David Cloud, Bill Gothard, Jack Chick, Jack Hyles, and Hyper-Fundamentalism

Have you heard the "teachings" of. . .

  • David Cloud?

  • Jack Hyles?

  • Jack Chick?

  • Bill Gothard?

  • Berit Kjos?

  • Peter Ruckman?

  • Other well-known legalists?


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Susan

退屈させた1 つ (bored one)
Feb 16, 2002
9,292
124
40
El Cajon, California, USA
Visit site
✟15,012.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Democrat
First let me say that I am a theological fundamentalist. That means that I believe in the "Five Fundamentals of the Christian Faith"

1: the Bible is the inspired and totally inerrant Word of God in the original manuscripts.

2: Jesus Christ is God, born of the virgin Mary.

3: Jesus died in my place for my sins (the Substitutional Atonement)

4: Jesus rose again from the grave literally and physically

5: Jesus is coming again.

However, I disagree with the legalism of the persons I mentioned in my subject line as well as their stances on many issues. :(

Could we begin a nice, polite, flame-free discussion about hyper-fundamentalist (Hyles, Chick, Cloud, Gothard, and others) legalism?

Thanks. . . :)
 

Susan

退屈させた1 つ (bored one)
Feb 16, 2002
9,292
124
40
El Cajon, California, USA
Visit site
✟15,012.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Democrat
As for me: I think the fear these people I mentioned instill and feed off of is enough good reason to stay away from them. They seem to be trembling in fear of sin, demons, and the world, when actually we have no reason to fear these things, for "Greater is He that is in you than he who is in the world."
I personally believe Christians should "overcome evil with good."

Also, I disagree with their going beyond the bounds of God's Word. The irony of this is that many of these people denounce Catholics for "going beyond the Word" or "laying burdens on people," while they themselves do the same thing. Or far worse. . . :(

For instance, Bill Gothard has gone so far to make his own "liturgy" for Sunday services, and regulates almost every detail of his followers' lives, even what they read, how they dress, and how they live as a family. He has also regulated that "true Christians" should have "bright eyes."

Berit Kjos warns that symbols have demonic power and that the mere presence of an evil symbol or item, even if absolutely unnoticed, attracts demons. The answer? Renunciations, prayers, and a frantic search for anything that serves as a "demonic focal point." Among those items are Cabbage Patch dolls, "Troll" dolls even if they aren't meant for religious purposes, Hello Kitty merchandise, and 100s of other things. Even crosses are considered suspect. . .

And so it goes. I personally don't see any verse in the Bible that requires us to conduct Sunday services any way but simply "decently and in order." I have yet to see a verse that says Cabbage Patch or Hello Kitty are idols (although they might be if one worships them, but even the KJV Bible has that potential capacity, as most of us have seen)
So what is your opinion on this? :)
 
Upvote 0

ZiSunka

It means 'yellow dog'
Jan 16, 2002
17,005
284
✟38,767.00
Faith
Christian
There is a certain kind of person that needs to be highly emotionally-charged all the time in order to feel important. They have to make others charged up in order to maintain their own emotional high, and will do whatever it takes to keep people in an uproar. It doesn't matter if the emotional charge is negative or positive, as long as it is high.

Some of the people on your list may suffer from this type of mental disorder.
 
Upvote 0

SpiritPsalmist

Heavy lean toward Messianic
Site Supporter
Jun 13, 2002
21,665
1,466
70
Southeast Kansas
✟393,824.00
Country
United States
Faith
Charismatic
Marital Status
Single
Hi, :wave:

Before I give my thoughts on this I want to say that I do not follow any of these men.  I've read only some of a couple of the men's material.

Now, I know that Jack Chick had a radical conversion, therefore, he walks a radical walk with a radical belief.  I do not agree with a lot of what he teaches, however, there is some stuff that is quite useful.  In the area of tracks I do use 1 of them.  It's geared for children and the heavy-hand is not there.

Gothard, I'm familiar with from about 25 -30 years ago.  I never went to one of his seminars but I heard many good things about them.  The people I knew that attended them were stirred to more holiness in their walk.  They saw that there were most definately areas in their life that needed changing.  They allowed God to change them.  Most christians that I run into today, seem to have no clue about walking in holiness.  The attitude seems to be "God loves me like I am", and while true, He loves you too much to let you stay the way you are.

