Home | Be a Christian | Devotionals | Join Us! | Forums | Rules | F.A.Q.


Go Back   Christian Forums > Theology (Christians Only) > Theology (Christian Only) > Christian Philosophy & Ethics
Register BlogsPrayersJobsArcade Calendar Mark Forums Read

Christian Philosophy & Ethics The forum to discuss philosophy and ethics from a Christian perspective.

Closed Thread
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  #991  
Old 21st September 2009, 02:53 AM
genez's Avatar
Contributor

64 Gender: Male Faith: Christian Country: United States Member For 5 Years
 
Join Date: 1st March 2004
Location: In Christ
Posts: 9,587
Blessings: 61,095,010
Reps: 115,489,322,076,477,296 (power: 115,489,322,076,496)
genez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond repute
genez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by Episcopalian Girl View Post

Living in Sin: A Bishop Rethinks Human Sexuality by Bishop John Shelby Spong
Spong????

He claimed that the resurrection of Jesus is a myth!

Its no wonder he is a good reference for pro gay propaganda.

.
__________________
.



God has two dwellings:
one in heaven, and the other
in a meek and thankful heart.
Izaak Walton
(1593-1683)





Become a CF Site Supporter Today and Make These Ads Go Away!

  #992  
Old 21st September 2009, 03:07 AM
Ave Maria's Avatar
Ave Maria Gratia Plena

30 Gender: Female Faith: Catholic Party: US-Republican Country: Vatican City State Member For 5 Years
 
Join Date: 31st May 2004
Location: Diocese of Evansville, IN USA
Posts: 71,378
Blessings: 1,150,096
My Mood Praying
Blog Entries: 14
Reps: 399,981,254,093,781,504 (power: 399,981,254,093,861)
Ave Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond repute
Ave Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by genez View Post
Spong????

He claimed that the resurrection of Jesus is a myth!

Its no wonder he is a good reference for pro gay propaganda.

.
Do you have any proof that he claimed that the resurrection of Jesus is a myth???
__________________

To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.


"We've had enough of exhortations to be silent! Cry out with a hundred thousand tongues. I see that the world is rotten because of silence." - Saint Catherine of Siena
  #993  
Old 21st September 2009, 03:28 AM
Legend

27 Gender: Female Faith: Catholic Country: Australia Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 12th September 2006
Posts: 15,520
Blessings: 1,109,829
Reps: 10,219,569,387,278,330 (power: 0)
EnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond repute
EnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by genez
What you said was a diversion away from having to deal with what was said. Jesus plainly stated that God's design was for male and female in marriage. It was not mining.
Jesus did no such thing. I get that you;d really, really LIKE that to be an accurate interpretation of that passage, but it just ain't so.

Show us just one gay relationship mentioned in the Bible involving godly people? You should, if what you claim were the truth. You can not.
.
Jonathon and David.
Ruth and Naomi.
The centurian and his servant.

There's 3.
  #994  
Old 21st September 2009, 03:46 AM
genez's Avatar
Contributor

64 Gender: Male Faith: Christian Country: United States Member For 5 Years
 
Join Date: 1st March 2004
Location: In Christ
Posts: 9,587
Blessings: 61,095,010
Reps: 115,489,322,076,477,296 (power: 115,489,322,076,496)
genez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond repute
genez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond reputegenez has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by EnemyPartyII View Post
Originally Posted by genez
What you said was a diversion away from having to deal with what was said. Jesus plainly stated that God's design was for male and female in marriage. It was not mining.
Jesus did no such thing. I get that you;d really, really LIKE that to be an accurate interpretation of that passage, but it just ain't so.
Show us just one gay relationship mentioned in the Bible involving godly people? You should, if what you claim were the truth. You can not.
.
Jonathon and David.
Ruth and Naomi.
The centurian and his servant.

There's 3.
I remember reading a book by a psychotherapist who had many homosexuals as patients. One of the consistent traits he noticed was how homosexuals would readily project homosexuality into aspects of normal life that others would not. What you just posted is proof that this doctor knew what he was talking about. I read that book long before ever reading a Bible. It was just one of his points that always stuck and I remembered. With the centurian and his servant? Its possible. Bisexual/homosexual expression was very common amongst the Romans. That is why the Jews in Jesus day saw homosexuality as being a Gentile disorder.
__________________
.



