Home | Be a Christian | Devotionals | Join Us! | Forums | Rules | F.A.Q.


Go Back   Christian Forums > Ministry > Outreach > Christianity and World Religion
Register BlogsPrayersJobsArcade Calendar Mark Forums Read

Christianity and World Religion Christianity and World Religion forum gives Christians and non-Christians the opportunity to come together to better understand and learn about different religions.

Closed Thread
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  #21  
Old 7th November 2009, 05:25 AM
Newbie

Gender: Male Faith: Atheist Party: US-Others Country: United States Member For 2 Years
 
Join Date: 2nd November 2009
Location: usa, missouri
Posts: 98
Blessings: 26,301
My Mood Asleep
Reps: 150,984,329 (power: 150,987)
kidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond repute
kidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond reputekidsagainstkows has a reputation beyond repute
why are atheists boring? well the answer to that is we are not boring. in fact, we understand that once we die, thats it. for this reason life is infinitely more valuable and we cherish every moment of it.

we dont have any cool stories though so sorry about that... except the Golden Compass i guess, but we know thats fiction.
__________________
15But in your hearts set apart Christ as Lord. Always be prepared to give an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have. But do this with gentleness and respect, (1 peter 3:15)
Become a CF Site Supporter Today and Make These Ads Go Away!

  #22  
Old 7th November 2009, 05:44 AM
Space Cadet

Gender: Female Faith: Atheist Party: AU-Greens Country: Australia Member For 2 Years
 
Join Date: 4th November 2009
Posts: 298
Blessings: 2,063,548
Reps: 19,550,139,574,747 (power: 19,550,139,577)
RealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond repute
RealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by dewaddict84 View Post
Not to step on a pixies toes

Be not afraid of a dear pixies toes sir, for they do not exist anyway

I opened this thread an an intended discussion between everyone, not just myself/believers, so feel free to answer these questions yourself also.

  #23  
Old 7th November 2009, 06:13 AM
Eudaimonist's Avatar
Reverencing the Exalted Spirit of Man

45 Gender: Male Faith: Atheist Country: Sweden Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 1st January 2003
Location: American resident of Sweden
Posts: 18,497
Blessings: 8,259,763
My Mood Tired
Reps: 440,945,404,461,670,976 (power: 440,945,404,461,699)
Eudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond repute
Eudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by Supreme View Post
Buildings are interesting. Traditition is interesting. Stories are interesting. Hope is interesting. It's an unfortunate fact that atheism lacks all four.
Oh, I have all four.

But this may hinge on just what one means by "atheism". If that means simply "a lack of belief in a god or gods", then I'll agree with you that is boring. If the entire world were atheist, the reasons for belief/nonbelief in members of the divine persuasion would be a boring subject to discuss, and I would discuss other things.

However, if atheism can refer to nontheistic ways of life, then the field of values opens up tremendously.

Buildings: Any building not dedicated to some religious ideal or purpose could reasonably be seen as a humanistic one, serving human purposes or ideals. How many buildings are not churches, temples, or mosques? Well, it looks like I have plenty of buildings to enjoy.

Tradition: Again, any secular or humanistic past could count here. The history of the West since the Renaissance is a tradition of a gradual shifting of cultural ideas to secular and humanistic ones. Progress is our tradition.

Stories: Ayn Rand is just one of many atheistic authors who wrote stories in which no god was thought to exist. While she, or the other authors, might not be to your taste, you can't say the stories don't exist.

Hope: We have plenty of hope. We can hope for our own happiness and that of others, for the gradual improvement of the human condition, and that everyone can learn to focus on what is good in life instead of obsessing over their own finitude and inventing grandiose escape clauses.

So, I think you'll find much of interest outside of theism.


eudaimonia,

Mark
__________________

To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
  #24  
Old 7th November 2009, 06:56 AM
Montalban's Avatar
Vive la France!

44 Gender: Male Faith: Eastern-Orthodox Country: Australia Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 20th January 2004
Location: Sydney, NSW
Posts: 31,357
Blessings: 6,201,102
My Mood Cheerful
Reps: 1,599,740,264,866,359,808 (power: 1,599,740,264,866,399)
Montalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond repute
Montalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by Alizera View Post
Have you been an atheist all your life?
Her reply should be "Not yet"
__________________
Will you be my Valentine?