People are people.  Some of them will go overboard on anything, no matter what it is.  I don't find myself in that catagory too often but when I've looked at what I believed as a Christian 30 years ago and what I believe now, there's been a lot of changing of mind. 

I can look back and remember when I said some of the most unbiblical things, thinking I was speaking for God, and yet now am a bit embarrassed over it. 

I'm thankful that those older than I did not jump all over me and tell me how wrong I was or they might have squelched the fire that God had lit.  They gently guided me toward what God really said and let the Holy Spirt do His job. 

When we arrive in Heaven, we are gonna see a lot of people we believe should not be there, but they will be.  God will individually judge each one of us and burn up all the things that He judges as chaff.

There is a whole lot to God that none of us has tapped into yet.  As time goes, He raises up differing individuals and births in them one subject in particular, He works that subject in them, and then He tells them to tell others.  Sometimes they tell it the wrong way, sometimes the listener is not hearing correctly.

We are not required by God to accept everything we hear a man or woman or child of God teach.  We can take what is beneficial to us and grow and then when the time is right, and if that is what God wants to do in you, then God will bring it up again.

I don't believe there is a person alive who has it all together in every area.  God is just too big.  All of our theologies are going to change when we see Him face to face.

Phil 2:12 (Amplified) Therefore, my dear ones, as you have always obeyed [my suggestions], so now, not only [with the enthusiasm you would show] in my presence but much more because I am absent, work out (cultivate, carry out to the goal, and fully complete) your own salvation with reverence and awe and <B>trembling</B> (self-distrust, [Marvin Vincent, Word Studies.] with serious caution, tenderness of conscience, watchfulness against temptation, timidly shrinking from whatever might offend God and discredit the name of Christ).&nbsp;&nbsp;
&nbsp;

&nbsp;

&nbsp;
 
Upvote 0

Susan

退屈させた1 つ (bored one)
Feb 16, 2002
9,292
124
40
El Cajon, California, USA
Visit site
✟15,012.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Democrat
Yes, some of their followers are *good* people. But is that any excuse for the mess they have created otherwise:
Nonbelivers who consider Christianity too good for them or merely an "old woman's religion"?
Christians who fear everything and live lives of an ascetic moralism that would make Simeon Stylites (the monk who lived on top of a pole for 20 years) proud, while simultaneously being so repellant to everyone else, Christian or nonbeliever, that the only friends they have are people who don't differ from them at any point?
Backslidden Christians who tried to be "perfect" and "play by the rules" but never could reach the goal, gave up because it was too hard to even keep trying, and are now liberal or so burned out on the faith that they don't care anymore?

I know from my own experience (11 years of homeschool teachings influenced by holiness legalists out of a homeschool curricula not connected to our church called "Accelerated Christian Education" or "School of Tomorrow," one year out of those years of being influenced by Bob Larson, Berit Kjos, and other "fear of demons" teachers) that the Christian walk is hard enough without extra hurdles being put into it.
Now that I'm finally out of school (my local book provider closed) I am finally beginning to see God as a loving Father, not, as I have seen Him for a good portion of my life as, Someone who is continually angry and can only be pleased through my doing more and being better. I am beginning to see Him as someone who made me as a unique individual, not merely as a girl who is supposed to live a life of quiet.
 
Upvote 0

SpiritPsalmist

Heavy lean toward Messianic
Site Supporter
Jun 13, 2002
21,665
1,466
70
Southeast Kansas
✟393,824.00
Country
United States
Faith
Charismatic
Marital Status
Single
Originally posted by Susan
Yes, some of their followers are *good* people. But is that any excuse for the mess they have created otherwise:
Nonbelivers who consider Christianity too good for them or merely an "old woman's religion"?
Christians who fear everything and live lives of an ascetic moralism that would make Simeon Stylites (the monk who lived on top of a pole for 20 years) proud, while simultaneously being so repellant to everyone else, Christian or nonbeliever, that the only friends they have are people who don't differ from them at any point?
Backslidden Christians who tried to be "perfect" and "play by the rules" but never could reach the goal, gave up because it was too hard to even keep trying, and are now liberal or so burned out on the faith that they don't care anymore?&nbsp;

