Home | Be a Christian | Devotionals | Join Us! | Forums | Rules | F.A.Q.


Go Back   Christian Forums > Theology (orthodox Christians only) > Theology (orthodox Christians only) > Christian Philosophy & Ethics
Register BlogsPrayersJobsArcade Calendar Mark Forums Read

Christian Philosophy & Ethics The forum to discuss philosophy and ethics from a Christian perspective.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 20th March 2011, 04:45 PM
curious

Gender: Male Faith: Christian Member For 3 Years
 
Join Date: 20th March 2011
Posts: 83
Blessings: 1,018,942
Reps: 11,002,656,803,527,132 (power: 11,002,656,803,531)
Jim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond repute
Jim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond reputeJim Bob has a reputation beyond repute
Is getting plastic surgery a sin?

I heard from a pastor once that if you get your nose corrected you criticize God because God made you this way. This argument makes no sense to me at all it's totally silly imo. This is like saying if siamese twins want to get separated they critize God or if a child without legs wants to get prosthetics then this critizes God.
Or what if a woman is totally depressed and feels inferior because she has no breasts at all then why should she be forced to live with this and continually feel miserable?
Also believing that if somebody has a crooked nose means that God wants it that way doesn't make sense either because if you believe that then you also have to believe if a deformed child is born then God wanted it that way. This is to blame God for sickness and everything which came through the fall of man!
Reply With Quote
Become a CF Site Supporter Today and Make These Ads Go Away!

  #2  
Old 20th March 2011, 07:19 PM
Newbie

Gender: Female Married Faith: Baptist Member For 3 Years
 
Join Date: 18th March 2011
Posts: 14
Blessings: 17,929
My Mood Bashful
Reps: 9,223,372,036,854,894 (power: 9,223,372,036,858)
Idontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond repute
Idontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond reputeIdontlikeobama has a reputation beyond repute
I think helping a deformed child, i.e. prosthetic legs or separation is a lot different than plastic surgery to correct a crooked nose.
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 20th March 2011, 08:43 PM
solarwave's Avatar
Know Thyself

Gender: Male Faith: Christian Country: Europe Member For 5 Years Steward
 
Join Date: 17th October 2006
Location: UK
Posts: 3,387
Blessings: 1,164,846
My Mood Cheerful
Reps: 76,493,385,490,766,848 (power: 76,493,385,490,777)
solarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond repute
solarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond repute
I agree. I don't think plastic surgery is wrong unless you take it to the extreme in vainity.
__________________
"But God demonstrates his own love for us in this: While we were still sinners, Christ died for us." - Romans 5:8

"He is the atoning sacrifice for our sins, and not only for ours but also for the sins of the whole world." - 1 John 2:2

"And now these three remain: faith, hope and love. But the greatest of these is love." - 1 Corinthians 13:13
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 21st March 2011, 12:32 AM
DamianWarS's Avatar
Follower of Isa Al Masih

Member For 5 Years
 
Join Date: 15th May 2008
Posts: 1,163
Blessings: 22,247,684
Reps: 169,224,417,985,933,984 (power: 169,224,417,985,940)
DamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond repute
DamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond reputeDamianWarS has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by Jim Bob View Post
I heard from a pastor once that if you get your nose corrected you criticize God because God made you this way. This argument makes no sense to me at all it's totally silly imo. This is like saying if siamese twins want to get separated they critize God or if a child without legs wants to get prosthetics then this critizes God.
Or what if a woman is totally depressed and feels inferior because she has no breasts at all then why should she be forced to live with this and continually feel miserable?
Also believing that if somebody has a crooked nose means that God wants it that way doesn't make sense either because if you believe that then you also have to believe if a deformed child is born then God wanted it that way. This is to blame God for sickness and everything which came through the fall of man!
our imperfections are the result of the cruse of sin upon our lives. Because of sin there is sickness, disease, blemishes, pain and suffering and death. But if sin causes these things than what is the answer? Well we all the know that and it is Christ. If sin gives death than Christ gives life and if sin gives imperfections than Christ gives perfection. When Christ raptures the church we will be given incorruptible bodies and it is only then that our physical will no longer bear the marks of sin and imperfections.

With that said I don't see a problem with plastic surgery as our current sate isn't necessarily the way God wants us because of the effect sin has had on our lives but we shouldn't look to plastic surgery as an answer. Colossians 2 says "in Christ [we] have been brought to fullness. In him you were also circumcised with a circumcision not performed by human hands." I think we can replace the word circumcision with whatever physical insecurity you have and so in Christ we are restored to what he desires although we may still bear the physical marks of sin we can claim the power of Christ on them instead and be identified as perfect in Christ even in our physical instead of relying on "human hands".
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 21st March 2011, 07:26 AM
LWB's Avatar
Regular Member

41 Gender: Male Faith: Christian Country: Australia Member For 3 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 28th January 2011
Location: Brisbane
Posts: 667
Blessings: 16,384
Reps: 28,569,779,928,199,984 (power: 28,569,779,928,203)
LWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond repute
LWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond reputeLWB has a reputation beyond repute
In a sense I think it is sinful. Being concerned with external appearance rather than inner virtue betrays a lack of faith. Which master do we serve? The world which judges by what it sees, or God who judges the invisible heart?

But it would be unfair to impose such a standard on anyone who hasn't come to the conclusion on their own. Especially children who suffer some kind of deformity.

