Home | Be a Christian | Devotionals | Join Us! | Forums | Rules | F.A.Q.


Go Back   Christian Forums > Theology (Christians Only) > Theology > General Theology
Register BlogsPrayersJobsArcade Members List Calendar Mark Forums Read

General Theology The forum for general theological discussions about issues that do not fit in any other forum, eg. Angelology

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 3rd November 2009, 07:19 PM
JimfromOhio's Avatar
Legend

50 Gender: Male Married Faith: Lutheran Party: US-Libertarian Country: United States Member For 5 Years Tentmaker
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 7th February 2004
Location: Ohio
Posts: 26,808
Blessings: 385,238
My Mood Doh
Blog Entries: 10
Reps: 118,036,801,594,663 (power: 0)
JimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond repute
JimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond repute
Cross

Catholics and Protestants is that many Catholic crosses have an image of Jesus hanging on them, while Protestant crosses are empty. (The cross with Christ on it is a crucifix.) More important is that the cross and the crucifix represent two very different understandings of Christ's atonement for sin. Both Catholics and evangelical Protestants believe that Christ died to pay the penalty for sin. The difference is that Protestants believe that Christ's work was finished on the cross, and Catholics believe it continues.

For Catholics, the appearance of Christ on the crucifix represents the fact that Christ's atoning work is still going on.

For Protestants, the empty cross demonstrates that Christ's sacrificial work is completed, and there is no more sacrifice for sin.
Reply With Quote
Become a CF Site Supporter Today and Make These Ads Go Away!

  #2  
Old 3rd November 2009, 07:22 PM
Evangelica's Avatar
Faithful Follower of Christ

Faith: Christian Country: Canada Member For 3 Years Tentmaker
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 31st January 2006
Location: Pacific Coast
Posts: 25,722
Blessings: 416,099
My Mood Joyful
Reps: 214,523,345,853,851,360 (power: 214,523,345,853,880)
Evangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond repute
Evangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond repute
And here I thought the empty cross was that Christ was no longer there but carrying on His work in the resurrected life
__________________
Hypocracy:
to conform outwardly
to traditions set by 'elders'
for which there isn't
an inward respect
of the tradition.
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 3rd November 2009, 07:28 PM
Yeznik's Avatar
Veteran

Gender: Male Faith: Oriental-Orthodox Country: Armenia Member For 5 Years
 
Join Date: 9th November 2004
Posts: 1,426
Blessings: 21,549
Reps: 6,119,198,989,755 (power: 6,119,198,996)
Yeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond repute
Yeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond reputeYeznik has a reputation beyond repute
Just an FYI, the majority of the Crosses in the world that don't have Christ on them is Orthodox.
__________________
Լո'յս ճշմարիտ Քրիստոս, արժանաւորեա' զհոգի իմ` ուրախութեամբ տեսանել զլոյս փառաց քոց ի կոչման աւուրն եւ հանգչել յուսով բարեաց յօթեվանս արդարոց,մինչեւ յօր մեծի գալստեան քո, ողորմեա' քո արարածոց եւ ինձ` բազմամեղիս:







Last edited by Yeznik; 3rd November 2009 at 07:28 PM. Reason: typo
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 3rd November 2009, 07:29 PM
JimfromOhio's Avatar
Legend

50 Gender: Male Married Faith: Lutheran Party: US-Libertarian Country: United States Member For 5 Years Tentmaker
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 7th February 2004
Location: Ohio
Posts: 26,808
Blessings: 385,238
My Mood Doh
Blog Entries: 10
Reps: 118,036,801,594,663 (power: 0)
JimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond repute
JimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by Evangelica View Post
And here I thought the empty cross was that Christ was no longer there but carrying on His work in the resurrected life
That too.
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 3rd November 2009, 07:30 PM
JimfromOhio's Avatar
Legend

50 Gender: Male Married Faith: Lutheran Party: US-Libertarian Country: United States Member For 5 Years Tentmaker
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 7th February 2004
Location: Ohio
Posts: 26,808
Blessings: 385,238
My Mood Doh
Blog Entries: 10
Reps: 118,036,801,594,663 (power: 0)
JimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond repute
JimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by Yeznik View Post
Just an FYI, the majority of the Crosses in the world that don't have Christ on them is Orthodox.
Good to know
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 3rd November 2009, 07:32 PM
Evangelica's Avatar
Faithful Follower of Christ

