Work IS evil. My friendliness was shrugged off in a misunderstanding.

Oct 15, 2011
430
4
✟8,086.00
Faith
Christian
I am a junior manager in my team and have an important role in the training, development and coordination aspects of my direct team.

Within my team, we are all good friends and we often plan things outside work as well, from trips out of town to museum or theater visits. And the overall company culture is very informal.

A more senior employee from a different team (we have hung out with her as well, though less often) wrote me an e-mail asking for information which one of my newest recruits knew about.
Now, this senior employee and my new recruit have something very noticeable in common, e.g. like being the only two in the company from a certain town (I am slightly changing the true story for privacy reasons, but it should have the same message).

I replied to both in CC, mentioning, in a completely neutral and intention-less manner "...for more information you can from now on rely on your fellow townswoman."

The senior employee replied that all was fine, and at the end of the her e-mail she wrote a P.S.: "You don't say fellow townswoman. That's wrong English. You say fellow citizen."

I double-checked an online dictionary, and replied to her a quoted a passage with the definition for "townswoman", showing that it was not wrong English.

Again, she replied:"Townswoman is incorrect English."

I thought she didn't rely on my source, or that she didn't read properly, so I checked another dictionary and sent her that definition as well.
I always put nice smileys :) in my messages.

The senior employee replied:"Is this some sort of joke? I don't find this funny, and have other things to worry about."

My new recruit seemed a bit nervous at that point. And I was upset, too, because I didn't even fully grasp what was going on.
I later explained the story to other colleagues to ask for advice and they all blamed me for "provoking" her, for trying to be a "know-it-all" and for "not stopping".

I am incredibly upset and feel wronged by this situation, especially because I truly had only innocent intentions, and hadn't even THOUGHT about provocation or showing knowledge. I REALLY REALLY REALLY still cannot understand what was wrong about what I did!

The only explanation I have: work makes people misunderstand such tiny things and drives them crazy.

Yet, I currently feel very alone as I cannot force myself to admit a fault that I don't even fully understand why it is mine.
 

Pal Handy

Irregular Member
Jun 15, 2011
3,796
228
Southeast Michigan
✟20,508.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
It's all about You, Jesus
And all this is for You
For Your glory and your fame
It's not about me
As if You should do things my way
You alone are God
And I surrender to your ways

Jesus, lover of my soul
All consuming fire is in Your gaze
Jesus, I want you to know
I will follow you all my days
For no one else in history is like you
And history itself belongs to you
Alpha and Omega, You have loved me
And I will share eternity with You
 
Upvote 0
Oct 15, 2011
430
4
✟8,086.00
Faith
Christian
It's all about You, Jesus
And all this is for You
For Your glory and your fame
It's not about me
As if You should do things my way
You alone are God
And I surrender to your ways

Jesus, lover of my soul
All consuming fire is in Your gaze
Jesus, I want you to know
I will follow you all my days
For no one else in history is like you
And history itself belongs to you
Alpha and Omega, You have loved me
And I will share eternity with You

WHAT HAS THIS GOT TO DO WITH MY QUESTION?!?!?!?!??!!?!?

OFF TOPIC!!!!!
 
Upvote 0

Dragnog

Junior Member
Jul 10, 2006
259
11
✟15,466.00
Faith
Anglican
Marital Status
Married
I am a junior manager in my team and have an important role in the training, development and coordination aspects of my direct team.

Within my team, we are all good friends and we often plan things outside work as well, from trips out of town to museum or theater visits. And the overall company culture is very informal.

A more senior employee from a different team (we have hung out with her as well, though less often) wrote me an e-mail asking for information which one of my newest recruits knew about.
Now, this senior employee and my new recruit have something very noticeable in common, e.g. like being the only two in the company from a certain town (I am slightly changing the true story for privacy reasons, but it should have the same message).
I replied to both in CC, mentioning, in a completely neutral and intention-less manner "...for more information you can from now on rely on your fellow townswoman."

The senior employee replied that all was fine, and at the end of the her e-mail she wrote a P.S.: "You don't say fellow townswoman. That's wrong English. You say fellow citizen."

I double-checked an online dictionary, and replied to her a quoted a passage with the definition for "townswoman", showing that it was not wrong English.

Again, she replied:"Townswoman is incorrect English."

I thought she didn't rely on my source, or that she didn't read properly, so I checked another dictionary and sent her that definition as well.
I always put nice smileys :) in my messages.

The senior employee replied:"Is this some sort of joke? I don't find this funny, and have other things to worry about."

