Home | Be a Christian | Devotionals | Join Us! | Forums | Rules | F.A.Q.


Go Back   Christian Forums > Society > Society > History
Register BlogsPrayersJobsArcade Calendar Mark Forums Read

History A new forum for the discussion of history.

Reply
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Unread 1st November 2009, 12:14 PM
Supreme's Avatar
Moderator

24 Gender: Male Faith: Protestant Country: United Kingdom Member For 5 Years
 
Join Date: 30th July 2009
Location: South London, United Kingdom of Her Majesty
Posts: 10,820
Blessings: 35,708,959
My Mood Angelic
Reps: 812,794,184,370,198,272 (power: 812,794,184,370,214)
Supreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond repute
Supreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond reputeSupreme has a reputation beyond repute
Why did the USA become increasingly involved in Vietnam?

This is an essay I've just found that I did for my GCSE History. It outlines the USA's involvement in Vietnam. I achieved an A* grade in it.

Question 1: Explain why the United States became increasingly involved in the war in Vietnam

The war in Vietnam was a conflict that started in the 1950s and ended in the early 1970s. During this time period, the United States became increasingly involved in Vietnamese political, economic and military affairs. There were a combination of reasons as to why the United States became more involved, the most important of which in my opinion were the Domino Theory and the growing influence of the National Liberation Front (NFL).
The most important reason as to why the United States became involved in Vietnam was the long term cause of the Domino Theory. The Domino Theory was the belief that once one country had fallen to communism, its neighbours would do the same. It was devised by John Foster Dulles, the US Secretary of State, during the 1950s. The Domino Theory would be a an obstacle for the Americans if they were to win the Cold War, as they had to keep as few countries from going communist as possible. If South Vietnam were to fall communist, its neighbours in South East Asia may do the same- including India, a country with a billion inhabitants and around 90% of its people living in poverty. Communism may look an attractive prospect to South East Asia’s poor, which increases the likelihood of the Domino Theory, and would have a dire effect for American economic interests in the region. American companies would be nationalised by the state under communism, and trade would be badly affected because Americans would not be able to sell commodities in communist countries. This would not only harm America’s economy, but also its military- it would not be able to sustain a well trained, well equipped army without the money to do so. Eventually, this would also have dire political effects for America- its President would look weak, and the Soviet Union would be the dominant global power, due to the United States’ inferior military, economy and financial system. Moreover, if the Domino Theory proved correct, and South East Asia was to turn communist upon South Vietnam’s transition to communism, the American lives lost in the Korean War- a bloody conflict resulting in 142,000 US casualties that also involved communist North Korea fighting the capitalist, US backed South Korea in a bid to ‘contain’ communism- would be in vain. This would be because their efforts to contain the spread of communism in Asia would be rendered almost useless if South East Asia were to become communist ten years after the Korean war. The ideas of a damaged US economy and military and the consequences this would bring for the Cold War, plus the lives given in vain in Korea were part of the worries of the Domino Theory, and were extremely important reasons as to why the United States became increasingly involved in the war in Vietnam.
Another important long term reason as to why the United States became increasingly involved in the war in Vietnam was the economic and military reason of the strategic importance of Vietnam. Vietnam bordered southern China, a communist and nuclear armed foe of the United States. Having an ally like South Vietnam would be of paramount importance if nuclear war broke out and the United States had nuclear warheads installed mere hundreds of miles below China and within range of south eastern Russia. Moreover, South Vietnam would be a good military ally to have if conventional warfare broke out- ships and planes from US installed naval and air bases would be able to navigate to China with relative ease due to the two countries’ proximity. The economic importance of Vietnam was also vital to US interests. Without Vietnamese co-operation in the South China Sea, the United States would lose access to vital shipping lanes that allowed the import and export of goods from the United States to South East Asia, India and the Middle East. If America were to lose Vietnam, it would have to consider alternative trade routes, which may prove too costly in terms of money, fuel and time. It was not just Vietnam’s strategic importance that determined US involvement in Vietnam, but also the strategic importance of South East Asia as a whole, which the Americans thought they would lose to communism if Vietnam turned communist (due to the Domino Theory). The military and economic strategic importance of Vietnam (and South East Asia as a whole) is therefore an important long term reason as to why the United States became increasingly involved in the war in Vietnam.
