider your own faith as truly a relationship when both partners are under God is quite amazing. :)

All the best!
Digit
vbmenu_register("postmenu_39835687", true);
 
  • Like
Reactions: tapero
Upvote 0

tapero

Legend
Site Supporter
Apr 14, 2004
36,534
1,128
Visit site
✟88,544.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
Hey everyone! This is my very first post, and thanks in advance for any insight you can give.

I'm an agnostic and my husband is a Christian. This has never been a problem for us, in fact, we like the ways we have influenced each other. But this is less about our relationship and more about the fact that we are expecting our first baby!

We both agree there are a lot of good reasons to go to church when you have a baby. I don't have any problem with church, I'm quite comfortable, and I donate money, so I feel like I'm doing some good and not just loitering around. The only thing is that churches seem so judgmental, and I don't want my child to be around that.

My husband wanted to go to his old Baptist church, and I wanted to go Unitarian.. I think we're compromising with a Methodist church, but I was reading their platform and it troubled me. For one thing, they don't allow homosexuals to serve the church in any function. I like the idea of church daycare, but I don't want my children to spend a lot of time in a place where they will be taught they are better than other people.

I want my child to be able to choose their religion freely when they're old enough to know what they're doing, not to be brainwashed. And I don't want them to learn about science and politics in church. There are lots of things I want them exposed to, but some not so great things I've seen in churches that I'd like to avoid.

Is there anyone here who's done this kind of thing, or just wants to weigh in? Does the Methodist church sound like it might be right for us? I really don't know that much about churches, and my husband has only ever been to Baptist churches. Thank you....

Hi, Congratulations on your going to have a baby.

There are very good churches out there. I've only gone to non denominational ones mainly so have little experience with denominational churches.

Non denoms have their own statement of faith, and while there may be 100 by the same non denomational type, they have the same statement of faith.

If you go to a church that is not political and does not single out specific sins, you still may run into people going there that do so on their own, so fairly unavoidable unless you are in a liberal church which doesn't believe or teach that sin is sin which is a lie, as the bible is very clear on sin. Not exhaustive, but covers plenty.

I would never attend a church that is political, though am thankful for movements that come through public means such as advocates or those in office, but to me the church is not quite the right place at all.

Christ didn't get into politics imo, said, give Ceasar what is Ceasars and God what is Gods.

Political churches have an agenda many times and the focus is not on Christ who saves us, but rather on issues, and when I go to church, I want to go to a Christ centered church.

Though again am thankful for those who stand up for certain issues but I would never go to a church that does so, if a political one I mean. Focus's on issues rather than on helping brothers and sisters and newcomers. I guess I'm talking about extreme political churches, but even if not extreme, still would nver go to a political church.

Doubt you'll find a church that doesn't get into science, such as teaching creation or having a sermon on it, except of the two you mentioned, the Unitarian church most likely will not teach creation.

If anyone teaches children they are better than others, than they are not well acquainted with scripture.

For God teaches us to be servant to all, and to be humble and much more and while everyone struggles with sin, those who feel superior have a problem, and can be found at any church or any place at all, even having nothing to do with church and having no belief in God. Is how some people are.

But that you say you don't want them taught that they are better shows you have prejudged what Christians are like, as tho there are those who do so, all christians are different and all churches are different.

And again, any Christian acts like their better, has a spiritual problem.

So, because someone says they believe homosexuality to be a sin (which it is, as is all sexual immorality), does not mean they think they are better than another.

Rather it is the truth. I don't say such unless asked if is a sin and then explain that all sin is sin, one is not worse than the other as pertains to eternity, as it's belief in Christ that brings salvation and forgiveness for sins, present past and future.

I stated it here as you brought up the topic, so felt needed to tell you, majority knows sexual sin is sin. But have never been to a church preaches particular sins. As sin is sin.

A liberal church would teach otherwise more than likely.