My new recruit seemed a bit nervous at that point. And I was upset, too, because I didn't even fully grasp what was going on.
I later explained the story to other colleagues to ask for advice and they all blamed me for "provoking" her, for trying to be a "know-it-all" and for "not stopping".

I am incredibly upset and feel wronged by this situation, especially because I truly had only innocent intentions, and hadn't even THOUGHT about provocation or showing knowledge. I REALLY REALLY REALLY still cannot understand what was wrong about what I did!

The only explanation I have: work makes people misunderstand such tiny things and drives them crazy.

Yet, I currently feel very alone as I cannot force myself to admit a fault that I don't even fully understand why it is mine.
I am sorry you are having a hard time at work.
Could you please clarify what was the question you wanted answered?
If you wanted to know what you did wrong - you pricked another persons pride.
Things have a way of escalating very quickly and the smallest thing can cause strife. Such as the reply you gave to Pal Handy who I assume was trying to cheer you up. Emails are always a difficult medium and she may have totally misunderstood your meaning. We are called to bring peace to a broken world even if it means sacrificing our pride. If I was you I would apologize to the senior employee and also to Pal Handy.
 
Upvote 0
Oct 15, 2011
430
4
✟8,086.00
Faith
Christian
Okay, I'm going to answer from a linguistics perspective here. So she said that fellow townswoman is wrong English (or whatever word it really was). And you say that it is not wrong.

Now there are two types of grammar: prescriptive grammars and descriptive grammars. You are both trying to follow a prescriptive grammar to know what is right or wrong which doesn't mean anything as there are tons of problems with this. For instance: "traditional grammar is often inaccurate and subjective, and tends to ignore actual usage. It ignores the fact that a living language is constantly in flux, and it tries to preserve features and distinctions that have long since fallen by the way..."

So basically, it doesn't matter what word you use as long as it as an arbitrary meaning. If the word "koluwotabatotulama" was a synonym of citizen or townswoman, you could use it too without any problem. So why would "townswoman" be wrong English? That is purely subjective. Also, I find that people who try to follow prescriptive grammars are not very open-minded and want everyone to follow their own little rules. That's probably why she got upset since you showed her that it is not "wrong English" even in a prescriptive way. She might have thought that you were trying to show that you're more knowledgeable because that's what she does herself. That is only a hypothesis though!

However, you are wrong too because you're also basing your opinion on a traditional grammar. My advice: let it go, don't follow prescriptive grammar too much and if someone talks about "wrong English" either a) avoid talking about it or b) tell them the flaws of their logic.

The whole grammar thing was just a parallel example of what we actually wrote via e-mail, the original of which I cannot write here for privacy reasons, personal and company, of course...

In essence, what happened is that she tried to correct something I said (which wasn't even entirely work-related), which I am 100% sure was already correct, and I used official reference to back up what I said, whereas she ultimately reacted saying "I have no time for this stuff". Then why correct me in the first place?

I am planning on telling about this to someone more senior, perhaps even the CEO, as I consider this kind of culture demeaning and arrogant.
 
Upvote 0
A

All4HISglory

Guest
Dragnog said:
I am sorry you are having a hard time at work.
Could you please clarify what was the question you wanted answered?
If you wanted to know what you did wrong - you pricked another persons pride.
Things have a way of escalating very quickly and the smallest thing can cause strife. Such as the reply you gave to Pal Handy who I assume was trying to cheer you up. Emails are always a difficult medium and she may have totally misunderstood your meaning. We are called to bring peace to a broken world even if it means sacrificing our pride. If I was you I would apologize to the senior employee and also to Pal Handy.

I agree!

~For Your glory Lord {iPad}
 
Upvote 0
A

All4HISglory

Guest
I completed an online training course offered through my company from the business school of Harvard. One of the courses had a section on email etiquette. A key point that was made in the training was to not go back and forth through email if your point or idea is not fully understood in the first few emails.

As you already know, tone and context is not always easily conveyed electronically. Regardless of if you were right or wrong, the best thing to do is to take the conversation off email and bring it face to face or by phone to avoid misunderstandings. (Although you can't redo it, you can try it in the future).

In addition, some things are trivial and shouldn't be brought to the level of a CEO. That may work against you in this case because your concern (although is valid to you) comes down to being a misunderstanding of grammatical use. As a professional, you should be able to categorize what is of true importance and what can be let go. If this other person begins to treat you different, then there is a problem worth addressing to the next level.

But in all things, pray about it and let God lead you. Don't act out of hurt feelings or pride.