&nbsp;

Susan,

I really do not&nbsp;mean to be offensive but we can apply that logic to everything that exists.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Some people take it too far no matter what it is.&nbsp;

I can use this site as an example.&nbsp; There is one person in particular that no matter what I say they say the opposite.&nbsp; I rephrase it&nbsp;in a variety of ways and&nbsp;even when I've said I agree with them, they argue and contradict me.&nbsp; This person is not comprehending clearly what is being said.&nbsp; But in their own opinion, they have it all perfectly together. With that person I've given up even trying.

I'm sorry that the&nbsp;things you learned in school caused you to believe things that may or may not be true.&nbsp; It is never Godly to live in fear of judgement or fear of the enemy.&nbsp; I'm sure your teacher never intended you to feel those things as a result of their teaching.&nbsp;

God has given us all the tools we need to overcome wherever it is we need to overcome.&nbsp; We cannot go through life blaming others for the way we have chosen to feel.&nbsp; I choose the way I feel.&nbsp; Others may say something that triggers an emotion. But it's me who chooses to dwell on that emotion and become depressed and fearful.&nbsp;

I remember watching a movie once where the main character was an abusive mother.&nbsp; Somewhere during the course of that movie something in me was triggered and without warning I began to sob.&nbsp; It characterized quite well some of what I experienced during my childhood and teen years.&nbsp; But to boycott the TV station for that emotion being stirred up was not the answer.&nbsp; It showed me that God still had some work to do.&nbsp; And, I choose not to watch those types of films anymore.&nbsp; Maybe someday, but not today.

Also, coming from a penticostal upbringing gave me other&nbsp;hurdles to jump.&nbsp;&nbsp;Clinging to God and not blaming Him was what got me through.&nbsp; However as we mature, just getting through is not spiritual maturity.

As I became an adult God told me that "the time for blaming other peoples actions/teachings were over.&nbsp; I was to take responsibility for my own feelings/actions/teachings and walk humbly before Him.&nbsp; Only then, could He&nbsp;heal me.&nbsp; I no longer could act that way because . . .or think/feel that way because . . .&nbsp; We are unhealable as long as we hold on to that thinking.&nbsp; Our thoughts and ways need to become as His thoughts and ways.&nbsp; This takes a lifetime.

Yes, there&nbsp;"may" be teaching&nbsp;that's incorrect, but God tells us to pray for our fellow brothers and sisters.&nbsp; None of us have it all together.&nbsp; We're all just trying to convey the portion that God has allowed us to understand maybe a little bit more than another.

For me, the best way I have found to pray is "God, that teaching does not set well with me.&nbsp; Please, show me where I need to change in my thinking or show that person what needs to change."&nbsp; Perhaps they just need to word it differently.&nbsp; Perhaps I just need to hear it differently.&nbsp; Even Jesus did not make statements that&nbsp;made everybody&nbsp;happy.&nbsp; What He said though was the Truth.&nbsp; It was not His fault that the hearer did not hear it right.&nbsp;&nbsp;

All each of us can do is walk with God according to what we understand.&nbsp; Paul wrote in Phil 2:12 (Amplified) "Therefore, my dear ones, as you have always obeyed my suggestions, so now, not only with the enthusiasm you would show in my presence but much more because I am absent, work out, (cultivate, carry out to the goal, and fully complete) your own salvation with reverence and awe and trembling (self-distrust, with serious caution, tenderness of conscience, watchfulness against temptation, timidly shrinking from whatever might offend God and discredit the name of Christ).

We are told to be gracious with one another (Colossians 3:12-17), we are told to think only good things about each other (Phil 4:8).&nbsp; Those are hard things to do but not impossible.&nbsp; It takes allowing God to change us.&nbsp; It's my understanding that we're all working towards that.

Anyway, I tend to be long winded.