Faith: Christian Country: Canada Member For 3 Years Tentmaker
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 31st January 2006
Location: Pacific Coast
Posts: 25,722
Blessings: 416,099
My Mood Joyful
Reps: 214,523,345,853,851,360 (power: 214,523,345,853,880)
Evangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond repute
Evangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond repute
Some believe that those images help them to see God in various forms. Native Americans saw the great spirit's strength when they looked at eagles, wisdom when they saw an owl.
When God said not to have images it's because He wants nothing between Him and His people. Not an earthly projection of a small bit of who He is.
__________________
Hypocracy:
to conform outwardly
to traditions set by 'elders'
for which there isn't
an inward respect
of the tradition.
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 3rd November 2009, 07:36 PM
JimfromOhio's Avatar
Legend

50 Gender: Male Married Faith: Lutheran Party: US-Libertarian Country: United States Member For 5 Years Tentmaker
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 7th February 2004
Location: Ohio
Posts: 26,808
Blessings: 385,238
My Mood Doh
Blog Entries: 10
Reps: 118,036,801,594,663 (power: 0)
JimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond repute
JimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by Evangelica View Post
Some believe that those images help them to see God in various forms. Native Americans saw the great spirit's strength when they looked at eagles, wisdom when they saw an owl.
When God said not to have images it's because He wants nothing between Him and His people. Not an earthly projection of a small bit of who He is.
During Reformation, some early Protestant reformers were very cautious about images of Christ. Crosses are frequent in places of worship, but these reformers believed that using images of God in worship was a violation of the second commandment.
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 3rd November 2009, 07:37 PM
tadoflamb's Avatar
can you do any less?

48 Gender: Male Married Faith: Catholic Member For 2 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 20th February 2007
Location: Diocese of Tucson
Posts: 4,940
Blessings: 87,566
Reps: 137,956,546,526,936 (power: 137,956,546,533)
tadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond repute
tadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond reputetadoflamb has a reputation beyond repute
In the words of Fr. Benedict Groeshel on why Catholics have the Crucifix:

"All of us has a Cross to carry, none of us knows what it's like to be risen from the dead."

Or something like that.

Are there really no crucifixes in Protestant churches?
__________________
Hope! The fault of many Christians of our day is to hope too little. They believe that every battle and every obstacle will be the downfall of the Church. They are the apostles in the boat during the storm: they forget that the Savior is with them.~Bl. Frederic Ozanam
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 3rd November 2009, 07:40 PM
Evangelica's Avatar
Faithful Follower of Christ

Faith: Christian Country: Canada Member For 3 Years Tentmaker
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 31st January 2006
Location: Pacific Coast
Posts: 25,722
Blessings: 416,099
My Mood Joyful
Reps: 214,523,345,853,851,360 (power: 214,523,345,853,880)
Evangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond repute
Evangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond reputeEvangelica has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by JimfromOhio View Post
During Reformation, some early Protestant reformers were very cautious about images of Christ. Crosses are frequent in places of worship, but these reformers believed that using images of God in worship was a violation of the second commandment.
Really? Just during the reformation
__________________
Hypocracy:
to conform outwardly
to traditions set by 'elders'
for which there isn't
an inward respect
of the tradition.
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 3rd November 2009, 07:42 PM
JimfromOhio's Avatar
Legend

50 Gender: Male Married Faith: Lutheran Party: US-Libertarian Country: United States Member For 5 Years Tentmaker
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 7th February 2004
Location: Ohio
Posts: 26,808
Blessings: 385,238
My Mood Doh
Blog Entries: 10
Reps: 118,036,801,594,663 (power: 0)
JimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond repute
JimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond reputeJimfromOhio has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by Evangelica View Post
Really? Just during the reformation
Of course, today too. LOL
Reply With Quote
Reply


Return to General Theology

Thread Tools
Display Modes



 
Become a CF Site Supporter Today and Make These Ads Go Away!
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 06:26 AM.


vBCredits v1.4 Copyright ©2007 - 2008, PixelFX Studios