Home | Be a Christian | Devotionals | Join Us! | Forums | Rules | F.A.Q.


Go Back   Christian Forums > Congregation > Christian Communities > United Church Of Christ
Register BlogsPrayersJobsArcade Calendar Mark Forums Read

United Church Of Christ The new forum for United Church Of Christ Members

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 8th September 2009, 10:44 PM
tinythinker's Avatar
Guest

Member For 3 Years
 
Join Date: 16th June 2008
Posts: 158
Blessings: 41,473
My Mood Pensive
Reps: 22,204,316 (power: 22,208)
tinythinker has disabled reputation
My view of UCC conflicted

Why does it bother me to see that this congregation has its roots in Calvinism...?

Or that the Heidelberg Confession from which the founder congregations took their direction focuses so strongly on utter depravity and God's wrath equalling eternal torment?

Or that other historical influences preached a minimal liturgy allowing only those things mentioned in the Bible?

Etc...

I guess I am confused about how the history of the UCC connects with its present and future.

I have read lots of stuff from the UCC website, and some UCCers borrows Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox things like Lectio Divina and the Jesus Prayer. I have heard about the political tendencies. I've seen the commercials and learned about the Still Speaking campaign. I read blogs by UCC people like Chuck Currie and Faithful Progressive. That seems to be part of my confusion. Does the UCC just not care about these historical influences in terms of informing its current views? Am I misreading something somewhere? How does a hellfire and brimstone descendant of Calvinism that affirms a document saying humans are totally corrupt and evil beings that an angry God is going to smite with endless damnation, etc, square that with the other beliefs presented?
__________________

Reply With Quote
Become a CF Site Supporter Today and Make These Ads Go Away!

  #2  
Old 9th September 2009, 10:19 AM
Supernaut's Avatar
muscle car

33 Gender: Male Faith: Atheist Party: US-Democrat Country: United States Member For 2 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 12th June 2009
Location: Sacramento
Posts: 3,400
Blessings: 94,112
My Mood Serious
Reps: 1,344,940,743,831,579,648 (power: 1,344,940,743,831,585)
Supernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond repute
Supernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by tinythinker View Post
Why does it bother me to see that this congregation has its roots in Calvinism...?

Or that the Heidelberg Confession from which the founder congregations took their direction focuses so strongly on utter depravity and God's wrath equalling eternal torment?

Or that other historical influences preached a minimal liturgy allowing only those things mentioned in the Bible?

Etc...

I guess I am confused about how the history of the UCC connects with its present and future.

I have read lots of stuff from the UCC website, and some UCCers borrows Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox things like Lectio Divina and the Jesus Prayer. I have heard about the political tendencies. I've seen the commercials and learned about the Still Speaking campaign. I read blogs by UCC people like Chuck Currie and Faithful Progressive. That seems to be part of my confusion. Does the UCC just not care about these historical influences in terms of informing its current views? Am I misreading something somewhere? How does a hellfire and brimstone descendant of Calvinism that affirms a document saying humans are totally corrupt and evil beings that an angry God is going to smite with endless damnation, etc, square that with the other beliefs presented?

The congregations are so different from end of the spectrum to the other. Some hold to strict traditional doctrine while others lean more heavily to Esoteric Christianity.

As far as holding to Calvinistic traditions like Hellfire and Brimstone...I have never heard of a UCC Church that actually believes and teaches that doctrine of hate.

Remember though that all Churches will have their liberals and conservatives.
__________________
Baby, what about you?
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 9th September 2009, 08:34 PM
Regular Member

Gender: Male Married Faith: Baptist Country: United States Member For 2 Years
 
Join Date: 26th August 2009
Location: Baytown, Texas
Posts: 193
Blessings: 62,346
My Mood Stressed
Reps: 295,422,052,567 (power: 0)
atcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond repute
atcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond repute
I have met some people from the church of christ denomination and some were of the hell fire and brimstone, but some weren't. It really depends on each congregation and what is taught.
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 9th September 2009, 08:41 PM
b.hopeful's Avatar
Sharp as a razor, soft as a prayer

37 Gender: Female Faith: Christian Country: United States Member For 2 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 18th July 2009
Location: St.Louis, Missouri
Posts: 2,059
Blessings: 11,228,207
My Mood SpiritFilled
Reps: 103,644,116,902,950,112 (power: 103,644,116,902,955)
b.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond repute
b.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond reputeb.hopeful has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by atcfisherman View Post
I have met some people from the church of christ denomination and some were of the hell fire and brimstone, but some weren't. It really depends on each congregation and what is taught.