But again, singling out a specific sin is rather wrong, imo, and some Christians do so due to a scripture that says certain sins done by those, they will not go to heaven.

These same Christians don't realize there are several lists saying such and such won't inherit heaven, and they are on it, as we all are on the bit that lists those with certain sins won't go to heaven.

Many don't even know they are on the list, as they don't look in their heart, or in the mirror t know we all are one or other of those lists. But between the lists given every human is on it.

They neglect to take the New Testament in it's whole context. So that is where part of the problem lies. Belief in Christ saves us, and all Christians are saved and can not lose their salvation, but we still sin.

The point of talking about sin is that it is going to be heard about in church, unless liberal and depending how liberal.

Your child won't be brainwashed unless someone straps them in a chair and forces them not to think for themselves, which unless torture occurs is not going to happen or if you go to a church which is a cult, where brainwashing does occur, and those are out and out cults.

My mother raised us with no morals; I was not brainwashed, I made my own choices when I was an adult, and younger.

I'd rather have been raised in a christian family really, but who knows what I would have done and what choices I would make had I been raised in a Christian family. Such brings no guarantees to no one that their child will be a Christian if raised in a Christian family.

We all make our own choices.

Churches are not judgemental, people are. And you can find a church that is judgemental and you would probably not want to go there.

I've never been to a judgemental 'church', but have always run into judgemental people. Exists everywhere, christian or non Christian.

You may say you have no values which are christian per se (just an example), but you have values which are your values while it just may be in your mind and not spoken, you also are judgemental as you believe your values should be upheld, whatever they may be.

Such as you said about homosexuals. That is just as judgmental as those saying shouldn't serve in the church.

So, we all have values but many and often times, people say it's Christians who are judgemental, while non Christians fail to see they are just as judgemental and may say, you are trying to force your beliefs on us non christians, when on the other hand, non christians it can be said are trying to force their beliefs on some Christians as well.

Bible clearly says who should hold office in a church and and it's a husband of one wife and more as pertains to that, hence why such is taught or practiced in churches that do so.

Is not judgemental to Christians who hold to that, as is what is in the bible to be done. But to those who differ on that is said it's judgemental. Some Christians do not hold to that teaching as well; consider it judgemental.

I'm just trying in this post to give you a lot of information to fill in maybe things you may not be aware of.

There is a forum on this site, it's a liberal congregation. I'll give you that link and they may help as they may know what denominations or congregations might be a good fit for both of you.

One last note, a child who is raised a christian is not forced to be a Christian. No one can force someone to believe something they don't believe, again unless tortured or in a cult.

You said you want your child to choose their religion freely when they are old enough, not to be brainwashed.

Any child and every child that grows up no matter what they are raised in freely chooses their own religion, unless they are in a country where persecution occurs, or if they are raised with threats and fear, etc, which does occur in many places and even in america. Even so there are many who closet what they truly believe, as is not safe to speak it.

They may be raised in one faith, and grow up and later change to a different faith.

Often times many don't think much about things such as all that is in the world till late 20s sometimes.

Some are in tune to the way of the world and the choices out there much younger as well.

Anyway, whatever church you go to, would need a healthy church, one that does not use fear, condemnation preaching, or guilt tactics. There's all manners of churches out there.

But there are very good churches as well. Healthy churches, but if Christian your child will learn things you may not want them to learn, depending on the church.

So, here's the congregation link on this site, which might help you more. Called whosoever will, may come liberal at this link: http://foru.ms/f401-whosoever-will-may-come-liberal.html

This will be a congregation that is non judgmental to my knowledge and may help you.

Sorry for the long post; just want to make you aware of things and show you that perhaps you prejudge Christians or churches and have your own beliefs, which might be judgemental to another, but because you hold it you don't see it as such.

Every christian is differnt and unique as are non christians, and every church is different and unique.