An important short term reason as to why the United States became increasingly involved in Vietnam was the increasing danger and support of the National Liberation Front (NLF). The NLF, often referred to as the ‘Vietcong’ by their American counterparts, were a communist guerrilla organization that used non-conventional tactics to attack Diem’s capitalist government and the United States in South Vietnam. They were an armed group to counter the unpopularity of the South Vietnamese dictator, President Diem and aimed to reunify Vietnam under a communist government. Frustrated by the reforms that Catholic Diem was implementing in South Vietnam- persecution of the Buddhist majority, imprisonment of adult and children opponents to Diem’s rule, little money on social reform- the NLF decided to terrorise the South Vietnamese government. The Americans responded by providing the South Vietnamese with military and economic help so that the South Vietnamese themselves could deal with the NLF. Eventually, however, a coup overthrew the President, who was succeeded by ten weak capitalist governments over a period of two years who could not could not govern effectively. This forced the Americans to send in their own military to combat the North Vietnamese and NLF (justified by the controversial ‘Gulf of Tonkin’ incident). However, American troops proved unpopular with the peasant villages due to their tactics of using napalm on innocent civilians and the US ‘zippo raids’, where the Americans would burn down entire villages suspected of being affiliated with the NLF. This improved support, and subsequently the strength of the NLF, as they had the co-operation and recruitment of an increasing number of locals with regard to hiding NLF supplies. Because of the inexperience of the Americans in guerrilla combat, the NLF were also using booby traps and snipers to inflict heavy US casualties, whilst also receiving effective weapons from the USSR and China. The NLF also had a superior knowledge of the terrain to the Americans. This made it all the more painful and humiliating for the Americans to loose, so troop numbers increased. The NLF therefore became more effective in their efforts to defeat the Americans, and launched the partially successful Tet Offensive in 1968 against the US in South Vietnamese cities, including the capital, Saigon. The NLF guerrilla warfare campaign, which threatened to humiliate America in their beliefs of the Domino Theory and the belief that America may lose the Cold War, plus the heavy casualties inflicted on the Americans, are therefore an important reason as to why the Americans became increasingly involved in the war in Vietnam.
The final important reason as to why the United States became increasingly involved in the war in Vietnam was the political ego of President Lyndon Johnson. Johnson was preceded by Kennedy and Eisenhower, two great American war heroes, and needed to prove to the US public that he was just as strong as his forerunners. Johnson saw Vietnam as a chance to demonstrate his strength, whilst also containing the spread of communism in Vietnam and South East Asia due to his belief in the Domino Theory. Moreover, getting increasingly involved in Vietnam may secure US economic and military interests in the region, due to its strategic importance, and could eventually lead to US victory in the Cold War. Johnson wanted to win the war as soon as possible, in order to keep it popular with the US public by ensuring as few lives were lost as possible, whilst also sending a message of intolerance of communism to the USSR to demonstrate US strength and therefore consistently increased troop numbers in Vietnam. However, due to the increased support and strength of the NLF by the Vietnamese people, the Americans suffered far more casualties than Johnson anticipated. Johnson retaliated by increasing troop numbers in an effort to show just how strong a leader he was, and how powerful America was. The desire for Johnson to prove he was a strong President in control of the Cold War is therefore an important reason why the US became more involved in Vietnam.
In conclusion, the United States increased its involvement in Vietnam for numerous reasons. The first and foremost reason was the Domino Theory and the US fear of communism and its effects on US economic and military interests in the Cold War. Secondly, the US saw Vietnam as an important military and financial ally to have in terms of strategic importance in the Cold War. Thirdly was the NFL and the increasing casualty toll the Americans were suffering which threatened to humiliate America in the Cold War, and fourthly was the political and psychological advantage Johnson saw in winning the Vietnam war as quickly as possible and thereby halting the Domino Theory.
__________________

__________________
“It is not the healthy who need a doctor, but the sick... For I have not come to call the righteous, but sinners.”- Matthew 9
Reply With Quote
Become a CF Site Supporter Today and Make These Ads Go Away!

