Home | Be a Christian | Devotionals | Join Us! | Forums | Rules | F.A.Q.


Go Back   Christian Forums > Congregation > Faith Groups > Messianic Judaism
Register BlogsPrayersJobsArcade Members List Calendar Mark Forums Read

Messianic Judaism A forum open to Christians and Jews to discuss Messianic Judaism beliefs and issues.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  #31  
Old 4th November 2009, 03:02 PM
visionary's Avatar
Legend

Gender: Female Faith: Messianic Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 25th March 2004
Posts: 22,338
Blessings: 6
My Mood Inspired
Blog Entries: 4
Reps: 261,787,083,207,455 (power: 261,787,083,235)
visionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond repute
visionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond reputevisionary has a reputation beyond repute
One of the most distinctive features about MJ is their return to Judiasm while retaining a faith in Yehsua as the Messiah. Anyone who tries to attach the name Messianic "Judaism" and yet not support a Judaistic worship style is misleading.
__________________
Since the Torah is a finite book expressing the will of an infinite God, many lessons must be derivable from each passage from all the infinite angles.
Reply With Quote
Become a CF Site Supporter Today and Make These Ads Go Away!

  #32  
Old 4th November 2009, 04:34 PM
Ivy's Avatar
Pray for President Barack Obama

45 Gender: Female Faith: Catholic Party: US-Others Country: United States Member For 4 Years Fisherman
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 26th October 2005
Location: New York
Posts: 5,733
Blessings: 357,633
My Mood Blessed
Reps: 6,400,947,796,780 (power: 6,400,947,806)
Ivy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond repute
Ivy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by Heber View Post
The only title worth holding is: Believer in (the Son of G_d / Jesus / Yeshua etc)
i.e. Undeserving Recipient of Mercy and Love
__________________

It is no small prudence to remain silent in evil times, to turn inwardly to Me,
and not to be disturbed by human opinions.
Do not let your peace depend on the words of men.
--Thomas Kempis


To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

Reply With Quote
  #33  
Old 5th November 2009, 03:01 AM
ContraMundum's Avatar
Senior Contributor

Gender: Male Faith: Anglican Member For 4 Years
 
Join Date: 2nd July 2005
Posts: 8,616
Blessings: 135,970
Reps: 26,760,299,974,294 (power: 26,760,299,987)
ContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond repute
ContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by Heber View Post

That is wrong. There are many within MJism who do believe in the eucharist and many who see a very clear connection between it and Passover.

I thank you, and in my experience this is true
. The three or so MJ congregations I have visited all celebrate it in the same manner as most Protestants do, often using a traditional Jewish blessing before the scriptural words of institution, which is fine of course.

The real issue is that Vis doesn't approve of using the scriptural word for thanksgiving ("eucharist" when Anglicised)- because Christians also use it. If I had dressed up the rite in Judeo-speak maybe she would have not even noticed the post. Perhaps I should call it a "Messianic Seder" or "Yeshua's kiddish" or whatever to make her happy. Same difference, same rite, same means of grace, of course. It's all about the costume to some people, so perhaps it needs to be dressed up to look "Jewish" more.

One thing I have learned- the more contact with MJs (in the real world) I have the more I see them as having common ground with me and my faith awhile it appears that they have less in common with some of the people that post here using the MJ icon.

I take it you know what the eucharist is?
That's a good question that I'd love to see answered.
__________________
"Here lies an atheist; all dressed up and no place to go." Epitaph in Maryland cemetery
Reply With Quote
  #34  
Old 5th November 2009, 03:06 AM
ContraMundum's Avatar
Senior Contributor

Gender: Male Faith: Anglican Member For 4 Years
 
Join Date: 2nd July 2005
Posts: 8,616
Blessings: 135,970
Reps: 26,760,299,974,294 (power: 26,760,299,987)
ContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond repute
ContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by visionary View Post
One of the most distinctive features about MJ is their return to Judiasm while retaining a faith in Yehsua as the Messiah. Anyone who tries to attach the name Messianic "Judaism" and yet not support a Judaistic worship style is misleading.

...and the $64 question is...what is truly "Judaistic" and what isn't. I think true worship of God is found in the liturgy the ancients churches use- the liturgy grounded and founded in both Temple and synagogue liturgy, where almost every point is from ancient Judaism, down to the colours of the vestments. Others, however, think it should look more like a modern synagogue mixed with pentecostalism or versions thereof. I think there's some room for both, others think only theirs is ok. I guess I'm just more open minded on this point than some. I have no idea where you stand on this, and it's ok by me no matter what you choose to follow.
__________________
"Here lies an atheist; all dressed up and no place to go." Epitaph in Maryland cemetery
Reply With Quote
  #35  
Old 5th November 2009, 07:42 AM
Regular Member

Gender: Male Faith: Judaism Member For 2 Years
 
Join Date: 31st July 2007
Posts: 332
Blessings: 15,080
Reps: 59,589,388,507,789 (power: 59,589,388,510)
fremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond repute
fremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond reputefremen has a reputation beyond repute
I thought being a MJ meant believing in Jesus and yet following the (written) Torah. Am I wrong in such an assumption?
__________________
Jewish, Zionist, and Free Thinker.
Reply With Quote
  #36  
Old 5th November 2009, 08:17 PM
ContraMundum's Avatar
Senior Contributor

Gender: Male Faith: Anglican Member For 4 Years
 
Join Date: 2nd July 2005
Posts: 8,616
Blessings: 135,970
Reps: 26,760,299,974,294 (power: 26,760,299,987)
ContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond repute
ContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond reputeContraMundum has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by fremen View Post
I thought being a MJ meant believing in Jesus and yet following the (written) Torah. Am I wrong in such an assumption?
I think MJism shares in the same dilemma that Judaism has- that is: how to follow the Torah when it's clear that one cannot follow every point. The decider is whose halacha one chooses to follow- Yeshua's and His decendants or the decendants of the Pharisees, the modern Rabbis. In both religions there is a lot of ground and room for interpretation IMHO.

Over the years I have discovered that following Yeshua is a lot harder than following the Rabbis. The commandment to love and forgive above all things and in everything is the ultimate human challenge, and all theology, ritual and religion fades into insignificance when one really looks in the mirror and works out that one has failed to love on a day to day basis. However, God's grace continually sees us through, helps us in our need and teaches us to love when we seemingly cannot.

Anyway, that's my two cents.
__________________
"Here lies an atheist; all dressed up and no place to go." Epitaph in Maryland cemetery
Reply With Quote
  #37  
Old 5th November 2009, 09:45 PM
Ivy's Avatar
Pray for President Barack Obama

45 Gender: Female Faith: Catholic Party: US-Others Country: United States Member For 4 Years Fisherman
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 26th October 2005
Location: New York
Posts: 5,733
Blessings: 357,633
My Mood Blessed
Reps: 6,400,947,796,780 (power: 6,400,947,806)
Ivy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond repute
Ivy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond reputeIvy has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by ContraMundum View Post

One thing I have learned- the more contact with MJs (in the real world) I have the more I see them as having common ground with me and my faith awhile it appears that they have less in common with some of the people that post here using the MJ icon.

That's an interesting statement. What do you see them as having in common?
__________________

It is no small prudence to remain silent in evil times, to turn inwardly to Me,
and not to be disturbed by human opinions.
Do not let your peace depend on the words of men.
--Thomas Kempis


To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

Reply With Quote
Reply


Return to Messianic Judaism

Thread Tools
Display Modes



 
Become a CF Site Supporter Today and Make These Ads Go Away!
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 11:29 PM.


vBCredits v1.4 Copyright ©2007 - 2008, PixelFX Studios