God bless you, :angel:

&nbsp;

add: knowing that differing people can be heavy-handed on particular&nbsp;subjects is good for knowing where not to steer someone.&nbsp; Such as, I would never steer a&nbsp;Catholic toward&nbsp;Chick Publications, etc.&nbsp; But I have steered people looking for&nbsp;good tracks there.&nbsp; I warn them upfront to read it before buying because of&nbsp;Chicks heavy hand but he&nbsp;none the less does have a couple of really good one's.

&nbsp;
 
Upvote 0

Ms.Babylon

Woman Who Rides the Beast
Jun 5, 2002
113
9
Visit site
✟317.00
Faith
Catholic
I've only heard of Jack Chick. As a Catholic I have a very negative opinion of him.
Now that I'm finally out of school (my local book provider closed) I am finally beginning to see God as a loving Father, not, as I have seen Him for a good portion of my life as, Someone who is continually angry and can only be pleased through my doing more and being better. I am beginning to see Him as someone who made me as a unique individual, not merely as a girl who is supposed to live a life of quiet.
I like your last sentence. :)
 
Upvote 0

A Sheep

Stop the suffering in Iraq
Mar 10, 2002
3,492
1
✟6,046.00
I am finally beginning to see God as a loving Father, not, as I have seen Him for a good portion of my life as, Someone who is continually angry and can only be pleased through my doing more and being better. I am beginning to see Him as someone who made me as a unique individual, not merely as a girl who is supposed to live a life of quiet.

I am glad that you have realized these things. It is very helpful to be able to discern the truth and lies. You want to really try not to sin; but you also do not want to be a legalist. There is a fine line between the two sometimes.
 
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums

Gerry

Jesus Paid It All
May 1, 2002
8,301
17
Visit site
✟14,307.00
Truth without love leads to legalism. Love without truth leads to liberalism.

When these two are married and come together as ONE, they form an inpenetrable barrier to satan. When they are seperated they unlock the door and swing it wide open to him.

Truth and love must never be seperated in the life of a Christian. When they are, there are horrible consequences.
 
Upvote 0
Susan this is a great thread! :)

As for the hyper-fundies (they hate that term), I pity them. It is sad that they see evil in things like VeggieTales, christian music, wine at communion, etcetera. I am no liberal, and I am also a believer in the 5 fundamentals.

Anyone think of another person as a legalist?
 
Upvote 0

Susan

退屈させた1 つ (bored one)
Feb 16, 2002
9,292
124
40
El Cajon, California, USA
Visit site
✟15,012.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Democrat
Is it normative&nbsp;truth&nbsp;that:

The only legitimate Bible is the 1611 KJV?

The only music that is allowable is lullabies and hymns that sound like them?
(Although I don't like loud rock at all, I do like some gospel and some other Christian music that is a little more fast-paced than hymns, and I do wonder if it is OK to like secular classical/instrumental music-which I like also :confused: )

A family can't be ruled on the basis of the wife and husband discussing and agreeing on things, but must be a virtual absolute dictatorship by the "man of the house"?
(My family is like the former, a 50/50 partnership, and it worked relatively well, however my schoolwork implied that "proper" families are like the latter, the absolute dictatorship model.)

One cannot watch professional sports, do "work-resembling" hobbies, or whatever else you can think of as somehow "resembling work" on Sunday?

You must be sober, severe, and almost to the point of sour all the time?

(That is what turned me into a "perfect nerd." Over the last few years I got to the point of being afraid to do anything and looking down on anything "not serious" or somehow "unbecoming," and and I became known as the most pious person around. I believed that every choice, every action, everything was loaded with spiritual implication and danger.)

Any form of entertainment, especially those involving imagination on your part or written by non-Christians, is wrong for every Christian?

Pierced ears are a sign of a lack of spirituality?

Anyone who is attracted to members of a different race than their own is sinning?

You can't work with or be a friend of non-believers, but only preach at them from a safe distance, 20 miles should suffice?

You can never let on that you personally experience pain, sorrow, whatever, and that you are not immediately thankful for experiencing it?

