i need some advice

sparkle123

Active Member
Site Supporter
May 1, 2015
254
183
✟64,572.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
I am back posting again about my marriage... my husband told me it was over between us this past weekend after starting a petty argument. I was on my way to church, so I went and when I came back later in the day he had taken down the prayer corner that he helped me build in the other room and moved all of his things in there and carelessly thrown some of my things in what was formerly our room. I didn't really feel up to having a conversation with him that day, as I was hurt...
He has done this before (threatened divorce to me) during arguments and then later he says he doesn't mean it, but every time it tears me up. I have some abandonment fears and I am insecure, find it hard to trust, and we have been in therapy for a couple months now; he knows this is a major weak spot for me and our therapist has told him it's destructive. Nonetheless, the behavior continues. I think I could forgive it easy once, but now it's feeling like he either wants the divorce or he's found a weak spot.
He is not a Christian so part of me feels like 1 Corinthians 7:15 applies. But then I think that I am being hard hearted and trying to justify my wanting to end this and be unloving. Besides, he isn't really ending the marriage; he's just dangling the threat over me enough to let me know how angry he is, or something... Sad thing is, it's working, and I don't really trust that next time it wont be "for real." As in, he'll just say he's really done with it. I was so scared this Sunday/Monday that I started making plans with family and the few friends I have. Yesterday I called to look at a house for rent.

We went to counseling yesterday as well. It turns out that my husband feels he has lost himself in our marriage, so he overreacts to my expression of feeling upset or hurt and goes for the jugular, I guess. I think he gave up a lot of things because he wanted me to like him, and I think he did a lot of things because he wanted me to like him. I didn't ask him to do these things, but I did make clear who I was, and that didn't always fit with the things he liked (ie, the group of far left academic/activist types who give literary readings that he used to hang out with before we met... I am not a leftist, not a right, I find it all obnoxious. I spent my time as an activist and don't want anything to do with it now. Even when I was more invested in politics I would have considered these folks to be naive, bourgeois, armchair types, speechifying about the man... anyway, it's just not my scene. at. all.) I have grown a lot during our marriage, and perhaps this has put additional pressure (in his mind) to lose himself more.

I don't really know that I even know him now... if it's true he just twisted himself to an image he thought would be acceptable to me. On the plus, he has decided that therapy isn't just a load of crap, and he is looking into individual therapy on his own.

The thing is, he hasn't shown any real remorse for the damage he's done with his threats. Last night he asked me what I wanted to do about sleeping arrangements. I think this was his way of saying he wanted to share a room. I told him I wanted separate rooms for now though. He said he was sorry for making things difficult, but that was pretty much it...
I think I want to divorce more than I want to stay together. Last night he told me he is going to start doing things on his own (like, going out places w/out me) and I started to feel anxious. I have wanted him to pursue his friendships outside of us, but this announcement coupled with the divorce threats... I just feel profoundly uneasy. I have been thinking a lot about just moving out on my own, and have a foot out the door mentally due to them. I don't know if I want to continue while my husband finds himself... I feel like he's just preparing to divorce me and isn't ready to do it yet.
 

ImaginaryDay

We Live Here
Mar 24, 2012
4,200
791
Fawlty Towers
✟30,199.00
Country
Canada
Faith
Protestant
Marital Status
Separated
Politics
CA-Conservatives
To me, it sounds like the ball is really in his court right now. Any hint he might give you that some of the 'choice' of what happens is up to you, it really doesn't appear that way. If he is telling you it's over between you, and he is making divorce threats, then I would suggest asking him point blank if he intends to act on it, and not let him skirt the issue. You might even ask the counselor to mediate the question as well - to help come to an answer. The game your husband is playing of making you do mental and emotional back-flips needs to end.
I guess that if I were in your situation, the ultimate answer would be more important than not knowing. It would help to say "Okay, now I know. Now I (or we) can do X,Y, and Z to move forward".
 
  • Like
Reactions: mkgal1
Upvote 0

mkgal1

His perfect way sets me free. 2 Samuel 22:33
Site Supporter
Jun 22, 2007
27,339
7,349
California
✟551,233.00
Faith
Anglican
Marital Status
Married
I agree.

I'd also try to point out that each time he tosses out that threat he's destroying a bit of your marriage each time (which then makes it even more difficult to restore each time---like you'd already expressed here). I'd impress that it's important to say what he means and to refrain from *not* saying things he doesn't truly mean (especially this threat).
 
Upvote 0

sparkle123

Active Member
Site Supporter
May 1, 2015
254
183
✟64,572.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
It's been impressed on him by me and the counselor (therapist?) that his threats undermine trust. He has said he was uncertain if he wants a divorce, that he was thinking about it (his parents told him not to make any quick decisions, apparently), and then he says he doesn't. He is very resentful of me right now as he feels I've held him back from friendships, happiness, etc. Coupled with his anger, I am not really excited to talk about feelings right now... but I think I will see if we can have the counselor mediate a conversation about divorce or not. Last night we had a kind of normal night of eating together and talking about our days, he tried to sit closer to me, and did ask me if I still want "a life together" but it feels very uneasy. I don't really trust him because of his volatility. Thanks for the advice :)
 
Upvote 0

mkgal1

His perfect way sets me free. 2 Samuel 22:33
Site Supporter
Jun 22, 2007
27,339
7,349
California
✟551,233.00
Faith
Anglican
Marital Status
Married
He is very resentful of me right now as he feels I've held him back from friendships, happiness, etc. Coupled with his anger, I am not really excited to talk about feelings right now... but I think I will see if we can have the counselor mediate a conversation about divorce or not. Last night we had a kind of normal night of eating together and talking about our days, he tried to sit closer to me, and did ask me if I still want "a life together" but it feels very uneasy. I don't really trust him because of his volatility

Yeah.....that's completely understandable (and healthy!). Why would you want to make the effort (and be vulnerable) with someone that could toss that all away (and not really care)? It's a tough spot.

His resentment about feeling as if you've held him back or that he's lost a part of himself? Isn't that all his choice---or some internal decision he'd made? You weren't keeping him from socializing with his other friends....correct?
 
Upvote 0