Every human being has values or morals they strongly hold, but it they aren't 'religious' they tend to call those who have a faith judgmental, when in actuality works both ways.

eeks, i went way long on this, and way off topic, you are sincereley seeking help and i felt to write as I did, I hope you don't mind.

take care,
:hug:
 
Upvote 0

WarEagle

Well-Known Member
Nov 12, 2006
4,273
475
✟7,149.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
My husband wanted to go to his old Baptist church, and I wanted to go Unitarian.. I think we're compromising with a Methodist church, but I was reading their platform and it troubled me. For one thing, they don't allow homosexuals to serve the church in any function.


Good for them. The Bible says that ministers in the church should be above reproach and of good moral character.

If a gay person is living in unrepentant sin, then they're not Biblically qualified to serve.


I like the idea of church daycare, but I don't want my children to spend a lot of time in a place where they will be taught they are better than other people.


Actually, Christianity doesn't teach this. Just the opposite, in fact. It teaches that we're sinners, just like everyone else.

I want my child to be able to choose their religion freely when they're old enough to know what they're doing, not to be brainwashed.


And yet, I'll bet you have no problem teaching them not to run out into the middle of the highway or that 2+2= 4.


And I don't want them to learn about science and politics in church.


Would you have a problem with them learning the junk science of evolution in schools, or humanism, or any of the numerous liberal political things children learn in public school?


Is there anyone here who's done this kind of thing, or just wants to weigh in? Does the Methodist church sound like it might be right for us?


I grew up in the Methodist church, but it's changed greatly for the worse over the years.


In the state it's in now, I don't know if it's right for anyone. You're better off finding a Bible believing church that will present the Gospel faithfully and hold you accountable.


I wish your husband was here. I'd really like to know why a Christian believes it's acceptable to compromise on Biblical teaching.
 
Upvote 0

Reformationist

Non nobis domine sed tuo nomine da gloriam
Mar 7, 2002
14,273
465
51
✟37,095.00
Country
United States
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
I'm an agnostic and my husband is a Christian. This has never been a problem for us, in fact, we like the ways we have influenced each other. But this is less about our relationship and more about the fact that we are expecting our first baby!


Congratulations on the impending arrival. :)

We both agree there are a lot of good reasons to go to church when you have a baby.

Like what, for instance?

I don't have any problem with church, I'm quite comfortable, and I donate money, so I feel like I'm doing some good and not just loitering around.

Well, I'm not sure what that has to do with faith but, okay. :confused:


The only thing is that churches seem so judgmental, and I don't want my child to be around that.

Churches are made up of people. If you want to stay away from judgmental people, you're going to have to stay away from people altogether, though that may be hard as you, yourself, are a person.

My husband wanted to go to his old Baptist church, and I wanted to go Unitarian.. I think we're compromising with a Methodist church, but I was reading their platform and it troubled me. For one thing, they don't allow homosexuals to serve the church in any
function.


Homosexuality has been a part of humanity for thousands of years but if you're looking for a church that matches your beliefs that homosexuality should be overlooked as if there is nothing wrong with it, you're going to need to avoid Christian churches altogether.

I like the idea of church daycare, but I don't want my children to spend a lot of time in a place where they will be taught they are better than other people.

Christianity is not about being taught you are better than others. We are taught to esteem others more highly than yourself, in fact. With that said, there are beliefs that Christians consider absolutes. Homosexuality being wrong is one of them.

I want my child to be able to choose their religion freely when they're old enough to know what they're doing, not to be brainwashed.

Well, that's good. :)

And I don't want them to learn about science and politics in church.

Okay. Do you want them to learn about politics and science in school? If so, it seems as if you're contending that science and politics devoid of faith is more appropriate than if it includes the foundation of faith in Christ. If thats the case, well, I doubt you and your husband will see eye to eye.

There are lots of things I want them exposed to, but some not so great things I've seen in churches that I'd like to avoid.

There are bad things everywhere, and bad people as well. Keeping them from exposure to bad things and bad people in one catagory, i.e., Christianity, doesn't remove all instances of evil.

