Is holding that same level of disagreement with equal civil rights hateful and bigoted? (hint - Yes, yes it is)
You’re still creating a false analogy. Racism and the colour of a person’s skin is not the same a same sex marriage. For one there is no Christian belief against race. In fact the Bible states that all people are equal IE
Galatians 3:28: “There is no longer Jew or Greek, there is no longer slave or free, there is no longer male and female; for all of you are one in Christ Jesus”
Saying there is no longer Jew or Gentile is saying there is no longer black or white. It is saying that all races are equal in Christ.
But marriage being the union between man and women is clearly stated in the Bible as a Christian belief.
Matthew 19:4-6 - He answered, “Have you not read that he who created them from the beginning made them male and female, and said, ‘Therefore a man shall leave his father and his mother and hold fast to his wife, and the two shall become one flesh’? So they are no longer two but one flesh. What therefore God has joined together let not man separate.”
People have the right to hate minorities, and many exercise that right. Exercising that right doesn't make it good or ethical.
But as I said disagreeing with same sex marriage is not being hateful. Its a right that people have in expressing their view about their belief about what marriage is. That belief is based on the Bible and has been around for thousands of years. As a society we cannot start denying cultures and religions their right to belief otherwise we become like China a communist and totalitarian nation.
what is the motivation of that "simple truth claim"?
There is no motivation. Scientific facts have no feelings or motives. They are just facts. Its a biological fact that a man cannot magically become a women. They have different sex organs, DNA, and hormones. Its a scientific fact that a man cannot become a mother and a child needs a mother.
So when someone takes the positio that based on the facts you cannot substitute a man for a women this is a truth according to the scientific facts and why they may be against same sex marriage. They have a right to express this as it is science and we as a society have always looked to science to tell us what reality is. But what is happening is some want to disregard the science and replace it with subjective feelings and thinking as being what creates reality. Some think this is incoherent.
what makes something like racism a legitimate opposing view.
No one is talking about racism. Once again you’re introducing a red herring, something I haven’t mentioned and has nothing to do with marriage and gender. I am saying it’s legitimate in todatys society to disagree with same sex marriage and that a man cannot magically become a women. Its just aprt of the diverse views in society that people have. So long as no one incites violence there is no law against it. Otherwise like I said we risk becoming a totalitarian nation like China where we dictate to everyone what they can and cannot believe and think.
Yes truth claims based on the evidence above.
and they get to face the consequences of their choice to publicly engage in that expression
But they should not face any consequences as they are doing nothing wrong. Anyone who tries to make any consequences are the ones doing something wrong. You have got things back the front. Expressing a view opposed to same sex marriage is legal and a right to do under Human Rights, freedom of speech and the right to hold and express religious belief so long as it does not incite violence.
civil rights are not based popularity
You are still introding a false comparison. We are talking about people’s views and beliefs on marriage. Belief about marriage has nothing to do with civil rights. No Christian is stopping a same sex couple from having the right to marry under a civil union under secular law. They are objecting to people trying to change the meaning of traditional marriage between a man and women which has been the meaning of marriage in society for 100's of years based on Christian beliefs.
Racists would disagree but its a moot point as religion doesn't grant anyone the right to discriminate
Well it is a moot point because racist cannot dictate Christian belief. Christian belief is based on the Biblical and not personal opinion. But you are right in saying that Christianity doesnt allow anyone to descriminate because it is clearly against Christian beliefs.
and they get to face the consequences of exercising their free speech. If that speech is hateful then they should expect to be confronted with that fact.
But people’s views on same sex marriage and gender (a man cannot become a women) are not hate speech. So they should not face any consequences. And yet they do from radical ideologues who want to silence free speech.
Just like people have long held beliefs about racial equality that have nothing to do with hating the individual.
So therefore you agree. People have the right to their beliefs regardless of what others think so long as it doesn’t insight violence.
same was said about those opposing interracial marriage
you keep introducing a Red Herring argument, interracial marriage has nothing to do with same sex marriage because the issue is about marriage being between a man and women which is about a belief based on Biblical scripture. There is no Biblical scripture about interracial marriage.