BTW, I'm not trying to deny your feelings or your point of view. I'm sorry that you have experienced this and it's upsetting you.

~For Your glory Lord {iPad}
 
Upvote 0
A

All4HISglory

Guest
Lenguastica said:
Okay, I'm going to answer from a linguistics perspective here. So she said that fellow townswoman is wrong English (or whatever word it really was). And you say that it is not wrong.

Now there are two types of grammar: prescriptive grammars and descriptive grammars. You are both trying to follow a prescriptive grammar to know what is right or wrong which doesn't mean anything as there are tons of problems with this. For instance: "traditional grammar is often inaccurate and subjective, and tends to ignore actual usage. It ignores the fact that a living language is constantly in flux, and it tries to preserve features and distinctions that have long since fallen by the way..."

So basically, it doesn't matter what word you use as long as it as an arbitrary meaning. If the word "koluwotabatotulama" was a synonym of citizen or townswoman, you could use it too without any problem. So why would "townswoman" be wrong English? That is purely subjective. Also, I find that people who try to follow prescriptive grammars are not very open-minded and want everyone to follow their own little rules. That's probably why she got upset since you showed her that it is not "wrong English" even in a prescriptive way. She might have thought that you were trying to show that you're more knowledgeable because that's what she does herself. That is only a hypothesis though!

However, you are wrong too because you're also basing your opinion on a traditional grammar. My advice: let it go, don't follow prescriptive grammar too much and if someone talks about "wrong English" either a) avoid talking about it or b) tell them the flaws of their logic.

Great advice!

~For Your glory Lord {iPad}
 
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums

joey_downunder

big sister
Apr 25, 2009
3,064
152
Land Down Under
✟12,875.00
Faith
Baptist
Marital Status
Married
I .....
I replied to both in CC, mentioning, in a completely neutral and intention-less manner "...for more information you can from now on rely on your fellow townswoman."...

Notice the word in red - why didn't you use a gender-neutral term? :doh:

I can understand why there was some friction! Political correctness is a necessary evil especially within the workplace these days. Look at gender-neutral section half-way down.
 
Upvote 0

BFine

Seed Planter
Jul 19, 2011
7,293
658
My room
✟11,098.00
Faith
Calvary Chapel
Marital Status
Married
Just another person who picks the wrong thing to be overly sensitive about--
next time just use the person's name.

For example:
a person who is overweight can talk about themselves being
fat but if anyone calls that person fat-- there's going to be a major fuss and
talk about suing etc....
 
Upvote 0

turkle

Blessed
Jan 25, 2004
907
629
✟224,007.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
From what I can see, this was all about how you felt the need to insist that you were right and she was wrong. Why was that so important? You are not going to gain good relationships if you beat something like this to death with resource after resource. She made a fleeting comment to you, and you turned a molehill into a mountain. She got understandably annoyed. Then you talked to other people who agreed that this is a non issue. And now you are calling work evil as a result.

Honestly, this kind of thing needs to be dropped right away. You don't have to be right all the time. People can disagree. That is not evil. It is part of learning how to have good relationships with others. Obsessing over who is right over something trivial will only destroy relationships, and that is on you. Who is right in this case is simply not important.

I strongly advise against taking this triviality to the CEO. I can almost guarantee that his or her opinion of you will be diminished if you do. The CEO does not have time for this kind of silliness.

I'm sorry that you're having such a hard time with this, but you will have many more to come. I think that you really need to think about what is really important and what is not, and when to let go. That is a sign of maturity, and will also give you a lot more peace.
 
Upvote 0

back2thebible

Active Member
Oct 7, 2012
228
10
✟422.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
I am a junior manager in my team and have an important role in the training, development and coordination aspects of my direct team.

Within my team, we are all good friends and we often plan things outside work as well, from trips out of town to museum or theater visits. And the overall company culture is very informal.

A more senior employee from a different team (we have hung out with her as well, though less often) wrote me an e-mail asking for information which one of my newest recruits knew about.
Now, this senior employee and my new recruit have something very noticeable in common, e.g. like being the only two in the company from a certain town (I am slightly changing the true story for privacy reasons, but it should have the same message).

I replied to both in CC, mentioning, in a completely neutral and intention-less manner "...for more information you can from now on rely on your fellow townswoman."

The senior employee replied that all was fine, and at the end of the her e-mail she wrote a P.S.: "You don't say fellow townswoman. That's wrong English. You say fellow citizen."

I double-checked an online dictionary, and replied to her a quoted a passage with the definition for "townswoman", showing that it was not wrong English.