Is there anyone here who's done this kind of thing, or just wants to weigh in? Does the Methodist church sound like it might be right for us? I really don't know that much about churches, and my husband has only ever been to Baptist churches. Thank you....

Hope that helps.

God bless
 
Upvote 0
T

terragena

Guest
Wow thanks for all the nice replies, and for being so helpful. Yes, I guess I was looking for suggestions as to what type of church to visit.

When I say there are a lot of good reasons to go, I meant to meet friends that maybe have their own families or don't party as much as our other friends. Most of our friends are in the 30s and still act like they're in college and drink like fishes. Have our kid associate with kids whose families are less likely to use drugs and real bad language things like that. I realize churchgoers are not all the same, but aren't they more likely to at least be trying to be good?

Also, we agree on most things that deal with religion. My husband hasn't gone to church for years for many of the same reasons I don't go. Why does he want to go to a conservative church.. it is not a good match for him. Because it's hard to break away from the things you're taught when you're young if it's really drilled in.

Of course, I would love to become a Christian, but I just have this problem with believing all the stuff. I was raised Baptist too and I was very into it. I also was educated (private religious school) in the Baptist church. I was taught a lot of things that I couldn't accept when I was older or just found out to be flat false. I stopped believing what I believed in, and it was very unpleasant process.

I just don't want that for my family, I think religion should be a comfort and an inspiration to be a better person and not divide people or make them feel guilty or scared. And I'm trying to find what kind of church would be best, because I do want to go and I do want to call myself a Christian of some kind, probably the kind that more conservative Christians spineless Christians for only believing the parts that are comfortable. But really I'm strong in my convictions, they just involve listening to my heart as well as the Bible because I don't trust the Bible 100%.

I hope that didn't sound disrespectful to anyone. I realize I went on for a while, but hey free spiritual advice? Yes please!
 
Upvote 0

Reformationist

Non nobis domine sed tuo nomine da gloriam
Mar 7, 2002
14,273
465
51
✟37,095.00
Country
United States
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
Yes, I guess I was looking for suggestions as to what type of church to visit.

Well, unless you're going for the purpose of learning about God and striving to obey Him in all your ways, it's not really going to make much of a difference on an eternal level. If, however, you're looking to find a church that won't tell you the truth of man's naturally rebellious disposition, well, then the Methodist church is definitely one that suits the bill.

When I say there are a lot of good reasons to go, I meant to meet friends that maybe have their own families or don't party as much as our other friends. Most of our friends are in the 30s and still act like they're in college and drink like fishes. Have our kid associate with kids whose families are less likely to use drugs and real bad language things like that. I realize churchgoers are not all the same, but aren't they more likely to at least be trying to be good?

Well, it is true that Christians accept the Bible's authority on how we are expected to behave. With that said, there is something inherently wrong with wanting the benefits of Christian fellowship without submission to the Benefactor.

Also, we agree on most things that deal with religion.

I'm sorry to hear that.

My husband hasn't gone to church for years for many of the same reasons I don't go.

That's generally what happens in marriages between believers and non-believers. Believers always think that bridge is only going to go one way. I'm curious, was your husband a practicing Christian when you met?

Why does he want to go to a conservative church.. it is not a good match for him. Because it's hard to break away from the things you're taught when you're young if it's really drilled in.

The problem with this approach is that your goal should be to find a church that teaches the truth rather than find a church that doesn't cause you to evaluate your beliefs. My old Pastor used to say, "A good service is one that you leave feeling both good and bad."

Of course, I would love to become a Christian, but I just have this problem with believing all the stuff.

While I'm not sure what "the stuff" is to which you refer, if it is the truth of the Gospel, church is going to be of little value, and no eternal value, to you if you have no faith.

I was raised Baptist too and I was very into it. I also was educated (private religious school) in the Baptist church. I was taught a lot of things that I couldn't accept when I was older or just found out to be flat false. I stopped believing what I believed in, and it was very unpleasant process.