Atc....there's a big difference between the UCC(United Church of Christ) and CoC(Church of Christ). They are often confused.
__________________
Trying to practice and reflect God's scandalous grace


To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.






Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 9th September 2009, 08:42 PM
Supernaut's Avatar
muscle car

33 Gender: Male Faith: Atheist Party: US-Democrat Country: United States Member For 2 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 12th June 2009
Location: Sacramento
Posts: 3,400
Blessings: 94,112
My Mood Serious
Reps: 1,344,940,743,831,579,648 (power: 1,344,940,743,831,585)
Supernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond repute
Supernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond reputeSupernaut has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by atcfisherman View Post
I have met some people from the church of christ denomination and some were of the hell fire and brimstone, but some weren't. It really depends on each congregation and what is taught.

Keep in mind that "Church of Christ" and "United Church of Christ" are completely different denoms.

COC is definetely hellfire and brimstone whereas even the most conservative UCC does not usually adhere to the doctrine of hell.
__________________
Baby, what about you?
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 9th September 2009, 09:27 PM
LiturgyInDMinor's Avatar
Celtic Rite Old Catholic Church

Gender: Male Married Faith: Utrecht Country: United States Member For 2 Years Steward
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 20th February 2009
Posts: 4,915
Blessings: 340,176,567
My Mood Lurking
Reps: 187,207,274,281,724,320 (power: 187,207,274,281,731)
LiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond repute
LiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond reputeLiturgyInDMinor has a reputation beyond repute
Yeah most of the UCC churches I've attended have really preached a social gospel.

CoC on the other hand is full of hyper-calvinist rhetoric.(my experience only of course).

Thanks for letting me visit guys.
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 10th September 2009, 12:03 AM
Regular Member

Gender: Male Married Faith: Baptist Country: United States Member For 2 Years
 
Join Date: 26th August 2009
Location: Baytown, Texas
Posts: 193
Blessings: 62,346
My Mood Stressed
Reps: 295,422,052,567 (power: 0)
atcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond repute
atcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond reputeatcfisherman has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by b.hopeful View Post
Atc....there's a big difference between the UCC(United Church of Christ) and CoC(Church of Christ). They are often confused.
Sorry, I actually didn't know that. Thanks for clarifying that for me. I assume that I can type each in at google and read the differences? Again, thanks for the clarification.
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 12th September 2009, 02:28 AM
Paul1965's Avatar
Liberal Fundamentalist

46 Gender: Male Married Faith: Christian Country: United States Member For 2 Years
 
Join Date: 15th July 2009
Location: Ohio
Posts: 89
Blessings: 30,332
My Mood Amazed
Reps: 1,840,349,211,438 (power: 1,840,349,214)
Paul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond repute
Paul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond reputePaul1965 has a reputation beyond repute
I grew up in a UCC church. From what I understand the UCC is very liberal. Their slogan is "God is still speaking." I think they have a tendency to forget that God spoke (the scriptures)! I have not been part of UCC for 25 years, but believe their LEADERSHIP needs to take the initiative for revival and returning to scripture to really hear God speak!
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 13th September 2009, 07:16 PM
Senior Veteran

Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 5th June 2005
Posts: 2,189
Blessings: 1,000,093,541
My Mood Pensive
Reps: 5,825,286,539,019 (power: 0)
spinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond repute
spinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond reputespinningtutu has a reputation beyond repute
Well... the UCC as a whole is more varied than not. There are some "liberal" areas (especially along coast lines), there are more "conservative" ones, there actually is a historical/traditional/fundamentalist group within the UCC which advocates for a strict return to the roots, there is the "God is still speaking" initiative which some have adopted, just as the "Open and Affirming" initiative is optional.

I think that asking "What is the UCC like?" is the wrong question... and that it is more helpful to ask "what is the individual congregation like?" In the end, the congregational polity and the openess to diversity seem to be the two connecting strands throughout the denomination as a whole. However, it is also probably true that within the UCC, those who are middle-to-left leaning hold the majority and that those who are right-leaning are in the minority.