God has two dwellings:
one in heaven, and the other
in a meek and thankful heart.
Izaak Walton
(1593-1683)





  #995  
Old 21st September 2009, 03:58 AM
Legend

27 Gender: Female Faith: Catholic Country: Australia Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 12th September 2006
Posts: 15,520
Blessings: 1,109,829
Reps: 10,219,569,387,278,330 (power: 0)
EnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond repute
EnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by genez View Post
I remember reading a book by a psychotherapist who had many homosexuals as patients. One of the consistent traits he noticed was how homosexuals would readily project homosexuality into aspects of normal life that others would not. What you just posted is proof that this doctor knew what he was talking about. I read that book long before ever reading a Bible. It was just one of his points that always stuck and I remembered. With the centurian and his servant? Its possible. Bisexual/homosexual expression was very common amongst the Romans. That is why the Jews in Jesus day saw homosexuality as being a Gentile disorder.
So you're just going to hand wave away my 3 examples are you? Nice.

But you asked for an example of righteous people in a homosexual relationship in the Bible, even if you don't accept david and Ruth (because, lets face it, its not like you'd go with what's obvious when it hurts your position so much) the centurion and his servant, whether they were Roman, Chinese or martian, are still an example.

You asked for an example, I gave you at least 1 that even you seem to accept. Are you big enough to follow through on your promise and reconsider my point?
  #996  
Old 21st September 2009, 08:16 AM
Ave Maria's Avatar
Ave Maria Gratia Plena

30 Gender: Female Faith: Catholic Party: US-Republican Country: Vatican City State Member For 5 Years
 
Join Date: 31st May 2004
Location: Diocese of Evansville, IN USA
Posts: 71,378
Blessings: 1,150,096
My Mood Praying
Blog Entries: 14
Reps: 399,981,254,093,781,504 (power: 399,981,254,093,861)
Ave Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond repute
Ave Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond reputeAve Maria has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by genez View Post
Read the reviews as well. The man is nuts! But, liberals who do not know the first thing about salvation, just love the man.
Sorry, I had to remove your link in order to be able to post. That said, are you trying to say that I, as a liberal, don't know the first thing about salvation?
__________________

To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.


"We've had enough of exhortations to be silent! Cry out with a hundred thousand tongues. I see that the world is rotten because of silence." - Saint Catherine of Siena
  #997  
Old 21st September 2009, 09:04 AM
AngelusSax's Avatar
Believe

31 Gender: Male Married Faith: Lutheran Party: US-Others Country: United States Member For 5 Years Fisherman
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 16th April 2004
Location: Ohio
Posts: 5,457
Blessings: 13,259,887
My Mood Blessed
Blog Entries: 10
Reps: 18,114,585,688,161,456 (power: 18,114,585,688,176)
AngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond repute
AngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond repute
Jonathon and David.
Ruth and Naomi.
The centurian and his servant.

There's 3.
Okay, I've got to just say this:
I don't know about Ruth and Naomi, but I doubt it. Centurian and servant... possible, but again I don't know. Jonathan and David, I highly doubt. I get the whole thing about becoming of one spirit and having the deepest love they'd known, and in today's way of speaking, that would be a homosexual relationship, and that's sad.

It's sad that we live in a time and culture when two men cannot express affection and a friendship so deep as to even be considered soulmates, unless it is about being gay. The idea of deep love being constrained to the realm of romance is ludicrous, in my opinion. It is possible to have a love so deep as to transcend all other earthly love and it not be a romantic relationship, and I believe Jonathan and David had one such relationship. Of course, the Bible doesn't explicitly rule out a romantic relationship that I know of, but it doesn't actually mention one either, except by our own interpretation of what that means based on what it means to most of us today.
__________________
I am the way, I am the light

I am the dark inside the night
I hear your hopes, I feel your dreams
And in the dark I hear your screams
Don't turn away, just take my hand
And when you make your final stand
I'll be right there ,I'll never leave
All I ask of you
Believe
-Believe by Savatage and the Trans-Siberian Orchestra

Don't fear tomorrow
And don't fear the night
It's where God repairs sorrows
That enter your life
-TSO

For the children are the architects of the future, and we are the architects of our children.
-Paul O'Neill

The world isn't the way it's supposed to be. That's why there's us. Champions. We live as though the world were as it should be, to show it what it can be.