Big changes generally are unpleasant. What was it that you couldn't accept?

I just don't want that for my family, I think religion should be a comfort and an inspiration to be a better person and not divide people or make them feel guilty or scared.

Well, you're guilty whether you feel that way or not. I say guilt is my friend, for it lets me know when I've strayed from the narrow road. The Bible should not only tell you what to do, it should tell you what not to do. If you do not feel any guilt for your transgressions, you'll have no reliance on God for your reconciliation.

And I'm trying to find what kind of church would be best, because I do want to go and I do want to call myself a Christian of some kind, probably the kind that people like War Eagle will think of as spineless Christians for only believing the parts that are comfortable. But really I'm strong in my convictions, they just involve listening to my heart as well as the Bible because I don't trust the Bible 100%.

Being a Christian means that you submit to the authority of God in all areas of your life, not just the ones that you have no problems overcoming on your own power. That is not a Christian at all, much less a spineless one.

I hope that didn't sound disrespectful to anyone. I realize I went on for a while, but hey free spiritual advice? Yes please!

I don't think you were disrespectful at all. In fact, you were very pleasant. :)

God bless
 
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums

WarEagle

Well-Known Member
Nov 12, 2006
4,273
475
✟7,149.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
When I say there are a lot of good reasons to go, I meant to meet friends that maybe have their own families or don't party as much as our other friends. Most of our friends are in the 30s and still act like they're in college and drink like fishes. Have our kid associate with kids whose families are less likely to use drugs and real bad language things like that. I realize churchgoers are not all the same, but aren't they more likely to at least be trying to be good?

So then, you're looking for a church that would be a good social outlet?

Is that what church is for?

Of course, I would love to become a Christian

Why?

I just don't want that for my family, I think religion should be a comfort and an inspiration to be a better person and not divide people or make them feel guilty or scared.

But are you looking for a good religion to join or do you want to follow Christ?

probably the kind that people like War Eagle will think of as spineless Christians...

Did you know that the Bible tells us that when you guys insult us, God counts that as a blessing for us?

for only believing the parts that are comfortable. But really I'm strong in my convictions, they just involve listening to my heart as well as the Bible because I don't trust the Bible 100%.

Did you know that the Bible says that the heart is deceitfully wicked?

I hope that didn't sound disrespectful to anyone.

Yeah, your insinuation was a little insulting.
 
Upvote 0
T

terragena

Guest
Well, unless you're going for the purpose of learning about God and striving to obey Him in all your ways, it's not really going to make much of a difference on an eternal level. If, however, you're looking to find a church that won't tell you the truth of man's naturally rebellious disposition, well, then the Methodist church is definitely one that suits the bill.

That's just a little bit oversimplified. I don't think the church should not tell you your faults (as humans) and challenge you to rise above them. I kind of think that is their job

Well, it is true that Christians accept the Bible's authority on how we are expected to behave. With that said, there is something inherently wrong with wanting the benefits of Christian fellowship without submission to the Benefactor.

I know, I feel that way too. It's like using them, and it makes me feel guilty. Hence the desire to donate, so at least I can feel like I'm doing something practical that's helpful.

I'm sorry to hear that.

Well... We're both pro-gay unions (he is for civil union only), both accept the theory of evolution, he believes in creation while believe in abiogenesis, same political party, believe in division of Church and State. As for the tenets of Christianity of course we're not on the same page.

That's generally what happens in marriages between believers and non-believers. Believers always think that bridge is only going to go one way. I'm curious, was your husband a practicing Christian when you met?

No, he didn't go to church when we first met. He read his Bible and prays, which he still does, and talked to people about how Christianity improved his life if they were interested, which he still does

The problem with this approach is that your goal should be to find a church that teaches the truth rather than find a church that doesn't cause you to evaluate your beliefs. My old Pastor used to say, "A good service is one that you leave feeling both good and bad."

