I think the unrepentant sinner who was approached in love by the church, would not return to that church. He would find a church who didnt care about his unrepentive, sinful behavior. That would be easy to find.
MY church split from the national denomination "Disciples of Christ" a couple of years ago because they no longer considered homosexuality a sin, & rewrote their national creed. There is no need for repentance in a church which ignores & condones sexual sin. So an unrepentive sinner would be more comfortable with that denomination.
Besides, many Christians today do not believe in repentance or judging sins, of their particular church members at all. Others believe in forgiving every sin of their pastor. In December, Robert Lairdon, nationally known pastor, confessed to his congregation that he was having a homosexual affair with his church's male youth minister. He is to be back at the pulpit this month after 4 months of counseling. Charisma magazine reported only 1/5 th of his congregation left, while the others stated, "We wouldnt be Christians if we didnt forgive him".
I am of the opinion that we are all the body of Christ, but we are only to judge those within our own particular church, seek their repentance, break fellowship, etc.
I can see what type of church it could become if unrepentive, active sinning was condoned. It would not be a good enviroment for the youth who were old enough to notice. The pastor & youth minister would not be immune from the immoral approval.
Thank you all for some very intelligent conversation on the matter. All scripture mentioned being true, it is apparent that we become a partner in hypocrisy if we condone every active unrepentive sin within our church members. It is the outside world we are not to judge.
Christi, not a problem here, but thanks for the apology anyway. I knew that you & some others were reading more meaning into my posts than I had intended, easy to do. I understand.