Home | Be a Christian | Devotionals | Join Us! | Forums | Rules | F.A.Q.


Go Back   Christian Forums > Ministry > Life Stages > Married Couples
Register BlogsPrayersJobsArcade Calendar Mark Forums Read

Married Couples Married Area - Available for those who are married, which is defined as a legal union between one man and one woman.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 5th September 2011, 11:05 PM
sdmsanjose's Avatar
Regular Member

Gender: Male Married Faith: Christian Country: United States Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 19th June 2006
Location: Arizona
Posts: 3,365
Blessings: 3,185,721
Reps: 177,695,453,613,662,720 (power: 177,695,453,613,674)
sdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond repute
sdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond repute
Love Must be tough-DISRESPEST-2

"Love Must Be Tough, a New Hope For Family In Crises" (DISRESPECT)-2


I posted the below on the “Marriage Restoration” forum and we kind of got off tract because of my question. I wanted to know what all you people here on the front page of the "Married Couples” forum think about Dr. Dobson’s book and advice. I am reprinting my post below and have changed the question to “Do you all have any comments about Dobson’sadvice?

Reprint is below:

In reading threads about marriages in crises on this forum, I looked up some information from Dr. James Dobson, Psychologist and marriage counselor.

His book is "Love Must Be Tough, a New Hope For Family In Crises"
The book is about saving a marriage not divorce, hence the title, “Love Must Be tough, NEW HOPE FOR A FAMILY IN CRISES”

Disrespect seems to be a very common underlying problem in many marital problems that have been posted. Dobson takes an approach that is not universally accepted by some churches but I found his approach to be worthy of consideration. In addressing the disrespect Dobson speaks of subjects such as pain, confidence, action, separation, accountability and God. Rather than me try to explain his approach I have reprinted some statements from his book below

A few quotes from Chapter 7:
"...it is also true that God often uses pain and crises to bring a sinful person to his senses....Prodigal son decided to go home to daddy when his money ran out and he was eating with the pigs"

"Remember that the basic marital problem usually involves matters of respect..."

"The precipitated crises, first, must be accompanied by an entire change of attitude. Instead of begging. pleading, wringing your hands and whimpering like an abused puppy, you as the vulnerable partner must appear strangely calm and assured. The key word is CONFIDENCE, and it is of maximum importance. Your manner should say, "I believe in me. I am no longer afraid. I can cope regardless of the outcome. I know something I am not talking about, I have had my day of sorrow and I am through crying. God and I can handle whatever life puts in my path



The book is also about the disrespected spouse taking action so that the disrespect does not destroy you. If you leave your spouse the continuing disrespect will stop and allow you time to start healing from the affects of your husband’s actions

The book also makes clear that by separating (no mention of divorce) from your spouse you will improve the chances of saving your marriage.

Quote from page 124:
‘…separation that is intended not to kill the marriage but to rescue it….”

“I believe that living apart for a period of time can clear the air for some families and permit the healing process to begin, especially where one partner is desperately in need of accountability”

The book details how taking action to stop disrespect and bringing about accountability increases your chances of restoring your marriage to a much healthier relationship and that would be better for your children.

Conversely, tolerating your spouses disrespect and potential infidelity can be disastrous. Dr. Dobson gives a real life situation where the wife (Sue) tolerated her husband’s disrespectful infidelity. Part of the story from page 23 is quoted below:
“In the process of giving her children their father for a while longer, she also gave them a severely depressed, suicidal mother, and eventually, a family breakup. Her children continued to suffer today….”

Dr. Dobson also points out that taking actions should be taken only after receiving guidance from the Holy Spirit and with professional Christian counseling.



Do you all have any comments about Dobson’s advice?

PS
I am more interested in dicussing Dobson's method rather than the adultres husband.
Reply With Quote
Become a CF Site Supporter Today and Make These Ads Go Away!