Fāilte dhut a Mhoire, tha thu lan de na grāsan;
Tha an Tighearna maille riut.

Hail Mary, full of Grace;
The Lord is with thee
  #25  
Old 7th November 2009, 06:59 AM
Montalban's Avatar
Vive la France!

44 Gender: Male Faith: Eastern-Orthodox Country: Australia Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 20th January 2004
Location: Sydney, NSW
Posts: 31,357
Blessings: 6,201,102
My Mood Cheerful
Reps: 1,599,740,264,866,359,808 (power: 1,599,740,264,866,399)
Montalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond repute
Montalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by Eudaimonist View Post
Oh, I have all four.

But this may hinge on just what one means by "atheism". If that means simply "a lack of belief in a god or gods", then I'll agree with you that is boring. If the entire world were atheist, the reasons for belief/nonbelief in members of the divine persuasion would be a boring subject to discuss, and I would discuss other things.

However, if atheism can refer to nontheistic ways of life, then the field of values opens up tremendously.

Buildings: Any building not dedicated to some religious ideal or purpose could reasonably be seen as a humanistic one, serving human purposes or ideals. How many buildings are not churches, temples, or mosques? Well, it looks like I have plenty of buildings to enjoy.
If you're an atheist then there's a whole realm of purpose you're missing out on
Originally Posted by Eudaimonist View Post
Tradition: Again, any secular or humanistic past could count here. The history of the West since the Renaissance is a tradition of a gradual shifting of cultural ideas to secular and humanistic ones. Progress is our tradition.
Progressive tradition?
Originally Posted by Eudaimonist View Post
Stories: Ayn Rand is just one of many atheistic authors who wrote stories in which no god was thought to exist. While she, or the other authors, might not be to your taste, you can't say the stories don't exist.
You're not an Objectivist are you?
Originally Posted by Eudaimonist View Post
Hope: We have plenty of hope. We can hope for our own happiness and that of others, for the gradual improvement of the human condition, and that everyone can learn to focus on what is good in life instead of obsessing over their own finitude and inventing grandiose escape clauses.

So, I think you'll find much of interest outside of theism.
Why hope though?
__________________
Will you be my Valentine?

Fāilte dhut a Mhoire, tha thu lan de na grāsan;
Tha an Tighearna maille riut.

Hail Mary, full of Grace;
The Lord is with thee
  #26  
Old 7th November 2009, 07:01 AM
Montalban's Avatar
Vive la France!

44 Gender: Male Faith: Eastern-Orthodox Country: Australia Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 20th January 2004
Location: Sydney, NSW
Posts: 31,357
Blessings: 6,201,102
My Mood Cheerful
Reps: 1,599,740,264,866,359,808 (power: 1,599,740,264,866,399)
Montalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond repute
Montalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by RealityPixie View Post
Be not afraid of a dear pixies toes sir, for they do not exist anyway

I opened this thread an an intended discussion between everyone, not just myself/believers, so feel free to answer these questions yourself also.

Do you believe in any objective truths?
__________________
Will you be my Valentine?

Fāilte dhut a Mhoire, tha thu lan de na grāsan;
Tha an Tighearna maille riut.

Hail Mary, full of Grace;
The Lord is with thee
  #27  
Old 7th November 2009, 07:03 AM
Montalban's Avatar
Vive la France!

44 Gender: Male Faith: Eastern-Orthodox Country: Australia Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 20th January 2004
Location: Sydney, NSW
Posts: 31,357
Blessings: 6,201,102
My Mood Cheerful
Reps: 1,599,740,264,866,359,808 (power: 1,599,740,264,866,399)
Montalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond repute
Montalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond repute
Purpose for an Atheist must be wholly subjective
__________________
Will you be my Valentine?

Fāilte dhut a Mhoire, tha thu lan de na grāsan;
Tha an Tighearna maille riut.