Again, she replied:"Townswoman is incorrect English."

I thought she didn't rely on my source, or that she didn't read properly, so I checked another dictionary and sent her that definition as well.
I always put nice smileys :) in my messages.

The senior employee replied:"Is this some sort of joke? I don't find this funny, and have other things to worry about."

My new recruit seemed a bit nervous at that point. And I was upset, too, because I didn't even fully grasp what was going on.
I later explained the story to other colleagues to ask for advice and they all blamed me for "provoking" her, for trying to be a "know-it-all" and for "not stopping".

I am incredibly upset and feel wronged by this situation, especially because I truly had only innocent intentions, and hadn't even THOUGHT about provocation or showing knowledge. I REALLY REALLY REALLY still cannot understand what was wrong about what I did!

The only explanation I have: work makes people misunderstand such tiny things and drives them crazy.

Yet, I currently feel very alone as I cannot force myself to admit a fault that I don't even fully understand why it is mine.


its much better to prove your right and destroy as many relationships as possible in the wake. in the end you will prove you have a better command of the english language, yet also show your failure in social skills
 
Upvote 0

Angelfrog

Rock, paper, JESUS! I win!
Oct 22, 2009
882
86
Sitting on a cloud in England.
✟9,863.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
From what I can see, this was all about how you felt the need to insist that you were right and she was wrong. Why was that so important? You are not going to gain good relationships if you beat something like this to death with resource after resource. She made a fleeting comment to you, and you turned a molehill into a mountain. She got understandably annoyed. Then you talked to other people who agreed that this is a non issue. And now you are calling work evil as a result.

Honestly, this kind of thing needs to be dropped right away. You don't have to be right all the time. People can disagree. That is not evil. It is part of learning how to have good relationships with others. Obsessing over who is right over something trivial will only destroy relationships, and that is on you. Who is right in this case is simply not important.

I strongly advise against taking this triviality to the CEO. I can almost guarantee that his or her opinion of you will be diminished if you do. The CEO does not have time for this kind of silliness.

I'm sorry that you're having such a hard time with this, but you will have many more to come. I think that you really need to think about what is really important and what is not, and when to let go. That is a sign of maturity, and will also give you a lot more peace.

To be honest, I couldn't have phrased it better than this.

It sounds like your colleague was simply being a little over sensitive about the term- and I rather imagine it was more to do with it not being gender neutral than anything else. PC gone mad? Probably- but that's pretty normal now. If I had been her and received the response she did- I must admit I would have seen it as someone who can't let something go and is determined to be 'right' at any cost.

Probably not what you intended at all- but that's how it would come across to others.

You already know that you have a bit of a tendency to be rather intense over things, Bridge- even though you're well meaning. I would simply let it go.

It's hardly 'evil' nor does it show how the workplace is evil. Unless there's a specific problem in a specific line of work or location- work is no more evil than a cinema, shopping centre, leisure place or anywhere else.

It would be a shame if people judge you by thinking you're arrogant ( I'm not saying you are- I think you may have a few social skill issues but I don't think for one minute you're arrogant. You have a really good heart, Bridge)- rather than your witness. I think it's important to listen to what others say- even if you don't understand it.
 
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums

Pal Handy

Irregular Member
Jun 15, 2011
3,796
228
Southeast Michigan
✟20,508.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
It's all about You, Jesus
And all this is for You
For Your glory and your fame
It's not about me
As if You should do things my way
You alone are God
And I surrender to your ways

Jesus, lover of my soul
All consuming fire is in Your gaze
Jesus, I want you to know
I will follow you all my days
For no one else in history is like you
And history itself belongs to you
Alpha and Omega, You have loved me
And I will share eternity with You

WHAT HAS THIS GOT TO DO WITH MY QUESTION?!?!?!?!??!!?!?

OFF TOPIC!!!!!
Jesus is the answer.
It is all about Him.
Be Christ like.
Pray for your enemies.
Do good to those who use and abuse you.
It all begins and ends with Jesus for those who follow Him.

My post was very much on topic because this is a Christian advice forum
not a I'm good and all others are bad forum.

If you really want advice, listen and stop justifying yourself
and receive Godly wisdom and your life will change for the better
instead of you making the same mistakes over and over.

You can not change others but you can through God's help change yourself and
the way you react to others and God will bless you when you do things His way.
 
Upvote 0

Ark100

The Lord is my Refuge
Mar 11, 2012
2,041
91
✟10,421.00
Faith
Pentecostal
Marital Status
Private
I am a junior manager in my team and have an important role in the training, development and coordination aspects of my direct team.

