xlolokinsx

Member
Apr 14, 2006
86
2
✟212.00
Faith
Presbyterian
I'm not good at debating things. My speaking skills are not that great, I can't ever find the right words to say out loud, even though I can find the right words for paper.

I don't have many Christian friends, but this is a friend who I've been trying really hard to reach. She's perhaps my best friend, and it's easier to talk with her about religion than a bunch of my other friends.

She hasgone to my church with her family for about a year. We've had three long discussions about religion, the most recent being last night. She comes to church pretty much every Sunday, but she hadn't been to church that much before her family attened my church. And she has so many questions about Christianity and the Bible, and seems very intrigued by Islam. I guess she's a very, very liberal Christian. When I asked her last night if she thought of herself as a Christian, she said yes. At the same time though, she doesn't believe that there is a Hell, and so Jesus dying on the cross didn't save us from our sins. She believes Jesus was a great guy, but didn't save the human race, she thinks Muhammed was just as good.

Last night, our main focus in the discussion/debate was is there was one right and one wrong religion. I believe in Christianity, and she just believes in a God, not picky about whose God. She told me that the error in my thinking was that Christians believe that they shouldn't judge, but yet we believe that our religion is the "right" one. And then she went on to talk about all the terrible things Christians have done to nonChristians over the years. And I didn't have an answer for her arguement. I beat around the bush, and explained why I believed we must be right, my personal experience with God, but I didn't know how to answer her question. All the time I was praying to God that he'd reveal himself to her, and that he'd reveal his son, because it's not going to be me that shows her Christ, I'm just trying to steer her in the right direction.

And what makes it even harder is that I can't use my only weapon against her, the Bible. She says that even if the bible was once the word of God, it's been totally garbled up, and now might have a couple parts that are God's word, but is mostly humans making it up. She was telling me about how in 200 ad some kings changed the bible, and now they think they have it how it was before that, but they can't be sure. I had never heard of this, and I asked my mom and dad, who had never heard of it either (and I consider them good sources for history of that stuff). Does anybody know what she was talking about? She has a tendency to make things up or stretch the truth about things, and she also enjoys books about Christians from a nonChristian point of view, so I have trouble believing a lot of the arguements she gives, including the one about the kings. At the same time, I have no idea where she got this info from, so I can't argue against it, no matter how strange it sounds.

I want so bad for her to believe in Christ's mercy. I said so much last night that I haven't said to anybody before because I feel so self concious talking about it. I told her I do this because I can't stand the thought I seeing people in Hell, but she didn't care, because she doesn't believe there is one. I told her about the time I felt God, last summer on a mission trip. She was there, sitting right next to me on the night that I had my questions answered, the night I felt God. But she's skeptical, because when I felt him, she didn't.

In retrospect, I see things I could have said, missed opportunities. But I don't know if the same situation will present itself again to use these ideas, and if the opporunity does arise, I probably don't remember them. Like I said, I'm not a very good talker.

What can I do? I'm going to double my efforts praying for her, and I'd love it if you would pray for her too. What can I say to her though? When another one of these conversations comes up, as it does every few months, what should I tell her? I don't know what more I can do.

Also, does anybody have any books/websites to read that they think would help me? Theology type stuff, arguements for why Jesus saves us?
 

vespasia

Franciscan.
Site Supporter
Oct 15, 2004
5,805
407
Back
✟51,460.00
Faith
Anglican
Marital Status
Private
The only recommendation I have is a simple one.

Keep praying FOR her to come to now Christ, that He meets her where she is in such a way she recognises Him for who He is.

We can only tell people about Christ, it is God who can move a heart.

She may well be refering to the debates that took place to decide what was the inspired word of God and what was not following the early start of heretical teachings.

You may find the theology forums of use in this respect.
 
Upvote 0

rocklife

Senior Veteran
Apr 4, 2004
9,329
156
✟18,086.00
Faith
Christian
IN my experience, many churchgoers have had a wrong application of not judging. God is the Judge, Christianity does allow for judgment. sinners can't go around being a judge, especially if we are also sinners. I believe Jesus meant do not judge hypocritically. He does tell us in Matthew 18:15 about talking to people in sins. We need His wisdom about that.

