P{-400,000K BC < (GBWE) < -4K BC} = 1
P means probability
BWE means big water event, GBWE means Genesis flood.
K = 1000 years
BC means before Christ
if P{x} = 1, then x is a sure event
"The same guys who say this is a "Big Water Event" are also saying that it was two floods 450,000 years ago. Why are you accepting their expertise when it agrees with what you believed beforehand, but rejecting it when it disagrees with that? Isn't that cherry-picking? After all, if you don't trust them to know the difference between two floods and one flood, why should they know the difference between one flood and no flood?"
Shern,
I am cherry picking.
It is just that, for me, there is plenty of room to move on theories about events that took place eons ago. As far as I know maybe there were 5 BWEs or 500 BWEs, plus a few big meteor events, who really knows? That still leaves room for the Genesis flood. (GBWE)
But that is just me and that is why I can agree with the OP insofar as definite claims made by scientists/people about distant events.
So you are right but I prefer to be a skeptical cherry picker.
M