Albion,
You are missing what I am saying
Paul clearly spoke of praying in tongues, he called it prayer.
It matters not that that makes little sense to you
How can that be? Praying is asking or petitioning with something in mind.It should also be considered that Paul did identify these actions as prayer and worship... that connotes that Paul felt it was possible to know whether or not you were praying or worshiping. What is not known is what it is that you are praying but that does not change what a prayer is.
I have read this chapter many times.
This verse does not say praying in tongues PRIVATELY , while the rest of this Passage in addition to Chapter 12 refers to speaking in Tongues CORPORATELY during a church service where interpretation is given .
Further, Acts 2 shows that Tongues were given which were unfamiliar to some in attendence , yet were recognizable to others (foreign languages) which these Hearers spoke .
Ergo, Tongues are for CORPORATE environments for the sake of the UNBeliever who may be in attendence , and, it is supposed to be a distinct foreign language which might be recognizable to some . And it is to be followed with an English interpretation (assuming the Corporate environment is filled with english speaking people) from ANother ....OR, by the Tongue Speaker himself because the Tongue Speaker is supposed to understand his own Tongue.
Here is a diligent treatise that a woman did concerning this topic :
"This is what I learned:
tounges means foreign language- look up the word for this gift in any language the Bible has been written in and look up that definition. you will find answers of "(foreign) language or dialect". Example is the original ancient Greek (glossolalia) which is 'to speak languages'. when someone down the road is said to speak a tounge, you know they speak a language or dialect unfamiliar to you.
So this means the churches who teach that tongues is also sounds of holy joy from the spirit such as chittering, laughing, crying, moaning, mooing, clucking or barking are incorrect.
tongues is plural- every reference to the gift in scripture is plural with only the exception of a specific person speaking a specific language. It is the ability to speak and/or understand foriegn languages.
So this means the churches who teach that tounges is a single language from heaven between God, angels and you, if you have the spirit, are incorrect.
there is only one kind of tounges gift- I never found any scriptural support for a tounges that was only for prayer and another that was for the congregation/public. All information from scripture points to the one ability of speaking foreign languages you previously didn't know.
So this means the churches who teach that there are different forms of tounges are incorrect.
tongues must be understood by all people around you and done in orderly fashion- this is something that Paul tried to pound into the heads of the Corinthian congregation. Everyone, including the speaker, must understand what was said either by already knowing that language or by a translator. Otherwise it was a waste of time and cannot be proven to be a genuine gift.
So this means the churches who practice mosh pit-like tongues extravaganzas or who never have an interpreted tongue message are in error.
tongues was for a sign to unbelievers and for edification of the church body- direct quotes from The Apostle Paul. Anyone who didnt believe Jesus was the real deal and that the church now belongs to ALL who believe would be proven wrong by the confirmation of this gift and that would in turn strengthen the church as a whole and add to it's ranks.
So this means the churches who teach that tongues is for a deeper personal connection to God is incorrect.
tongues may have passed away long ago-there are many compelling reasons to believe this to be true and i have acctually confirmed it for the gift of prophecy simply due to the biblical definition of a prophet. I personally haven't yet put a headstone on tongues, but i do say that if the genuine gift does still exist, it must be incredibly rare. I haven't experienced or heard of any credible accounts of the true gift being used combined that with the purpose and usefulness of such a gift is all but gone.
So this brings into question any church that teaches this gift is attainable, let alone mandatory for the church body.
When I did this study it was acctually hard to find a tongues supporter that was willing to talk about it. The one pastor I did find to talk to me gave his ideas of what it was all about and a few scriptures.. a couple of which had nothing to do with spiritual gifts or tongues. Even the Assembly of God main website stated that some of its core doctrine was not found in scripture, but was based on "assumptions and deductions from an apparent pattern found in the book of acts". it's like alot of people belived in it and had stories of experiences to tell me, but they couldnt tell me why or explain anything with any real satisfaction"
tongues must be understood by all people around you and done in orderly
How is it possible to pray if you don't have a clue what you are saying?