The difference in Jesus and Muhammed is Jesus saves us from sin and Muhammed does not. Jesus is the One prophesied in Old Testament, especially see all of Isaiah chapter 53. He is our guilt offering to a Holy God who brings us peace with God. Not Muhammed. If she actually studies Islam out more, she will find they don't have assurance of heaven, it is "maybe if Allah lets you in on Judgment Day." There is no assurance in this lifetime according to them, from what I've read. Jesus gives people a promise of a way past Death and victory over sin, He also gives His Holy Spirit to us. Islam actually does say Jesus is a prophet, and talks about other Old testament prophets. If we look at Isaiah and Jesus, that is enough there to stop us from seeking Mohammed.

Only God can make your friend see. If she continues on claiming to be christian but walking in darkness, you will probably need to distance yourself. I encourage you to continue in bible readings, bible study daily. I also find bible on walkmen tapes very encouraging.
 
Upvote 0

Bornagain15

Waiting for His coming
Jun 10, 2005
2,961
20
Michigan
✟3,245.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Republican
I've never heard of anything about kings changing the Bible in 200 AD, especially considering that the Romans, who ruled at the time, considered Christianity a cult and systematically persecuted them! I doubt any rulers were Christians then. What she's probably referring to is the Council of Nicea, which had absolute standards for determining what was in the canon, for example: 1) it had to be written by an apostle or an immediate follower; 2) it had to be relevant and not just a repetition of another book; 3) it could not contradict any other Scripture, Old or New Testament; and there were other standards, too.

My advice is to get around her intellect and go after her conscience. Ask her if she thinks she's going to heaven and why. If she claims to be a good person, ask her if she's kept the Ten Commandments. And if she hasn't (and no one has), point that out. Go through them one by one; ask her if she's lied, stolen, blasphemed the name of God (that's the 9th, 7th, and 3rd commandments as an example), and let her know that the Bible says no liars, thieves, or blasphemers will enter God's kingdom. Then ask her if she's going to be innocent or guilty of breaking God's laws on the day of judgment. If she agrees that she is a sinner and deserving of hell, then present the cross to her--point out that Jesus died for her sins and took her punishment, not Muhammad. And pray that the Holy Spirit convicts her soul.
 
Upvote 0

ILikePeanutbutter

Christian Hardcore
Mar 8, 2006
384
28
37
Inside
✟15,659.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Single
26"When the Counselor comes, whom I will send to you from the Father, the Spirit of truth who goes out from the Father, he will testify about me. -John 15:26 Whitnessing is about having faith. You take a step of faith to talk about God, and then have faith that your words will make an impact on that person. Perhaps thats why its so hard to do: It requires a lot of faith.

I find that the more passion you have for Christ, the easier words come out when you need them. The better you understand Him, the better you explain Him to others.

Keeping a religious debate going in the right direction requires you to constantly go back to jesus. Instead of talking about which religion is right, try talking about Jesus.

The kings part in 200 AD she talks about is probably just a horribly butchered concept of the 1st Council of Nicea (actually in 325 AD). The version she talks about I think is what "The DaVinci Code" talks about, but im not sure because Ive never read it.


Anyways, it dosnt matter because we have (incomplete, but still real) copies of the gospels that were written well before the year 200 AD, and they are almost exacltly the same as our current ones. :) Our earliest fragments of the gospels are all dated before 100 AD.


Above all, you must take faith that God must change her heart. You cant do it. Pray before talking to her, and have faith.... thats the best you can do, aside from studying scripture.
 
Upvote 0

fenderbender

Active Member
Nov 18, 2006
105
7
68
✟7,760.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Hmmmm. She sounds ike a tough nut to crack. Try not to focus on the intellectual arguments too much. If you can, keep steering the conversation back to your personnal experiences and how the bible is still relevent for today's society.

As far as her comment about what Christians have done to non-christians over the years - maybe mention that there have been a lot of things done under the name of christianity that were definately not from God, the same as there are many today who are killing innocent people in the name of Islam (9/11 for example).

Above all pray. Be there for her. Be a friend. Don't come on too strong unless you have a very strong leading from God, or you'll turn her off.

There was some old christian guy from a long time ago said something wise. I'm not sure of the exact words but it goes something like this, "God has called us to go and preach the gospel to the lost. Sometimes (emphasis on "sometimes") we may have to use words."

In other words, let her see Christ in your life and your speaking block won't matter as much. Although Jesus did preach to the masses, he also befriended many sinners and won them over through the way He lived.

Praying for you and her . . . .
 
Upvote 0