Recent content by Joyousperson

JosephZ, Here is one point supporting my point of contempt from within the Quran by the translator of Ishaq's Sira, However the apostle continued to proclaim what God has ordered him to proclaim, concealing nothing, and exciting the dislike by contemning [express contempt] their religion...

Setst777 Great points again. JosephZ quoted above' ...The apostle, by the orders of Allah, continued patiently, confidently, and lovingly to preach to his people, despite their accusations of falsehood, their insults, and their mockeries. https://kalamullah.com/Books/The History Of...

Very good and right on target. Re numbers before migrating to Medina, Warner mentioned 120, not sure where he got his numbers. Ishaq Sira [166] mentioned "in large numbers .." I read in the Sira of Ishaq, Muhammad was commanded to preach after THREE years of receiving the revelations. Muhammad...

Note this from Ishaq 166. When the apostle openly displayed Islam as God ordered him his people did not withdraw or turn against him, so far as I have heard, until he [Muhammad] spoke disparagingly of their gods. When he did that they took great offence and resolved unanimously to treat him as...

JosephZ wrote: Robert Spencer fails to mention any of this in his book. Note this video at 4:48 of Ali, Robert Spencer did not mention he is quoting from Ibn Ishad or the others. He stated 'Legend has it ...." because the main purpose of his book is about the history and event of jihad [holy...

There is no excuse for the above. There are many ways of communicating opposing and unfavorable views to others without offending the other party. Note this

JosephZ, You keep condemning Robert Spencer and David Wood's view without proving any argument of substance. Here is an opportunity for you to highlight where they are wrong from this debate between Robert Spencer & David Wood versus Ebady & Hussain. Show where are they wrong in using the...

What Setst stated in quoted "..." earlier is true and anyone can read the full passage in the Sira which Setst777 reproduced in total. It is stated "until they came to blows" but no mentioned who started to be physical first. But was is sure is, Sa'd drew the first blood to be shed in Islam...

Here is an interesting debate between Robert Spencer and David Wood facing Shia scholars Shaykh Sakhawat Hussain and Sayyid Atiq Ebady. I noted Robert Spencer and David Wood are both very objective in relying their arguments based on the authentic sources of Islam, i.e. the Quran, Ahadith...

How can you be so ignorant of human history including anthropology and psychology in this case. Didn't you read the latest on what happened to the Christian missionary, John Chau, in North Sentinel Island of the Andaman group of islands; The life and death of John Chau, the man who tried to...

Yet, Ali failed to understand the intended purpose of Spencer's book. Note I gave you a youtube linked where he stated the main reason for the book, i.e. to describe the whole history jihad [holy war] of Islam's 1400 history. Because the book is not about 'what is jihad' Spencer merely provided...

I am not a Muslim - see my profile on the left of my post. I think you inferred 'sound like you are a Muslim' from the first line, "Note: DO NOT BLAME MUSLIMS!" I have edited the OP and added 'but critique the evil and violent elements of the ideology of Islam. The point is, for all the...

Which atheist textbook? Note my argument here; Who is a Christian? The above definition of 'who is Christian' will prevent Christianity from being accused as a violent religion in relation to the terrible violent elements in the OT and NT. What are the disadvantages, negative or limitation to...

JosephZ Here is another video from Robert Spencer which is specific to jihad. You have condemned Robert Spencer like a fraud, show me where he is wrong in quoting the Quran in the video below? Robert Spencer: The Theological Aspects of Islam That Lead to Jihad I believe Spencer could still...

Note this point from Robert Spencer on being accused to taking verses out of context; In the video @12:28 Spencer stated; A lot of people by the fact of my quoting them [verses] has said "..you are quoting these [verses] out of context" Spencer responded: 'I am not claiming to be giving you...