The first UCC I ever attended was in a very Evangelical part of the Midwest, in a small city... and it was pretty much a traditional Calvinist church except that in that congregation there were a minority of "progressives" who were into reading stuff like Campolo and ordaining women. At one point in that church's history, one of their pastors came out of the closet and the congregation sucessful voted to have them removed from the church.

The second UCC I went to was practically the polar opposite of the first - and it was located in a very secular part of New England. The minister was female, the congregation voted to become "Open and Affirming" and to take part in the "God is still speaking" initiative. The message for Easter sunday openly questioned (if not denied) the bodily resurrection and, at times, I wondered if I was the only person there who held a High Christology.

The third UCC I went to was a progressive-Evangelical place. Yes, there was a huge emphasis on the Social Gospel, very Campolo style... the main pastor was female, it was a multi-cultural and multi-racial place, people did not like George W Bush, it was Open & Affirming with a significant queer population... and at the same time, people believed in and worshipped the Risen Christ. The liturgy included Confession time, to repent of our sins... it was a place that believed in the Gospel message.
...It was, more or less, my cup of tea (so to speak).

But my own experience here highlights why I am UCC... I used to be trying to find the "right" denomination (i.e. the one that agreed with me on everything I believe). But that doesn't really exist. But what can happen - is that a person can find a congregation of like-minded people, a family to be a part of. Since I'm in seminary, I need the UCC in the sense that I need the freedom to truly be myself without also denying everyone else in the Church who isn't like me.
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 13th September 2009, 10:22 PM
tinythinker's Avatar
Guest

Member For 3 Years
 
Join Date: 16th June 2008
Posts: 158
Blessings: 41,473
My Mood Pensive
Reps: 22,204,316 (power: 22,208)
tinythinker has disabled reputation
Originally Posted by paxi1334 View Post
Well... the UCC as a whole is more varied than not. There are some "liberal" areas (especially along coast lines), there are more "conservative" ones, there actually is a historical/traditional/fundamentalist group within the UCC which advocates for a strict return to the roots, there is the "God is still speaking" initiative which some have adopted, just as the "Open and Affirming" initiative is optional.

I think that asking "What is the UCC like?" is the wrong question... and that it is more helpful to ask "what is the individual congregation like?" In the end, the congregational polity and the openess to diversity seem to be the two connecting strands throughout the denomination as a whole. However, it is also probably true that within the UCC, those who are middle-to-left leaning hold the majority and that those who are right-leaning are in the minority.

The first UCC I ever attended was in a very Evangelical part of the Midwest, in a small city... and it was pretty much a traditional Calvinist church except that in that congregation there were a minority of "progressives" who were into reading stuff like Campolo and ordaining women. At one point in that church's history, one of their pastors came out of the closet and the congregation sucessful voted to have them removed from the church.

The second UCC I went to was practically the polar opposite of the first - and it was located in a very secular part of New England. The minister was female, the congregation voted to become "Open and Affirming" and to take part in the "God is still speaking" initiative. The message for Easter sunday openly questioned (if not denied) the bodily resurrection and, at times, I wondered if I was the only person there who held a High Christology.

The third UCC I went to was a progressive-Evangelical place. Yes, there was a huge emphasis on the Social Gospel, very Campolo style... the main pastor was female, it was a multi-cultural and multi-racial place, people did not like George W Bush, it was Open & Affirming with a significant queer population... and at the same time, people believed in and worshipped the Risen Christ. The liturgy included Confession time, to repent of our sins... it was a place that believed in the Gospel message.
...It was, more or less, my cup of tea (so to speak).

But my own experience here highlights why I am UCC... I used to be trying to find the "right" denomination (i.e. the one that agreed with me on everything I believe). But that doesn't really exist. But what can happen - is that a person can find a congregation of like-minded people, a family to be a part of. Since I'm in seminary, I need the UCC in the sense that I need the freedom to truly be myself without also denying everyone else in the Church who isn't like me.
Sure, no group is perfect, but some sermons just strike one as so immature, ignorant, or wrong-headed that you just feel like the approval by the congregation tells you what you need to know about fitting in. The local UCC isn't a welcoming or Still Speaking group, and this is a fairly conservative non-urban area.
__________________

Reply With Quote
Reply


Return to United Church Of Christ

Thread Tools
Display Modes


 
Become a CF Site Supporter Today and Make These Ads Go Away!


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 11:25 PM.