Home | Be a Christian | Devotionals | Join Us! | Forums | Rules | F.A.Q.


Go Back   Christian Forums > Congregation > Faith Groups > The Lord's Table - Liberal Catholics
Register BlogsPrayersJobsArcade Calendar Mark Forums Read

The Lord's Table - Liberal Catholics A forum for all liberal Catholics.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 9th September 2009, 06:29 PM
Andrew B.'s Avatar
Newbie

64 Gender: Male Faith: Christian Country: United States Member For 3 Years
 
Join Date: 14th November 2008
Posts: 68
Blessings: 102,031
Reps: 96,261,318 (power: 96,265)
Andrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond repute
Andrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond repute
Missing Sacrament?

Someone on a Christian talk show I was listening to brought this up, but nobody was willing to discuss it. Jesus gave specific instructions to his followers that they wash each other feet. This instruction is no less specific than other things Jesus told us to do, but it never became a sacrament. Or, even a practice. Not that it would be practical to do in church. But it could be done symbolically, just as baptism is done in church with a representative action.

Is there any church record of why this practice is not followed?
Reply With Quote
Become a CF Site Supporter Today and Make These Ads Go Away!

  #2  
Old 11th September 2009, 01:56 PM
Dark_Lite's Avatar
Chewbacha

Faith: Catholic Member For 5 Years
 
Join Date: 15th February 2002
Posts: 17,114
Blessings: 45,126,563
Reps: 1,238,051,283,267,514,112 (power: 1,238,051,283,267,541)
Dark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond repute
Dark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond reputeDark_Lite has a reputation beyond repute
If you're talking about in the Catholic Church, it is done at the end of Lent in response to Jesus' command. Foot washing - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
__________________

To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

Client-side CF enhancements for Google Chrome. Now with [bible=tag]power[/bible].

To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

Read CF in your mobile web browser. For all kinds of devices.
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 11th September 2009, 02:24 PM
Athanasias's Avatar
Regular Member

Gender: Male Married Faith: Catholic Party: US-Republican Country: United States Member For 4 Years
 
Join Date: 24th January 2008
Location: St. Louis
Posts: 2,414
Blessings: 6,061,439
My Mood Inspired
Reps: 35,572,589,408,352,448 (power: 35,572,589,408,359)
Athanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond repute
Athanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond reputeAthanasias has a reputation beyond repute
Washing of the feet is symbolic in the new testament. A Sacrament has to meet 3 criteria. It is a 1). outward sign 2)instituted by Christ that 3).actually gives grace. In this sense then the washing of the feet meets only 2 of the criteria for a sacrament. The washing that meets the criteria of sacrament in scripture is baptism.I hope that helps!
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 12th September 2009, 04:19 PM
scotsdoc54's Avatar
Quod ubique, quod semper, quod ab omnibus

Gender: Male Faith: Anglican Party: US-Democrat Country: United States Member For 2 Years
 
Join Date: 2nd September 2009
Location: TN
Posts: 25
Blessings: 60,990
Reps: 350 (power: 0)
scotsdoc54 is a jewel in the roughscotsdoc54 is a jewel in the roughscotsdoc54 is a jewel in the roughscotsdoc54 is a jewel in the rough
Originally Posted by Athanasias View Post
Washing of the feet is symbolic in the new testament. A Sacrament has to meet 3 criteria. It is a 1). outward sign 2)instituted by Christ that 3).actually gives grace. In this sense then the washing of the feet meets only 2 of the criteria for a sacrament. The washing that meets the criteria of sacrament in scripture is baptism.I hope that helps!
Agreed. Footwashing is practiced in many Catholic parishes as well as Anglican (Episcopalian) parishes. I also believe that some high church Lutherans incorporate it as well. But as a whole it's not a sacrament.
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 13th September 2009, 09:06 PM
Protinus's Avatar
...once more unto the breach dear friends

52 Gender: Male Faith: Catholic Party: US-Democrat Country: United States Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 13th April 2004
Location: New York City
Posts: 6,535
Blessings: 151,542
My Mood Pensive
Reps: 51,530,185,439 (power: 51,530,199)
Protinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond repute
Protinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond reputeProtinus has a reputation beyond repute
Jesus did not say this but only observe the service that was done to Him. What are you saying?
__________________
"The Light shines in the darkness, and the darkness did not comprehend it."

John 1:5
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 14th September 2009, 12:38 AM
Andrew B.'s Avatar
Newbie

64 Gender: Male Faith: Christian Country: United States Member For 3 Years
 
Join Date: 14th November 2008
Posts: 68
Blessings: 102,031
Reps: 96,261,318 (power: 96,265)
Andrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond repute
Andrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond reputeAndrew B. has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by Protinus View Post
Jesus did not say this but only observe the service that was done to Him. What are you saying?
This part of about washing feet begins with John 13:4

Also, I'd like to thank everyone who posted info for me. Very helpful.
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 14th September 2009, 12:53 PM
JasonV's Avatar
Priest

Gender: Male Faith: Utrecht Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 25th September 2006
Posts: 3,700
Blessings: 11,948,905
My Mood Bookworm
Reps: 18,944,763,352,946,140 (power: 18,944,763,352,955)
JasonV has disabled reputation
I believe there are several Christian churches who do some type of foot washing ceremony.

I also know that the Mormon church has a foot washing ceremony for it's hierarchy.
__________________

Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 15th October 2009, 11:53 AM
Yardstick's Avatar
Anglo-Catholic

23 Gender: Male Faith: Anglican Party: US-Green Country: United States Member For 3 Years
 
Join Date: 12th October 2008
Posts: 269
Blessings: 46,731
Reps: 686,358,889 (power: 686,362)
Yardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond repute
Yardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond reputeYardstick has a reputation beyond repute
My church does a foot washing.
__________________
Christianity is counter-cultural.

St. Basil on theft:
"When someone strips a man of his clothes we call him a thief. And one who might clothe the naked and does not -- should he not be given the same name? The bread in your board belongs to the hungry: the cloak in your wardrobe belongs to the naked, the shoes you let rot belong to the barefoot; the money in your vaults belongs to the destitute."
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 31st January 2010, 12:10 AM
Junior Member

Gender: Male Married Faith: Anglican Party: US-Democrat Country: United States Member For 2 Years
 
Join Date: 30th January 2010
Location: Bluffton, SC, USA
Posts: 2,426
Blessings: 6,087,502
My Mood Praising
Reps: 271,175,901,510,437,696 (power: 271,175,901,510,442)
mark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond repute
mark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond reputemark1 has a reputation beyond repute
If the issue is whether there are churches that have the ritual fo footwashing, many do.

However, I am not aware of any that treat footwashing as a sacrament.

Anthanasius gave the Church definition fo a sacrament. However, there really is one practical addition. The sacraments of the Church are those that have been passed down through the tradition of the Church as a sacrament. Otherwise, we can have lively prayer-filled discussions on what should and should not be sacraments.
Reply With Quote
Reply


Return to The Lord's Table - Liberal Catholics

Thread Tools
Display Modes


 
Become a CF Site Supporter Today and Make These Ads Go Away!


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 06:47 AM.