- Oct 10, 2011
- 23,291
- 5,252
- 45
- Country
- United States
- Faith
- Non-Denom
- Marital Status
- Celibate
In today's America, almost everyone has mental issues. Just look at a couple current threads right here in the non-denom forum to see how many have a myriad of issues. Look at "pill time" in the public schools.
Giving people a free pass for their "issues" serves no one's best interests. Every mass shooter in the last few years has had a history of mental illness and everyone just patted them on the head and said, "there's nothing you can do about it". Well, they found something to do about it!
We need to stop coddling people. Those who can be made to pull themselves up and get moving should, and those who are incapable need serious help--not just some unsupervised meds, but real institutional help.
Don't judge him to harshly, you guys, I can understand his point, I think he's trying to say that in order to have a perfect world, we need a way to sort out the fakers, scammers, or those who are just plain (please excuse me for this) just plain lazy... They do exist... and in a perfect society, we need to sort out those who have true, proven, real illnesses and are "not able" (to work) because of it, from those who are "able-bodied" (able to work)
Now I will tell you that I have social anxiety issues, Depression, at times severe PTSD, am a paranoid scitzophrenic, and hear voices (have audio and visual hallucinations) and because of this I have my good days, and my bad days, and am unable to work, but I am not going to use this as excuse for bad or evil and wicked behavior (committing crimes) saying the voices or something told me to do it, everyday it takes hard work (very strenuous effort) on my part to combat these problems and try to overcome these issues, everyday is a great struggle and challenge for me just to function somewhat normally, and someday's I am fine (on a good day) but on a bad day, when I am having symptoms, it's all I can do to just hold myself together and keep from freaking out...
That being said a mentally disabled person, like myself, who goes out and commits a horendous crime, still has to be prosecuted, but I think It takes professionals to sort it out to as the level of sentence the person should receive, I would say it takes a professional Certified Psychologist to verify the nature of the persons disability, then a professional investigator to sift out whether or not a person is lying or not to as whether or not their disorder is real, or whether it was responsible for the persons committing the crime, (and perhaps a lie detector test) and then, a judge who then decides whether or not based on the other two professionals evaluations, whether or not the person is a danger or threat to society, and where they should go based upon the evidence presented, either to a mental institution, or a care home, or prison and for how long, based upon the evidence/evaluations.
If the Psychologist and the investigators evaluations are in conflict or seem to contradict each other, then the Judge is going to have a hard time deciding, but if it is in agreement that yes, this person does have a mental disorder that led to their crime, then it depends upon the crime, obviously if they killed or almost killed someone out of an act of brutality, or killed multiple people, then even if it is deemed that mental disorders were responsible, that person is still a danger and a threat to society, and we have to, prosecute them for the crime, they should go to either a lock down mental institution, for how long is up to the judge, and may be based on future psychological evaluations in the mental institution.
Now if, a person let's say robbed a house while nobody was home, but is known to be harmless and gentle, (maybe they were living on the streets and just desperate) and the investigator, and lie detector tests, and Psychologist are in agreement that mental disorders were responsible, then maybe that Judge would send them to a care home or something like that, until such a time that future psychological evaluations, were in agreement that the person could be rehabilitated and join normal society again...
It all depends on the circumstances and conclusions of the experts, and the Judge will have to ultimately decide, now if the person claims to having a mental disorder that led them to do it, but the psychologist and investigator believe he is lying, then he should be prosecuted like any other able-bodied, mentally able/capable person would be, which might mean a prison sentence, how long a prison sentence depends on the judge , the circumstances, and the nature of the crime...
We need skilled judges and professionals to sort out all the circumstances of these issue, before a decision can be made...
Anyways, just my opinion, in Jesus name,
God Bless!
Upvote
0