Any church will make me do that! I realize my attitude of approaching a church like a buffet probably seems horrible to some folks.. but I don't mean it in a bad way and I am still feeling the whole thing out anyway.

While I'm not sure what "the stuff" is to which you refer, if it is the truth of the Gospel, church is going to be of little value, and no eternal value, to you if you have no faith.

Miracles, virgin birth, rising from the dead, life after death, original sin, that Jesus was not completely human.

Big changes generally are unpleasant. What was it that you couldn't accept?

I went to a pretty fundamentalist school as a child, and church until my late teens.. I'm 28 now.. most of the things I was taught about science were not correct and some of history and a lot of the morality, like that all other religions will go to Hell.. I just don't believe it, and when I questioned the existence of God I didn't think that He really made sense either. It was a very all or nothing flavor of Christianity and it didn't stand up to scrutiny.

Well, you're guilty whether you feel that way or not. I say guilt is my friend, for it lets me know when I've strayed from the narrow road. The Bible should not only tell you what to do, it should tell you what not to do. If you do not feel any guilt for your transgressions, you'll have no reliance on God for your reconciliation.

That is true.. I'm not lacking in a compass where right and wrong are concerned.

Being a Christian means that you submit to the authority of God in all areas of your life, not just the ones that you have no problems overcoming on your own power. That is not a Christian at all, much less a spineless one.

I don't entirely disagree with you there.

I don't think you were disrespectful at all. In fact, you were very pleasant. :)

God bless


Thanks
 
Upvote 0
T

terragena

Guest
Did you know that the Bible tells us that when you guys insult us, God counts that as a blessing for us?

I'm sorry, I really didn't mean to say anything insulting. I'm not used to talking about religion, at least not with Christians. I really am trying to be polite and honest at the same time.

Yeah, your insinuation was a little insulting.

It was unintentional. I know this is your forum, thanks for putting up with me.
 
Upvote 0

WarEagle

Well-Known Member
Nov 12, 2006
4,273
475
✟7,149.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
I'm sorry, I really didn't mean to say anything insulting. I'm not used to talking about religion, at least not with Christians. I really am trying to be polite and honest at the same time.

Then I guess that means you're going to edit it out of your post.
 
Upvote 0

Reformationist

Non nobis domine sed tuo nomine da gloriam
Mar 7, 2002
14,273
465
51
✟37,095.00
Country
United States
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
That's just a little bit oversimplified. I don't think the church should not tell you your faults (as humans) and challenge you to rise above them. I kind of think that is their job



I know, I feel that way too. It's like using them, and it makes me feel guilty. Hence the desire to donate, so at least I can feel like I'm doing something practical that's helpful.



Well... We're both pro-gay unions (he is for civil union only), both accept the theory of evolution, he believes in creation while believe in abiogenesis, same political party, believe in division of Church and State. As for the tenets of Christianity of course we're not on the same page.



No, he didn't go to church when we first met. He read his Bible and prays, which he still does, and talked to people about how Christianity improved his life if they were interested, which he still does



Any church will make me do that! I realize my attitude of approaching a church like a buffet probably seems horrible to some folks.. but I don't mean it in a bad way and I am still feeling the whole thing out anyway.



Miracles, virgin birth, rising from the dead, life after death, original sin, that Jesus was not completely human.



I went to a pretty fundamentalist school as a child, and church until my late teens.. I'm 28 now.. most of the things I was taught about science were not correct and some of history and a lot of the morality, like that all other religions will go to Hell.. I just don't believe it, and when I questioned the existence of God I didn't think that He really made sense either. It was a very all or nothing flavor of Christianity and it didn't stand up to scrutiny.



That is true.. I'm not lacking in a compass where right and wrong are concerned.



I don't entirely disagree with you there.




Thanks

Well terragena, feel free to ask us anything more specific you may want to discuss. Until then, I pray the Lord reveals Himself to both you and your husband such that you would both embrace Him in all your ways.

