Home | Be a Christian | Devotionals | Join Us! | Forums | Rules | F.A.Q.


Go Back   Christian Forums > Theology (Christians Only) > Theology > Christian History
Register BlogsPrayersJobsArcade Members List Calendar Mark Forums Read

Christian History The forum to discuss the history of the Christian church.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  #21  
Old 25th September 2009, 07:38 PM
catzrfluffy's Avatar
Newbie

19 Gender: Female Faith: Christian Country: United Kingdom
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 4th September 2009
Location: Location, Location
Posts: 565
Blessings: 500,083,519
My Mood Cheeky
Reps: 413,965,716,087,777 (power: 413,965,716,088)
catzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond repute
catzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond repute
But then why the need for the story to be carried all the way around the world? Unless the earth was being repopulated? It appears in almost every culture. See here for a list: Flood Stories from Around the World
Reply With Quote
Become a CF Site Supporter Today and Make These Ads Go Away!

  #22  
Old 25th September 2009, 08:08 PM
Senior Contributor

42 Gender: Male Married Faith: Anglican Party: AU-Greens Country: Australia Member For 5 Years
 
Join Date: 6th July 2004
Location: A very long way away
Posts: 14,087
Blessings: 8,795
Reps: 27,694,988,937,009 (power: 27,694,988,957)
ebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond repute
ebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by catzrfluffy View Post
But then why the need for the story to be carried all the way around the world?
Floods are a major event in most parts of the world, so one would expect catastrophic flood stories to be near universal.

Interestingly, around here there is an Indigenous story about the Murray River breaking through and creating the Barham Choke that is suffiently precise to date it to the real geological event - between ten and fifteen thousand years ago.
__________________
Goodness is stronger than evil,
love is stronger than hate,
light is stronger than darkness,
life is stronger than death,
victory is ours through him who loved us.
(++Desmond Tutu)
Reply With Quote
  #23  
Old 26th September 2009, 07:27 AM
Afghanistan is SERIOUSLY a dump!

23 Gender: Female Faith: Catholic Country: Australia Member For 3 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 12th September 2006
Posts: 14,291
Blessings: 136,907
Reps: 7,215,020,562,594 (power: 0)
EnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond repute
EnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by catzrfluffy View Post
But then why the need for the story to be carried all the way around the world? Unless the earth was being repopulated? It appears in almost every culture. See here for a list: Flood Stories from Around the World
Not the same story of the same flood appears in nearly every culture.
Reply With Quote
  #24  
Old 26th September 2009, 12:11 PM
catzrfluffy's Avatar
Newbie

19 Gender: Female Faith: Christian Country: United Kingdom
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 4th September 2009
Location: Location, Location
Posts: 565
Blessings: 500,083,519
My Mood Cheeky
Reps: 413,965,716,087,777 (power: 413,965,716,088)
catzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond repute
catzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond reputecatzrfluffy has a reputation beyond repute
The similarities are too remarkable to dismiss, please read the link, most of them contain some sort of Noah type figure as well.
Reply With Quote
  #25  
Old 26th September 2009, 07:34 PM
Senior Contributor

42 Gender: Male Married Faith: Anglican Party: AU-Greens Country: Australia Member For 5 Years
 
Join Date: 6th July 2004
Location: A very long way away
Posts: 14,087
Blessings: 8,795
Reps: 27,694,988,937,009 (power: 27,694,988,957)
ebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond repute
ebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond reputeebia has a reputation beyond repute
I just read one page of them, and not a single Noah figure in sight, so "most of them contain a Noah figure" would appear, at first glace, to be an overstatement at best.

But what constitutes a Noah figure? Someone escaping the flood on a boat would be a pretty common theme in a flood story.
__________________
Goodness is stronger than evil,
love is stronger than hate,
light is stronger than darkness,
life is stronger than death,
victory is ours through him who loved us.
(++Desmond Tutu)
Reply With Quote
  #26  
Old 26th September 2009, 10:17 PM
Afghanistan is SERIOUSLY a dump!

23 Gender: Female Faith: Catholic Country: Australia Member For 3 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 12th September 2006
Posts: 14,291
Blessings: 136,907
Reps: 7,215,020,562,594 (power: 0)
EnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond repute
EnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by catzrfluffy View Post
The similarities are too remarkable to dismiss, please read the link, most of them contain some sort of Noah type figure as well.
I'ead similar things before. All the flood stories with genuine similarities have common roots in the same area, which is what we'd expect. One of the places civilisation began was in Mesopotamia, were the flood story is part of their oral tradition, so its not suprising that the flood story was incorporated into all of their successor cultures. But guess what? Cultures and civilisations that DON'T decend from Mesopotamian roots don't have the same flood story.

I'm not ignoring the similarities, I'm merely avoiding leaping to the conclusion that best suits what I want to believe, and rather trying to analyse things a little further.
Reply With Quote
Reply


Return to Christian History

Thread Tools
Display Modes



 
Become a CF Site Supporter Today and Make These Ads Go Away!
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 11:14 PM.


vBCredits v1.4 Copyright ©2007 - 2008, PixelFX Studios