You should know regardless of whether it is in your own language of English, or, a different language . And if you dont, then you may very well be saying something which is unpleasing to God or even defaming God since Satan could easily manipulate this ; thats why is important to MAKE SURE you have the real gift of Tongues and that it is used in strict accordance to the Bible .
In fact, many of the Cults actually speak in a different language which no one understands including the SPeaker. The Bible demands that the SPeaker know what he is speaking if theres no other INterpreter in order for the Tongue to be genuine . This too depends on the honesty and integrity of the Tongue Speaker for he/she could be committing a deliberate fraud ,or, a satanic counterfiet unbeknowns to the Speaker as is the case today in many churches due to the pressure to have this gift (the 'haves' versus the 'have nots') .
This subject is entirely too simple to warrant such strenuous silly efforts and ideas on your part.If you think that the Bible is supposed to be unintelligible, then I have to disagree. And the fact that Paul spoke of tongues and referred to prayer does not mean that we should have no idea what it means...or that the obvious meaning could not have been missed. But none of that are you willing to consider, so you aren't able to help out, that's all. It happens.
But how is it possible to call something prayer if prayer means petitioning for something and you don't know what you are asking for? Does that help?
Yes it is.
1 Cor 14:13-14
13 For this reason the one who speaks in a tongue should pray that they may interpret what they say.
14 For if I pray in a tongue, my spirit prays, but my mind is unfruitful.
Yes, because in this passage this means foreign language.
Why do you say that? Tongues are not just foreign languages..
1 Corinthians 13:1
13 If I speak in the tongues[a] of men or of angels, but do not have love, I am only a resounding gong or a clanging cymbal.
How can be angels be a foreigner to us? Do you think we can understand the languages of angels?? That's why one should pray for interpretation..
1 Corinthians 12:10
10 and to still another the interpretation of tongues.
in this passage this is the Gift of Interpretation of tongues.
1 Corinthians 14:2
2 For anyone who speaks in a tongue does not speak to people but to God. Indeed, no one understands them; they utter mysteries by the Spirit.
This passage says that not speak to people. How can people understand?? You see that's why there are gift of interpretation of Tongues.. And no one understands them. Meaning, NO ONE.. AS IN NO..
Not to go off topic and also not trying to sound corny, but have a serious question. Is tounges writeable? If its a language wouldn't that mean it has words, letters...etc? Like when we get to heaven and can possibly speak it, would we know how to write it down?
I never really thought about that before and now I am really fascinated about knowing a new language. Of course in heaven we speak a diffrent divine language right? Something like the angels speak? Its so hard for me to remember all this stuff lol
The angels have a language? Why would they? HOW could a spirit form sounds?
Not to go off topic and also not trying to sound corny, but have a serious question. Is tounges writeable? If its a language wouldn't that mean it has words, letters...etc? Like when we get to heaven and can possibly speak it, would we know how to write it down?
I never really thought about that before and now I am really fascinated about knowing a new language. Of course in heaven we speak a diffrent divine language right? Something like the angels speak? Its so hard for me to remember all this stuff lol
Revelation 17:7
7 Then the angel said to me: “Why are you astonished? I will explain to you the mystery of the woman and of the beast she rides, which has the seven heads and ten horns.
That's when an angel has assumed an Earthly form. Not an answer for how angels relate in the spirit realm.
13 If I speak in the tongues of men or of angels, but do not have love, I am only a resounding gong or a clanging cymbal.
That verse does not say that angels have voice boxes or tongues or a language. It is hypothetical, i.e. "Even if you were able to speak like an angel, but didn't have love...."
It's like saying, "If you were superman, you still couldn't get to your appointment on time." That does NOT say you are superman or can actually fly, you know.
Also several people from the old testament heard angels speak to them and stories of heaven and visions of heaven have spoken of the sounds angels make.
"Glory to God in the highest, peace on earth good will toward men"
You mean that these people HEARD in their OWN language, similar to what happened on Pentecost Sunday. It's not that there is an angelic language used among these spirits.
Several angels have also been SEEN, as recorded in scripture, but we all know (don't we?) that this is just the way that they appeared to men or women for the purpose of the occasion.