  #2  
Unread 5th November 2009, 11:09 AM
Autumnleaf's Avatar
Legend

Gender: Male Married Faith: Charismatic Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 18th June 2005
Posts: 23,589
Blessings: 1,550,785
My Mood Happy
Blog Entries: 7
Reps: 357,698,520,665,149,056 (power: 357,698,520,665,182)
Autumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond repute
Autumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond reputeAutumnleaf has a reputation beyond repute
There was also the money made from the war by central banks...
__________________

__________________
"Do or do not. There is no try." - Yoda
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Unread 7th November 2009, 11:27 PM
Regular Member

52 Gender: Male Faith: Protestant Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 19th May 2007
Location: Hopewell, VA
Posts: 1,642
Blessings: 88,201
Reps: 190,456,044,468,136,544 (power: 190,456,044,468,145)
rdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond repute
rdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond reputerdclmn7 has a reputation beyond repute
Limited numbers of american troops served as advisors starting in 1959. A series of corrupt administrations did little to stabilize the region.
Kennedy would eventually get elected by accusing the republicans of being soft on communism.
A set of factors that led to disaster.
__________________

Reply With Quote
  #4  
Unread 3rd December 2009, 08:32 AM
USincognito's Avatar
Stop QWERTYface!

Gender: Male Faith: Atheist Country: United States Member For 5 Years Tentmaker
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 25th December 2003
Location: Dallas
Posts: 26,828
Blessings: 11,884
Reps: 705,083,665,022,041,216 (power: 705,083,665,022,078)
USincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond repute
USincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond reputeUSincognito has a reputation beyond repute
Corrupt South Vietnamese government, and an army that couldn't fight effectively.
__________________

__________________
(The Library of Alexandria) questioned the permanence of the stars, but did not question the justice of slavery - Carl Sagan in Cosmos
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Unread 3rd December 2009, 02:11 PM
DaisyDay's Avatar
blind squirrel

Gender: Female Married Faith: Unitarian Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 7th January 2003
Posts: 18,606
Blessings: 12,385,811
Reps: 781,542,780,354,919,168 (power: 781,542,780,354,949)
DaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond repute
DaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond reputeDaisyDay has a reputation beyond repute
Congrats on your A. What a big wall of tiny text.

Was there anything in particular you wanted to discuss about it?
__________________

__________________
- Daisy

If such people were amenable to facts, they would have gotten the point long ago...Whatever it is that is blocking the understanding of the "denialist", it is not access to facts or information. The blockage is most likely emotional, possibly based on fear, and one does not most effectively deal with emotional barriers by using facts as instruments of assault and battery. - Dan Murphy
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Unread 13th January 2010, 04:08 PM
Newbie

30 Gender: Male Faith: Christian Country: South Africa Member For 5 Years
 
Join Date: 12th October 2009
Location: Pretoria
Posts: 88
Blessings: 121,922
Blog Entries: 1
Reps: 19,288,103,689,405 (power: 19,288,103,695)
klasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond repute
klasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond reputeklasvaakie has a reputation beyond repute
Well...the reason why they have gotten involved in every war since the war for independence. PROFIT!!! You see, war is profitable to banks, weopons manufacturers, vehicle manufacturers etc...these companies and banks in turn sponsor the politicians...then a war is fought and sustained as long as possible so that the maximum profit may be garnished.
Just so you know, the Gulf of Tonkin incident on August 4th 1964, which basically hurled the US into the war...NEVER HAPPENED.
So yes, the US went to war over something that did not happen. Furthermore, there were strict rules to engagement...which limited the US officers...like where they could and could not go etc. These rules were made public so that the Viet Cong could get their hands on them. In the end, the war was supposed to be sustained, not won.
Interesting thing...JFK was assassinated just as he was beginning to withdraw troops from Vietnam and also when he had decided to oppose the central banking institution in America.
__________________

__________________
I celebrate my religion. I dont mourn it
To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

Last edited by klasvaakie; 13th January 2010 at 04:22 PM.
Reply With Quote
Reply


Return to History

Thread Tools
Display Modes


 
Become a CF Site Supporter Today and Make These Ads Go Away!


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 11:18 PM.