An open apology

Status
Not open for further replies.

nyj

Goodbye, my puppy
Feb 5, 2002
20,966
1,303
USA
Visit site
✟39,238.00
Country
United States
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Private
It was King Charles the First who said, Never make a defence or apology before you be accused., and while that is not necessarily true of the Christian, especially in light of Matthew 5:22-26, the accusation has been leveled against me and should be addressed. Yes, it is true that I responded in a less-than-Christian way, and yes it is true that I gave scandal not only to myself, but to this forum and to the faith I claim to represent. Regardless of whether or not I reacted to personal slights against my person (be they real or merely perceived), the manner in which I responded was uncalled for, it was unsuitable. I therefore issue an apology to those I directly targeted by my words, particularly Vow and Belle, and I issue a further apology to those I indirectly offended by my vitriol. For my actions, I am truly sorry.
 

VOW

Moderator
Feb 7, 2002
6,912
15
71
*displaced* CA, soon to be AZ!
Visit site
✟28,000.00
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Married
To NYJ:

After reading one of your responses to me, I think I finally understood where your forcefulness originated from. I have known couples who have struggled with infertility, and seen the deep, degradating pain it has caused them. When someone says or does something that pokes in a personal pain, I often react with a knee-jerk. And I have seen how the topic of abortion affects the people who desperately want children but have not been blessed.

My responses were never intended to inflict that type of pain upon you, and I deeply regret it if they have.

On the other side of the same coin, *I* reacted with the same type of knee-jerk reaction as well.

You see, NYJ, I had a third-grade child who experienced an unbelievable emotional breakdown, and he had to be hospitalized in a psychiatric facility. Now, his problem was NOT related to rape/pregnancy/abortion in any way. My son has ADD (Attention Deficit Disorder), an illness which is often genetic in origin. My husband's side of the family is peppered with relatives who have suffered from this disorder in many shapes, sizes, and forms. In fact, it is because of the family history that my husband and I got our son in treatment when he was only in Kindergarten. Some people, including the schoolteachers, thought we were over-reacting. However, they hadn't seen the destructiveness of this first-hand.

ADD is sort of like diabetes. You never CURE it, you can only hope to control it. It's also a life-long problem. If you are fortunate, you learn coping skills. Medication can help. In my son's case, medication made a DRAMATIC improvement. It's not a magic cure-all, though. And for my son, the medication would become ineffective and he'd have to change to something different, to give his body a rest.

When he was in third grade, he was changed from his normal medication to Ritalin. Most children do quite well on Ritalin. In my son's case, it made him violent. He attacked another child on the playground, grabbed the kid by the throat. We immediately took him to his doctor. When questioned, my son admitted that he was filled with uncontrollable rage, that he wanted to do harm to others, and harm to himself.

The doctor said he had to be hospitalized immediately.

We're talking about a third grade child! Eight years old!

And at that time, in that very desperate, vulnerable, painful time, we were assaulted with the reality of the US healthcare system. Guess what, folks? Mental health coverage of most insurances STINKS. Get out your policies, get out the coverage booklets, take a LOOK at what you get when you are in desperate need.

Instead of allowing my son to be hospitalized at a facility where his doctor was on staff, the health plan said we had to go to the next county, to a place we had never seen, and turn the care of our precious child over to people we didn't know.

If your child needs open-heart surgery, or chemotherapy, or some drastic medical treatment, the hospitals open their doors to the family, they put out the welcome mat. Mom and/or Dad are permitted to stay with the child, often in a bed provided by the hospital. You can't go into the operating room, but you are allowed to stay with your child almost constantly.

In a psychiatric hospital, you set the suitcase down on the floor, sign the papers, and then kiss your child goodbye.

Visiting hours are extremely restricted.

My BABY was hurting, in desperate pain, and I had to ABANDON him!

He was there for two weeks, the longest two weeks of my life.

I'm sorry this is so long, such babbling. But now you know why I would consider almost anything in this world to protect my child from emotional distress.

I do apologize to you, NYJ. And to everyone else here.



Peace be with you,
~VOW
 
Upvote 0

seebs

God Made Me A Skeptic
Apr 9, 2002
31,914
1,529
18
Saint Paul, MN
Visit site
✟55,225.00
Faith
Seeker
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
I almost certainly owe at least *someone* an apology... but I'd also like to point out that, while both of you seemed pretty angry, well, there's a *reason* that abortion is a hot-button issue; somewhere on the spectrum from "I dunno, a few months ago I wanted to carry it to term, but I was thinking of going to Europe this summer, so I'll just try again later" to "this baby has no lungs, and if it isn't aborted, the mother will die", most people draw a line... but not everyone agrees on exactly *where* to draw that line. Some people might not even at those edges; some people draw it fairly firmly, and others fairly vaguely.

I only know a couple of people who have gotten abortions, so I can't really generalize. There are circumstances under which I must admit to having no better suggestions. :(

It's a tough moral issue, and while I may believe that some people have made the wrong choice, I don't believe it's clear or obvious enough that I have any grounds for assuming they did not sincerely consider the issue, and do their best.

In the end, God knows what the real limits are, and we don't. All the "don't kill" rules in the world would be unlikely to stand between me and someone who appeared to be sincerely trying to harm my family... and in some cases, I think that *is* what God wants us to do; I sometimes suspect that His law is a lot less concerned with which verbs describe your actions, and a lot more concerned with how you choose when the chips are down.
 
Upvote 0
VOW-

I understand what you go through with the sick child. I should know, since I suffered with mental illness from my earliest memories, and still do.

Your desire to protect your child is noble beyond words. Sometimes that desire can manifest in other ways, as we saw here. At least you realized it...how many can't or won't.

Congrats. :)
 
Upvote 0
Status
Not open for further replies.