  #2  
Old 5th September 2011, 11:07 PM
Autumnleaf's Avatar
Legend

Gender: Male Married Faith: Charismatic Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 18th June 2005
Posts: 22,680
Blessings: 1,521,540
My Mood Happy
Blog Entries: 7
Reps: 340,188,474,869,445,888 (power: 340,188,474,869,477)
Autumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond repute
Autumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond repute
The Bible talks about humility. Dobson talks about CONFIDENCE. I'm curious what the rest of you think.
__________________
If the people cannot trust their government to do the job for which it exists, to protect them and to promote their common welfare, all else is lost. - Barack Obama
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 5th September 2011, 11:18 PM
mkgal1's Avatar
His perfect way sets me free. 2 Samuel 22:33

Gender: Female Married Faith: Christian Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 22nd June 2007
Location: California
Posts: 15,371
Blessings: 204,998,829
My Mood Amazed
Reps: 710,244,983,490,226,816 (power: 710,244,983,490,249)
mkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond repute
mkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond reputemkgal1 has a reputation beyond repute
I don't see any contradiction, AL. Humility isn't a lack of confidence......it's knowing where our strength comes from. Our strength comes from God--not our spouses (as some spouses may subtly imply). Also.....another aspect of humility is willingly surrendering to God. Sometimes a person can feel torn, and will often be more surrendered to their spouse (as there are more tangible consequences for NOT surrendering to them). I believe that is a large part of what the book is describing---being able to gather the strength to actually follow Christ without reservation or fear.

Stan, I think it's an excellent book (and biblical principles). I just wish it were accepted more in mainstream Christianity.
__________________
"Don't just pretend that you love others. Really love them. Hate what is wrong. Stand on the side of good. Love each other with genuine affection, and take delight in honoring one another- Romans 12: 9-10

Last edited by mkgal1; 5th September 2011 at 11:47 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 5th September 2011, 11:19 PM
McScribe's Avatar
Me

Gender: Male Faith: Christian Party: CA-Conservatives Country: Canada Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 15th April 2009
Location: Canada
Posts: 6,988
Blessings: 2,812,408
My Mood Blessed
Reps: 323,359,012,935,065,088 (power: 323,359,012,935,077)
McScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond repute
McScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond reputeMcScribe has a reputation beyond repute
Humility is clarity about who we are. As Paul says, neither things too high nor things too low. Was what I did tough love? I'm not even sure.
__________________
The large carnivorous bird looks around hungrily.
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 5th September 2011, 11:22 PM
Senior Veteran

Gender: Female Married Faith: Non-Denominational Party: US-Republican Country: United States Member For 5 Years Steward
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 18th May 2008
Location: Missouri
Posts: 4,942
Blessings: 505,541,665
My Mood Bookworm
Reps: 9,223,372,036,854,775,808 (power: 9,223,372,036,854,788)
dorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond repute
dorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond repute
Hi Stan. This is probably totally beside the point of what you're looking for and I'm sorry for that. But the first thing that jumped out at me - and bothers me - is that its assuming that, of course, its the husband who's the "bad" spouse while the poor wife has been tolerating his naughty behavior. That's true in some cases, obviously, but there are also cases where its the opposite. Its not always the husband who's the bad guy. A lot of Dobson's scenarios seem to be the former, though.

Again, sorry that this isn't what you were looking for, I just wanted to share the first observation off the top of my head.
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 5th September 2011, 11:25 PM
Senior Veteran

Gender: Female Married Faith: Non-Denominational Party: US-Republican Country: United States Member For 5 Years Steward
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 18th May 2008
Location: Missouri
Posts: 4,942
Blessings: 505,541,665
My Mood Bookworm
Reps: 9,223,372,036,854,775,808 (power: 9,223,372,036,854,788)
dorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond repute
dorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond repute
Also, is this the book where the wife is advised to not let her husband see the children until he "shapes up?" There was something like this that we all got into a huge discussion on a year or two ago that went on forever.
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 5th September 2011, 11:43 PM
Senior Member