Hail Mary, full of Grace;
The Lord is with thee

Last edited by Montalban; 7th November 2009 at 07:07 AM. Reason: add italics
  #28  
Old 7th November 2009, 07:19 AM
Space Cadet

Gender: Female Faith: Atheist Party: AU-Greens Country: Australia Member For 2 Years
 
Join Date: 4th November 2009
Posts: 298
Blessings: 2,063,548
Reps: 19,550,139,574,747 (power: 19,550,139,577)
RealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond repute
RealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond reputeRealityPixie has a reputation beyond repute
Montalban: Yes I believe in many objective truths, mainly in regard to science. However, there are some relms of the human experience (ie, morality) where I do not believe there is an object truth.

The objective truth behind my purpose, the one that it true regardless of what I think of it, is that I am here to spread my genes. That's cool, I accept that. However I also superimpose my own subjective meaning, things like "I want to use my life to help people", etc. When we are getting into psychology, how people think, etc, nobody thinks the same way, and so there can be few objective truths of the mind, conciousness and thought process. Of the natural world though, yes there are many objective truths.

Erm...I'm not sure whether I've explained that quite right, I'm a little distracted right now. If anyone wants to jump in or correct me you are more than welcome.
  #29  
Old 7th November 2009, 07:21 AM
Eudaimonist's Avatar
Reverencing the Exalted Spirit of Man

45 Gender: Male Faith: Atheist Country: Sweden Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 1st January 2003
Location: American resident of Sweden
Posts: 18,497
Blessings: 8,259,763
My Mood Tired
Reps: 440,945,404,461,670,976 (power: 440,945,404,461,699)
Eudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond repute
Eudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond reputeEudaimonist has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by Montalban View Post
If you're an atheist then there's a whole realm of purpose you're missing out on
Irrelevant. I have ideals, even if they are not specifically theistic ones. The issue here isn't if I have the same range of ideals as Christians (or other theists) do, but if I have a range of ideals at all.

Of course, I could also point out that theistic purposes in our godless universe are either pointless or at best placebo-like, so it's not like I'm missing out on much.

Purpose for an Atheist must be wholly subjective
There is no "must" here. Purpose for an atheist may be biocentric, as it is for me. Purpose for me isn't about mere desire.

You're not an Objectivist are you?
That's a tricky question to answer. I'm strongly influenced by Ayn Rand's ideas, but I don't fit neatly into a box labelled "Objectivist". I like much of the broader Greek/Aristotelian philosophical tradition, and so I usually call myself a Eudaimonist, but in some contexts Objectivist may be appropriate enough.

Why hope though?
You don't seriously mean to suggest that hope is only a theistic issue? It's a human issue. Anyone can experience hope. Christians only have one specific form of hope.

The point of hoping is to avoid despair and to have the psychological resources to make the most of one's existence. Despair is anti-life and anti-flourishing. Hope need not be for eternal life, but for life of any desirable sort.


eudaimonia,

Mark
__________________

To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

Last edited by Eudaimonist; 7th November 2009 at 07:29 AM.
  #30  
Old 7th November 2009, 08:03 AM
Montalban's Avatar
Vive la France!

44 Gender: Male Faith: Eastern-Orthodox Country: Australia Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 20th January 2004
Location: Sydney, NSW
Posts: 31,357
Blessings: 6,201,102
My Mood Cheerful
Reps: 1,599,740,264,866,359,808 (power: 1,599,740,264,866,399)
Montalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond repute
Montalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond reputeMontalban has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by RealityPixie View Post
Montalban: Yes I believe in many objective truths, mainly in regard to science. However, there are some relms of the human experience (ie, morality) where I do not believe there is an object truth.

The objective truth behind my purpose, the one that it true regardless of what I think of it, is that I am here to spread my genes. That's cool, I accept that. However I also superimpose my own subjective meaning, things like "I want to use my life to help people", etc. When we are getting into psychology, how people think, etc, nobody thinks the same way, and so there can be few objective truths of the mind, conciousness and thought process. Of the natural world though, yes there are many objective truths.
Why do you impose subjective meaning?

Why is it your genes have allowed you to know that your only purpose is to spread them?
__________________
Will you be my Valentine?

Fāilte dhut a Mhoire, tha thu lan de na grāsan;
Tha an Tighearna maille riut.

Hail Mary, full of Grace;
The Lord is with thee
Closed Thread


Return to Christianity and World Religion

Thread Tools
Display Modes


 
Become a CF Site Supporter Today and Make These Ads Go Away!


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 12:50 PM.