HRV at the printers.

WOW! After 45 years I finally made cheerleader! ( Not that I ever even considered that even in HS ) but thanks for the vote!

This is the only one I cheer for though --------------> Praise the L-rd

Simchat stated:

There's nothing proven, as in documents that denounce the St. John Chrysostom Theological Seminary as a legitimate school.

HT:

The website that was "defending" James Trimm's credentials dissapeared off the face of the earth once it was exposed by the two researchers whose links I posted earlier.Is that your definition of "legitimate"?


Simchat:

Funny thing about that... not a single person has stepped forward to make charges of plagerism. Not one.

HT:

Did you not read the link I posted? The Lebtahor site has made those very charges. Below is a note from researcher Kathryn Kern. The links to her site were in the earlier posts:

http://www.lebtahor.com/truth/trimm/plagiarisms/hrvpage.htm


From:* Kathryn <research@m...>
Date:* Tue*Oct*28,*2003* 5:47 pm
Subject:* "donations"


Shalom b'YHWH
I noticed that Trimm is again seeking donations for another publication. I just received another email from a disgruntled "donor".


"I thought you may like to know that I have placed a complaint with the Texas Attorney general office. Last June I ordered some teaching tapes from Trimm that a few of us had clubbed together for. We were required to give an 'appreciation gift' of $60 and pay $15 postage. They have never arrived, nearly all emails have been ignored and requests for refunds have been ignored too. A friend ordered a book from him which never arrived, her request for a refund was turned down on the basis that it was a 'donation'."

This is a reoccurring complaint that I have been receiving emails about. I personally find it sad that this man can solicit "donations" in this manner and not follow through with the product offered. Where is the accountability? Personally, I feel that those robbed are better off than having received the product, but better still would be to have never fallen into the trap at all.

Kathryn


HT:

As far as your "rabbit trails" terminology, this thread is about the hrv, and I am on topic.No "hijacking" here, only discussion. Nice try though

BS'D

Now, as far as Trimm's night on Paltalk with the "Messiah Truth" people... I haven't seen anything yet. A single Rebbe there has claimed that Trimm does not have a very profound level of hebraic knowledge, but I have not seen any quotes to verify these claims. In fact, this Rebbe goes in cirlces when describing Trimm's paltalk visit. First he says that Trimm has no working knowledge of Hebrew, then he says that Trimm does in fact support his claims with numerous citations, etc etc etc... The Rebbe does not clearly state what happened that night in Paltalk, and he did not present the text either.

Click to expand...

My meeting with him was a seprate issue. His incident with Dr. Yosef in the Messianic Q n A room was more of a challenge by MT to the Mezzies. I just happened to be introduced to him in a Israel chat- a mutal friend introduced us and mentioned his education.

Only later did I really find out what he was all about and the reputation he has earned around the world. To be honest, he isn't really on my radar unlike some others.

I never accused you of hijacking this particular thread... just that it is your common practice.


Everything else really doesn't demand a comment at this point.

*sighs*

And yet again, you avoid the question of 'messianic' posed to you.

That's ok. I won't press the issue.

Here's one you might need Yafet

Simchat:

And yet again, you avoid the question of 'messianic' posed to you.

HT:

It is obvious by the widely varying differences between your and my opinions, that I could not agree with your opinion of messianic. Why do you and others always fall back on this approach when you have no answer? Remember, without a little "sand" no oysters would produce pearls. Think about it

But you can't play in this sandbox if you aren't an oyster Debating in this forum is for "oysters" only, but really shouldn't that be something that is Kosher?

SW:

But you can't play in this sandbox if you aren't an oyster Debating in this forum is for "oysters" only, but really shouldn't that be something that is Kosher?

HT:
SInce this forum is titled "Messianic Judaism", and by your own admission you are not Jewish, what then would it make you?

P.S. I think we need to go to the bloodtest.

By the rules of this forum I am considered a full member. And as far as blood tests? Some don't wear them on their sleeves.


I may not know what runs through my veins as of yet but I do know whose blood I am covered under.

SW wrote:

By the rules of this forum I am considered a full member.

HT:
According to this rule:

4) No posts that denigrate a Christian denomination or Christian group including Protestant or Catholic denominations will be tolerated - these will be deleted and the poster will be warned.

You, Simchat and many others would be getting warnings, and stuff would be getting deleted, but it doesn't happen. Threads like this one:

http://www.christianforums.com/t51665&page=1&highlight=cross [nice klan pic ]

SW:

I may not know what runs through my veins as of yet but I do know whose blood I am covered under.

HT:

The same blood that the Christians are covered under, who you and others on this forum show disdain for.

If you want to cite the rules, then you should abide by them, and stop insulting our Christian brothers and sisters, of which you were once one.......okay, back on topic.

Higher Truth said:

SW wrote:

By the rules of this forum I am considered a full member.

HT:
According to this rule:

4) No posts that denigrate a Christian denomination or Christian group including Protestant or Catholic denominations will be tolerated - these will be deleted and the poster will be warned.

You, Simchat and many others would be getting warnings, and stuff would be getting deleted, but it doesn't happen. Threads like this one:

http://www.christianforums.com/t51665&page=1&highlight=cross [nice klan pic ]

If you want to cite the rules, then you should abide by them, and stop insulting our Christian brothers and sisters, of which you were once one....okay...back on topic.

Click to expand...

I saw nothing wrong with that thread. It was an honest discussion of using the cross as a symbol, no rules were violated. If you think a rule is violated, feel free to report the post in question.

Bloodlines are not a question in Messianic Judaism section... go see the newly added to FAQ.

and btw, discussing a symbol used is not deginerate to a particluar group. And the way I interpreted the rules, one may not demean another christian group in that particular section.... but can only speak against it within the IDD forums. However, in the protestant forum, for example, Catholics will take offense to things said there... it's just the nature of denominations.

So is the hrv a real "translation" based on valid credentials and real scholarship?

http://www.lebtahor.com/truth/trimm/yeshiva/sainthohn/saintjohnpage.htm

http://www.lebtahor.com/truth/trimm/plagiarisms/mark.htm

So is the hrv a real "translation" based on valid credentials and real scholarship?

Click to expand...

It absolutely cannot be any worse than the corrupted KJV and all of it's offspring.

Thats a fact.

Trolling?

It was simply a link rebutting slanderous claims by some.

Thats what I got out of it anyway...