Member For 3 Years
 
Join Date: 15th June 2011
Posts: 1,991
Blessings: 150,933
My Mood Blessed
Reps: 189,530,365,933,507,552 (power: 189,530,365,933,512)
hijklmnop has disabled reputation
I loved this book. It helped save my marriage and quite frankly, my sanity.
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 5th September 2011, 11:47 PM
Senior Member

Member For 3 Years
 
Join Date: 15th June 2011
Posts: 1,991
Blessings: 150,933
My Mood Blessed
Reps: 189,530,365,933,507,552 (power: 189,530,365,933,512)
hijklmnop has disabled reputation
Originally Posted by mkgal1 View Post
I don't see any contradiction, AL. Humility isn't a lack of confidence......it's knowing where our strength comes from. Our strength comes from God--not our spouses (as some spouses may subtly imply). Also.....another aspect of humility is willingly surrendering to God.....sometimes a person can feel torn, and will often be more surrendered to their spouse. I believe that is a large part of what the book is describing---being able to gather the strength to actually follow Christ without reservation or fear.

Stan, I think it's an excellent book (and biblical principles). I just wish it were accepted more in mainstream Christianity.
Most important thing in life I didn't know I had to learn!!! LOL I was blind to how dependent on my spouse I was until I was faced with not having him anymore. So glad to be free of that.
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 5th September 2011, 11:48 PM
Senior Veteran

Gender: Female Married Faith: Non-Denominational Party: US-Republican Country: United States Member For 5 Years Steward
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 18th May 2008
Location: Missouri
Posts: 4,942
Blessings: 505,541,665
My Mood Bookworm
Reps: 9,223,372,036,854,775,808 (power: 9,223,372,036,854,788)
dorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond repute
dorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond reputedorig59 has a reputation beyond repute
I definitely agree with the offended spouse not acting all pathetic. I think sometimes people think that being a Christian means you should let people walk all over you.
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 5th September 2011, 11:55 PM
sdmsanjose's Avatar
Regular Member

Gender: Male Married Faith: Christian Country: United States Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 19th June 2006
Location: Arizona
Posts: 3,365
Blessings: 3,185,721
Reps: 177,695,453,613,662,720 (power: 177,695,453,613,674)
sdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond repute
sdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond reputesdmsanjose has a reputation beyond repute
Reply by DORI
Hi Stan. This is probably totally beside the point of what you're looking for and I'm sorry for that. But the first thing that jumped out at me - and bothers me - is that its assuming that, of course, its the husband who's the "bad" spouse while the poor wife has been tolerating his naughty behavior. That's true in some cases, obviously, but there are also cases where its the opposite. Its not always the husband who's the bad guy. A lot of Dobson's scenarios seem to be the former, though.

Again, sorry that this isn't what you were looking for, I just wanted to share the first observation off the top of my head.


Dori
I think that Dobson also used other examples of the situation in the book with the woman being the offender. I loaned my book out several months ago to a person who needed it so I cannot go back and see for sure.

Dobson is from the 50s and 60s era and he maybe a little like you said. In addition, it maybe that women come to him more than men. I hate generalizing these cases but I think that most men resist going to ask for help and especially if it is another man that is the counselor. That is my guess, I could be wrong.

Another guess of mine is this. In the 50s and early 60s, when women did not seem to be as free as now, the offender seemed to be mostly the men. Dori, it is probably hard for men of that era to be as astute as you are about women.

However, I think Dobson’s method may be of some help to the hurting, both male and female, even if he is not as astute as you. Believe me, I am no great fan of Dobson in all areas but this one he seems to have some worthy advice. The fact that I am not a great Dobson fan in every area is another story we can get into at some other time. I told Dobson that he was acting like JR Ewing of the show Dallas one time and quit sending him support money. However, I do believe that Dobson has some things right. I do not want to throw the baby out with the bathwater.

Thanks for your post Dori. I always like reading your posts and am glad to see you more active again on this forum. You posts make this forum better.

Stan
Reply With Quote
Reply


Return to Married Couples

Thread Tools
Display Modes


 
Become a CF Site Supporter Today and Make These Ads Go Away!


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 02:31 AM.