God bless
 
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums

AllTalkNoAction

Potentially Wonderful
Aug 7, 2005
3,724
78
Near London, England
Visit site
✟19,423.00
Faith
Pentecostal
Marital Status
Single

The only thing is that churches seem so judgmental, and I don't want my child to be around that.

The only judgement christians should make about people not in God's church is precisely that !
Whether they are gay, straight, do-gooders or murderers, they need to be born again, and thet won't do that until they see the benefit of it !
It's the churches calling to show the goodness of God.

"what have I to do to judge them also that are without?" (1 Cor.5:12)

"For the love of Christ constraineth us; because we thus judge, that if one died for all, then were all dead"
(2 Cor. 5:14) (dead spiritually, not having a right relationship with God)

Once people become God's people in the true sense by receiving His Spirit (detailed in Acts 2:4, 33, 39; 10:44-46) they begin to appreciate God's understanding, love and abilities. They find they have new desires for these things which were hidden before and old sins begin to disappear.

Sadly many "churches" don't know this love, they substitute man's love which gives in to what people want and cannot see what God wants.

The best thing for your family is to find a church like the one God set up.
 
Upvote 0

Digit

Senior Veteran
Mar 4, 2007
3,364
215
Australia
✟12,570.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
Hello Terragena,

First of all, I don't think you owe anyone apologies for anything you've posted here. This isn't our forum, it's actually your forum, and we come here as visitors to help you, the poster. The issues that you have with Christianity (virgin birth, miracles) and so on, can all be resolved with study of the Bible and it's events. Unfortunately it's time consuming, but let me say that with as many denominations as Christianity has (33000+) there are people who believe in all sorts of things, yet maintain the most important core beliefs in Christ's integrity and His offer of salvation for us. All of the things you mentioned are important, but at least for me, they form the branches to my faith, and they are not the roots - I think that's important, as some of them change, and you don't want to have to re-establish your faith each time your understanding of one of the branches evolves.

Cheers!
Digit
 
Upvote 0

Multi-Elis

Senior Veteran
Jul 6, 2003
2,173
114
41
Paris
Visit site
✟17,911.00
Faith
Christian
I want my child to be able to choose their religion freely when they're old enough to know what they're doing, not to be brainwashed.
My father is a christian, and he's a thinking person. This ended himself as the heretic in the church. While growing up, he watched me get socially influenced by the very rightwing, conservative, charismatic churches. (Socialy influenced is a nicer word than brainwashed.) And during this time he patiently explained to me his views and I constantly debated him, and dissagreed with him. Then one day I got fed up with the church I was brought up in (not that it was that bad, it was just part of the growing up proces). Then over a period of 3 years I started to change, and ended up adopting views more similar to my father's views than those of the church I grew up in. Now I'm the heretic. The point is: sometimes a parent who invests in his/her children and mentors them well will prevail on other ideas that may flout in the atmosphere. A parent can end up socially influencing (brainwashing) his/her child as much or more than an institution. So it really all comes down to you and the values you will strive to give to your child, though you may only see the fruit when they are old enough to know what they are doing. Children and teenagers don't think very much for themselves, and that's normal.
 
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums

katealpha

Regular Member
Nov 28, 2006
442
28
✟8,235.00
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Married
I pray you give your child the opportunity to be exposed to the Christian upbringing so that they have the knoweldge to really chose for themselves when they are older.
I was from a non-practising, agnostic type family who still believed that Christianity was a good thing because it was 'moral' but nothing beyond that, and the result is it took me 30 years to find my way to the Church. 30 years. I'd have rather been exposed to the facts a bit earlier really because I've made so many mistakes in my life, generally due to selfishness.

Btw you are entirely right to be giving something practical, though you should be listening to your heart of hearts telling you that you should really be in church for more reason than this. 'Good works' are a vital part of following Christ's example but so is faith.
 
Upvote 0