Yet, I currently feel very alone as I cannot force myself to admit a fault that I don't even fully understand why it is mine.

My advice to you is to limit the way you joke around. Many people these days take things too seriously, and especially at work, there has to be a limit.

You may find it uncomfortable or even strange, but you have to adhere to the norms of work-place. Less jokes.

You don;'t have to put smilies in all of your emails, some people even take smilies the wrong way.

Best to remain professional, and joke a little when need be, not all the time and not with everyone.

always remember some people are watching you, even though you dont know they are. Some are even pro'lly reading the internal mails and emails when you dont think they are.

You are there to work, and let it remain so. It looks like you are having problems with some thick people there and also seeing your other posts, that would be the best advice I can give you.

Be more serious at work, less jokes. Bring professionalism into it more and let others see that in you. Leave the other things for outside of work.

Let your emails be strictly 'work' stuffs, no smilies if possible except someone you are very very friendly with.

You have to redeem yourself back in front of those who are probably talking behind your back about you. Dont give anyone the satisfaction of seeing you leave/or be fired just like that.

FOCUS ON WORK ONLY when you are at work
 
Upvote 0
Oct 15, 2011
430
4
✟8,086.00
Faith
Christian
Notice the word in red - why didn't you use a gender-neutral term? :doh:

I can understand why there was some friction! Political correctness is a necessary evil especially within the workplace these days. Look at gender-neutral section half-way down.

I repeat that it was an example similar to what actually happened. I didn't use the exact same words as in the original situation due to strict privacy reasons and since it could possibly never occur anywhere else in the world.
 
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums

thesunisout

growing in grace
Supporter
Mar 24, 2011
4,761
1,399
He lifts me up
✟159,601.00
Country
United States
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
I am a junior manager in my team and have an important role in the training, development and coordination aspects of my direct team.

Within my team, we are all good friends and we often plan things outside work as well, from trips out of town to museum or theater visits. And the overall company culture is very informal.

A more senior employee from a different team (we have hung out with her as well, though less often) wrote me an e-mail asking for information which one of my newest recruits knew about.
Now, this senior employee and my new recruit have something very noticeable in common, e.g. like being the only two in the company from a certain town (I am slightly changing the true story for privacy reasons, but it should have the same message).

I replied to both in CC, mentioning, in a completely neutral and intention-less manner "...for more information you can from now on rely on your fellow townswoman."

The senior employee replied that all was fine, and at the end of the her e-mail she wrote a P.S.: "You don't say fellow townswoman. That's wrong English. You say fellow citizen."

I double-checked an online dictionary, and replied to her a quoted a passage with the definition for "townswoman", showing that it was not wrong English.

Again, she replied:"Townswoman is incorrect English."

I thought she didn't rely on my source, or that she didn't read properly, so I checked another dictionary and sent her that definition as well.
I always put nice smileys :) in my messages.

The senior employee replied:"Is this some sort of joke? I don't find this funny, and have other things to worry about."

My new recruit seemed a bit nervous at that point. And I was upset, too, because I didn't even fully grasp what was going on.
I later explained the story to other colleagues to ask for advice and they all blamed me for "provoking" her, for trying to be a "know-it-all" and for "not stopping".

I am incredibly upset and feel wronged by this situation, especially because I truly had only innocent intentions, and hadn't even THOUGHT about provocation or showing knowledge. I REALLY REALLY REALLY still cannot understand what was wrong about what I did!

The only explanation I have: work makes people misunderstand such tiny things and drives them crazy.

Yet, I currently feel very alone as I cannot force myself to admit a fault that I don't even fully understand why it is mine.

The senior employee was obviously annoyed by something you said in your email, most likely when you referenced her as a fellow townsperson to your subordinate, and so she decided to nitpick you on your use of language. That is what we call passive aggressive behavior. You didn't understand what was going on, so you made the issue worse by having a little back and forth with her over who was right. It was never about who was right, it was about the fact that you did something to irritate your co-worker.

Now what you need to do is completely let the issue go and pray for Gods intervention in the situation. You have allowed yourself to get all worked up about it, taking the bait of Satan. Forgive this person, forgive yourself, and pray that God will iron all of this out. Do not worry about who is right or wrong; it doesn't matter. What matters is that you represent Christ in your workplace. You need to follow this scripture:

Philippians 2:13

Do everything without complaining or arguing,

Bear what happens at the job gracefully and without complaining. Jesus didn't complain when He was being sent to His death, so neither should you complain to your coworkers about situations such as these.
 
Upvote 0