Are all of these normative truth rules for Christian living? :confused:
 
Upvote 0

Susan

退屈させた1 つ (bored one)
Feb 16, 2002
9,292
124
40
El Cajon, California, USA
Visit site
✟15,012.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Democrat
BTW I am no liberal either. :) I guess you would call me practically moderate and theologically fundamentalist now in the sense that I don't keep the above-listed rules anymore, and that unless something is specifically or obviously implicitly forbidden in God's Word, it is a matter of personal conviction. :)
 
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums

Susan

退屈させた1 つ (bored one)
Feb 16, 2002
9,292
124
40
El Cajon, California, USA
Visit site
✟15,012.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Democrat
And sometimes legalism contains gross untruth.
More than a few times teachers like those I listed misrepresent or outright lie to back up their preconcieved notions or public statements. . .

Like Jack Chick and his Alberto whoever guy, the alleged priest, that turned out to be a world class fraud.

Like Berit Kjos and her claim that Deuteronomy 18 said that anime was another god and not even to listen to its influence. Look that chapter up for yourself, it doesn't refer to a drawing style at all. . .

Like Peter Ruckman who claims that all who do not agree with KJV Onlyism are trying to force the KJV out of Christian life.

Or Bill Gothard, who insists that intense legalism is not a part of his system and only due to overzealous followers.
 
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums

GreenEyedLady

My little Dinky Doo
Jan 15, 2002
2,641
167
Missouri
Visit site
✟4,791.00
Faith
Baptist
I hope I don't get all hard core on you all.
But the fact is the gospel is plain and simple. Jesus was born, died and rose from the dead and assended into heaven. This is the truth, the way and the light.
Why does it matter who says what about what doctrine? Let me ask you this.....when is the last time you went out and witnessed to your loved ones? When was the last time you talked about THE GOSPEL, Jesus Christ. Forget the doctrines, forget the debates. Can you NOT see that it gets you nowhere? We need to STOP anailazing and just obey what the bible says. How hard is that? How hard is it stop just obey as God commandes us to do? Things comming out of man's mouth seem sour, but do they have a point? Christ states in
Matthew 10:34 _Think not that I am come to send peace on earth: I came not to send peace, but a sword.

Why do many christians think that Jesus is here to send peace? To join together to be come one with the world? You don't like what you hear? Read it...somethimes we don't like what we hear, sometimes the bible is a mirror that shows our imperfections that we reject because we cannot stand what the bible says is true. Is the world sour? Of course it is!!! The world is NOT peace. What are you looking for? Some man that makes the world look all good and peaceful? The bible says the world is NOT to be loved. These men, maybe you don't like what you hear. Maybe you don't like what they have to say..but is it possible that these men ARE being lead by the Holy spirit to WAKE up those christian who are "sleeping" in the world?
Christ said I AM NOT HERE TO BRING PEACE!!!!
I may disagree with some of what these men have to say....but the truth hurts. The bible is being used as a sword to discern the spirits that are of this world.

Hebrews 5:14 _But strong meat belongeth to them that are of full age, even those who by reason of use have their senses exercised to discern both good and evil.

For the word of God is quick, and powerful, and sharper than any twoedged sword, piercing even to the dividing asunder of soul and spirit, and of the joints and marrow, and is a discerner of the thoughts and intents of the heart.
Hebrews 4:12

what are your thoughts and intents of YOUR heart? Why spend all day debating about what is right and wrong and start leading people to Christ? Will you feel shame as you stand efore the jundgement seat of Christ and look around and NOT se your loved ones standing with you? What will you say to your loved ones who ask you..."WHY didn't you try harder? Why did you keep this from me?"

Get your behinds out there are lead some people to Christ, teach them about the word of God, show them to obey God is to get baptised. They they will spead the message to others. What are you waiting for? Are you scared? Do you feel shame at a party because your NOT sure in they way others will react? This is satan whispering words of rejections to those who YOU think might NOT want to hear what you have to say. Do IT TELL THEM ABOUT salvation, tell them about the Word of God. Stop the debating and stop thinking and analizing and JUST OBEY whatthe Word of God says!

Sorry, I just feel convicted to write this. To Stop the debates. stop telling those YOU think are wrong and start with the TRUTH, which YOU KNOW is in Gods Word!
DO it....like the nike ad says "just do it" OBEY!
Loveyou all with all my soul and heart.
GEL
 
Upvote 0
Status
Not open for further replies.