-TV's Angel


To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
  #998  
Old 21st September 2009, 10:18 AM
OllieFranz's Avatar
Senior Member

Gender: Male Faith: Christian Member For 5 Years Steward
 
Join Date: 2nd July 2007
Posts: 5,005
Blessings: 4,368,730
My Mood Serious
Reps: 93,847,009,549,098,768 (power: 93,847,009,549,109)
OllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond repute
OllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond reputeOllieFranz has a reputation beyond repute
From the Schreiner excerpt that Ken posted"

At least two pieces of evidence, however, indicate that an argument from the created order is constructed in Rom. 1:26–27. First, Paul selected the unusual words θῆλυς (thēlys, female) and ἄρσην (arsēn, male) rather than γύνη (gynē, woman) and ἀνήρ (anēr, man), respectively. In doing so he drew on the creation account of Genesis, which uses the same words (Gen. 1:27 LXX; cf. Matt. 19:4; Mark 10:6). These words emphasize the sexual distinctiveness of male and female (Moo 1991: 109), suggesting that sexual relations with the same sex violate the distinctions that God intended in the creation of man and woman. Second, the phrase “contrary to nature” (παρὰ φύσιν) is rooted in Stoic and Hellenistic Jewish traditions that saw homosexual relations as violations of the created order (see below).
By missing the fact that Paul was citing an example from a work of Plato's, Schreiner falsely attributed Plato's word choices to Paul, and jumped to unsupportable conclusions

The latter point is borne out by verse 27, which specifies in three ways what constitutes the unnatural activity for men: (1) in forsaking sexual relations with women (ἀφέντες τὴν φυσικὴν χρῆσιν τῆς θηλείας); (2) in burning in desire for other men (ἐξεκαύθησαν ἐν τῇ ὀρέξει αὐτῶν εἰς ἀλλήλους, exekauthēsan en tē orexei autōn eis allēlous); and (3) in doing that which was shameful with other men (ἄρσενες ἐν ἄρσεσιν τὴν ἀσχημοσύνην κατεργαζόμενοι, arsenes en arsesin tēn aschēmosynēn katergazomenoi).7 Verse 27 gives no indication that only specific kinds of homosexual activity are prohibited. Instead, homosexual relations in general are indicted.
Burning (ἐκκαίω ekkaiō) and lust (ὄρεξις orexis) are two of the five parts, or symptoms of the vice of Passion. Paul inserts all five symptoms into this passage in order to point out the actual sin. The other three parts are desire (ἐπιθυμία epithymia), found in verse 24, emotion (πάθος pathos), found in verse 26, and error or wandering [from the path of Reason] (πλάνη planē), found in verse 27. Rather than describing the awfulness of "homosexuality," their purpose is to point to the actual sin being described.

Two other words are often highlighted in this passage to point out how awful "homosexuality" was in Paul's eyes: dishonored (ἀτιμία atimia) and shameful (ἀσχημοσύνη aschēmosynē). The second one is referenced in the Schreiner paragraph above.

It is true that atimia is the negative of time (honored), just as in English, unfaithful is the negative of faithful. But something atimia is not necessarily worthy of scorn. The Potter can make from the same lump of clay two vessels, one honored and one dishonored. Nor does shame (aschemosyne) necessarily come from sin. Paul in several passages speaks about the shame he endured for the sake of preaching the gospel. Both of these words, along with their opposites appear in 1 Corinthians 12:23, where Pual tells us to honor the dishonored, and to exalt the shamed:
And those [members] of the body, which we think to be less honourable, upon these we bestow more abundant honour; and our uncomely [parts] have more abundant comeliness.
__________________
Do I claim that I am never wrong in what I've come to believe from my study of the Scriptures? Of course not. Then I would not be open to learning the truth when I still have so much more to learn. If I ever believed I knew all of God's truth, I'd be claiming to know the whole of God's mind -- I'd be, like Eve under the Serpent's influence, and like Nimrod, or whichever early king of Babel ordered the building of the Tower, and like the mad emperor Caligula, trying to become God
  #999  
Old 21st September 2009, 10:33 AM
Legend

27 Gender: Female Faith: Catholic Country: Australia Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 12th September 2006
Posts: 15,520
Blessings: 1,109,829
Reps: 10,219,569,387,278,330 (power: 0)
EnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond repute
EnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond reputeEnemyPartyII has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by AngelusSax View Post
Okay, I've got to just say this:
I don't know about Ruth and Naomi, but I doubt it. Centurian and servant... possible, but again I don't know. Jonathan and David, I highly doubt. I get the whole thing about becoming of one spirit and having the deepest love they'd known, and in today's way of speaking, that would be a homosexual relationship, and that's sad.