I can understand people wanting to correct deformity caused by injury or disease, or getting a mole removed here and there, but most of the cosmetic work I've seen looks worse than what nature intended. Breast implants look hideous and need repeated surgery and expense to maintain, and face lifts and the like end up leaving the people looking like bizarre aliens.
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 21st March 2011, 11:46 AM
Mature veteran

62 Gender: Male Faith: Charismatic Party: US-Others Country: United States Member For 5 Years Brickmaker
 
Join Date: 13th September 2006
Location: MA
Posts: 10,111
Blessings: 4,117,356
Reps: 613,820,715,776,872,704 (power: 613,820,715,776,890)
dayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond repute
dayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond reputedayhiker has a reputation beyond repute
I don't think its a sin.
God created us as beautiful creatures and when age, etc takes that beauty away from us I don't see any problem fixing it a little.
I'd say its a loving thing to do especially to fix a birth deformity.
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 21st March 2011, 12:09 PM
solarwave's Avatar
Know Thyself

Gender: Male Faith: Christian Country: Europe Member For 5 Years Steward
 
Join Date: 17th October 2006
Location: UK
Posts: 3,387
Blessings: 1,164,846
My Mood Cheerful
Reps: 76,493,385,490,766,848 (power: 76,493,385,490,777)
solarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond repute
solarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond reputesolarwave has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by LWB View Post
In a sense I think it is sinful. Being concerned with external appearance rather than inner virtue betrays a lack of faith. Which master do we serve? The world which judges by what it sees, or God who judges the invisible heart?
Make up is sinful. How about wearing nice clothes? Nice hair? Of course have faith in God but physical things are real too. We arn't Platonists who think the only real things are the perfect idea in another spiritual realm. As long as we treat physical things as physical things and not our God then it isn't sin.


I can understand people wanting to correct deformity caused by injury or disease, or getting a mole removed here and there, but most of the cosmetic work I've seen looks worse than what nature intended. Breast implants look hideous and need repeated surgery and expense to maintain, and face lifts and the like end up leaving the people looking like bizarre aliens.
I agree that taking it to the extreme is sin if it is done for vainity.
__________________
"But God demonstrates his own love for us in this: While we were still sinners, Christ died for us." - Romans 5:8

"He is the atoning sacrifice for our sins, and not only for ours but also for the sins of the whole world." - 1 John 2:2

"And now these three remain: faith, hope and love. But the greatest of these is love." - 1 Corinthians 13:13
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 21st March 2011, 01:19 PM
dies-l's Avatar
Adoptive father of 3 and adopted son of God.

36 Gender: Male Married Faith: Christian Party: US-Libertarian Country: United States Member For 5 Years
 
Join Date: 30th March 2007
Location: Virgo Supercluster
Posts: 9,332
Blessings: 21,069,267
My Mood Praying
Reps: 798,487,417,824,736,256 (power: 798,487,417,824,753)
dies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond repute
dies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond reputedies-l has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by Jim Bob View Post
I heard from a pastor once that if you get your nose corrected you criticize God because God made you this way. This argument makes no sense to me at all it's totally silly imo. This is like saying if siamese twins want to get separated they critize God or if a child without legs wants to get prosthetics then this critizes God.
First off, I think it is unreasonable to say the plastic surgery is inherently sinful. Like many things, it has good applications and bad.

Or what if a woman is totally depressed and feels inferior because she has no breasts at all then why should she be forced to live with this and continually feel miserable?
What I hear is that the woman in this example believes the lie that the world has told her that, if only she had a more desirable body, she would be happy. It is almost certain that she will not be any less miserable because of the plastic surgery she receives. So, if she is seeking surgery to feel better about herself, she is wasting her time and money. So, whether or not it is "a sin", her line of thinking is misguided and unwise.

The truth is that the world tells us all sorts of lies about what will make us happy: more money, more sex, a better appearance, more technology, more stuff, a bigger house, a nicer car, a different government, a nice vacation, and so on. Each of these things can have a fleeting impact on our happiness and comfort, but they give us nothing meaningful if that is what we are using them for.

Also believing that if somebody has a crooked nose means that God wants it that way doesn't make sense either because if you believe that then you also have to believe if a deformed child is born then God wanted it that way. This is to blame God for sickness and everything which came through the fall of man!
I agree with you on this. To blame defects (whether minor or severe) on God is misguided theology.
__________________

To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.


Faith is not the belief that God will ultimately align His will to our own; it is the desire to surrender our lives completely to His.
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 25th August 2011, 02:26 PM
Newbie

Gender: Female Married Faith: Christian Member For 2 Years
 
Join Date: 25th August 2011
Posts: 11
Blessings: 14,399
Reps: 10 (power: 0)
diane21 is on a distinguished road
I think plastic surgery is not a bad Idea,when the 4-year-old boy who has his chin rebuilt after a dog bit him Or the young woman who has the birthmark on her forehead lightened with a laser.
__________________

To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

Last edited by diane21; 25th August 2011 at 03:48 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 25th August 2011, 03:57 PM
Armistead14's Avatar
Newbie

Gender: Male Married Faith: Baptist Member For 5 Years
 
Join Date: 18th March 2006
Posts: 1,374
Blessings: 1,080,244
Reps: 48,317,086,923,624,672 (power: 48,317,086,923,634)
Armistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond repute
Armistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond reputeArmistead14 has a reputation beyond repute
How silly, we change how we appear everyday to look more pleasing.

Haircuts, why not just let it grow naturally as God intended and never cut it.

Make up...most women everyday to improve their looks.

Bra's...why not let them hang naturally until they're at your knees....

on and on....

Plastic surgery is no different. I do agree to some it becomes a God and they pay dearly for it, but corrective or just some mild improvements are fine.

My wife got boobs 7 years ago, no problems and they look great. Actually reduced and lifted. She is rather small, but busty and getting older they became more of a bother after children started dropping. She feels and looks much better now.
Reply With Quote
Reply


Return to Christian Philosophy & Ethics

Thread Tools
Display Modes


 
Become a CF Site Supporter Today and Make These Ads Go Away!


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 08:50 PM.