It's sad that we live in a time and culture when two men cannot express affection and a friendship so deep as to even be considered soulmates, unless it is about being gay. The idea of deep love being constrained to the realm of romance is ludicrous, in my opinion. It is possible to have a love so deep as to transcend all other earthly love and it not be a romantic relationship, and I believe Jonathan and David had one such relationship. Of course, the Bible doesn't explicitly rule out a romantic relationship that I know of, but it doesn't actually mention one either, except by our own interpretation of what that means based on what it means to most of us today.
Of course heterosexual men can display affection.

But when the original language uses terms that are specific to romantic relationships, when they are said to love one another "more than any woman", when they spend all that time sneaking around behind Saul's back, the hanging around each other naked... Ever heard the saying about "if it walks like a duck"? I mean, its POSSIBLE they were just really, really good friends, who never even thought about physical intimacy, but the description really doesn't read that way, and the deeper you research it, the more like a homosexual relationship it sounds.

Heres a fun experiment for you, change the names and describe Jonathon and David's relationship as though its two friends you know and are concerned about, with the parental consern, the loving each other more than women, all of it, to your nearist pulpit bashing anti-homosexual, and watch them froth at the wrongness of the relationship. If it were any other 2 men described in such terms, anywhere outside the Bible, I don't believe there would be any question at all that Jonathon and David's relationship was erotic, and if you're honest with yourself, I'm sure you'll agree.
  #1000  
Old 21st September 2009, 10:56 AM
AngelusSax's Avatar
Believe

31 Gender: Male Married Faith: Lutheran Party: US-Others Country: United States Member For 5 Years Fisherman
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 16th April 2004
Location: Ohio
Posts: 5,457
Blessings: 13,259,887
My Mood Blessed
Blog Entries: 10
Reps: 18,114,585,688,161,456 (power: 18,114,585,688,176)
AngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond repute
AngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond reputeAngelusSax has a reputation beyond repute
Of course heterosexual men can display affection.

But when the original language uses terms that are specific to romantic relationships, when they are said to love one another "more than any woman", when they spend all that time sneaking around behind Saul's back, the hanging around each other naked... Ever heard the saying about "if it walks like a duck"? I mean, its POSSIBLE they were just really, really good friends, who never even thought about physical intimacy, but the description really doesn't read that way, and the deeper you research it, the more like a homosexual relationship it sounds.

Heres a fun experiment for you, change the names and describe Jonathon and David's relationship as though its two friends you know and are concerned about, with the parental consern, the loving each other more than women, all of it, to your nearist pulpit bashing anti-homosexual, and watch them froth at the wrongness of the relationship. If it were any other 2 men described in such terms, anywhere outside the Bible, I don't believe there would be any question at all that Jonathon and David's relationship was erotic, and if you're honest with yourself, I'm sure you'll agree.
Oh I don't think it can be ruled out either way. When I read it, I often get a romantic impression, but I don't know how much of that is my 21st century American mind imposing that into the text, and how much isn't. I think the debate over whether it was a homosexual relationship misses the point of the story, though. I think the point had more to do with two people who would stick with each other even when the going got really, really rough, and how God's Grace is evident in such a relationship. Any romantic involvement is incidental, I think, though like I said, I cannot rule it out, and certainly if it is true that they had a romantic relationship and there was no punishment for it, and even blessing because of it, that would be a huge deal with how churches should approach this issue. But as for the story itself, the romance or lack thereof is secondary point, at the highest, in my opinion.
__________________
I am the way, I am the light

I am the dark inside the night
I hear your hopes, I feel your dreams
And in the dark I hear your screams
Don't turn away, just take my hand
And when you make your final stand
I'll be right there ,I'll never leave
All I ask of you
Believe
-Believe by Savatage and the Trans-Siberian Orchestra

Don't fear tomorrow
And don't fear the night
It's where God repairs sorrows
That enter your life
-TSO

For the children are the architects of the future, and we are the architects of our children.
-Paul O'Neill

The world isn't the way it's supposed to be. That's why there's us. Champions. We live as though the world were as it should be, to show it what it can be.

-TV's Angel


To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
Closed Thread


Return to Christian Philosophy & Ethics

Thread Tools
Display Modes


 
Become a CF Site Supporter Today and Make These Ads Go Away!


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 06:23 AM.