Home | Be a Christian | Devotionals | Join Us! | Forums | Rules | F.A.Q.


Go Back   Christian Forums > Congregation > Faith Groups > Progressive/Moderate Adventists
Register BlogsPrayersJobsArcade Calendar Mark Forums Read

Progressive/Moderate Adventists A forum for Progressive/Moderate Adventists.

Reply
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Unread 23rd October 2008, 03:54 AM
Veteran

Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 12th August 2008
Posts: 1,861
Blessings: 149,141
My Mood Cynical
Reps: 3,525,108,003 (power: 0)
S53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond repute
S53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond repute
Question from a hybrid Adventist-Messianic

I've only recently spent 2 years around Adventists. Every time I tell my Evangelical "friends" they me I shouldn't. Why? Because apparently, the SDA church believes that the Archangel Michael IS Jesus.

I don't know if that's a better question for the Traditional Adventists....but frankly, I'm very puzzled. I e-mailed my old SDA Academy Bible teacher, but he hasn't replied yet.....and it's been about a month.
Reply With Quote
Become a CF Site Supporter Today and Make These Ads Go Away!

  #2  
Unread 23rd October 2008, 10:50 AM
Byfaithalone1's Avatar
The gospel is Jesus Christ!

Gender: Male Married Faith: Non-Denominational Member For 5 Years
 
Join Date: 3rd May 2007
Posts: 3,611
Blessings: 6,100,297
Reps: 10,986,165,904,026,884 (power: 10,986,165,904,037)
Byfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond repute
Byfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond reputeByfaithalone1 has a reputation beyond repute
A few questions to ask.

Originally Posted by S53 View Post
I've only recently spent 2 years around Adventists. Every time I tell my Evangelical "friends" they me I shouldn't. Why? Because apparently, the SDA church believes that the Archangel Michael IS Jesus.

I don't know if that's a better question for the Traditional Adventists....but frankly, I'm very puzzled. I e-mailed my old SDA Academy Bible teacher, but he hasn't replied yet.....and it's been about a month.
I am a former SDA. I was SDA for over 30 years.

You will find that SDAs believe a number of different things. As you will see in this forum, there are traditional SDAs, progressive SDAs and, perhaps, other varieties as well. Although the issues are not always easily defined, in general traditional SDAs hold to the 28 fundamental beliefs of SDAism (or at least most of them). Progressive SDAs do not limit themselves by the 28 fundamentals or by the SDA baptismal vows.

As you become involved in an SDA community, you might seek answers to questions such as these:
(1) Does SDAism teach that, at some point in the future, non-sabbatarians will receive the mark of the beast and will be cast into the lake of fire?

(2) Does SDAism teach that SDAism teaches the "remnant message" that will be espoused by God's people at the end of time?

(3) Does SDAism teach that man must become sinless prior to Christ's second coming so that he may stand in the sight of a holy God without a mediator following the close of probation?

(4) Does SDAism teach salvation by grace alone, or salvation by grace plus works?

(5) Does SDAism teach that the judgment is currently taking place and, if so, why?

(6) Does SDAism teach that God's people must prepare for a national Sunday law that will soon be passed; and that God's people should be prepared to flee to the mountains once it does?

(7) How many authoritative sources of truth does SDAism have?

(8) What is the Biblical basis for teaching that some of the old covenant laws are binding on Gentiles, but that others are not?

(9) Do SDAs believe that man loses his salvation between the point of his sin and until the point of his repentance?

(10) What do SDAs believe will happen to those who once embrace "the sabbath" and then later abandon it?
Note that many of the progressive SDAs who post in this forum would disagree with most (if not all) of the above assertions.

BFA
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Unread 23rd October 2008, 11:38 AM
Sophia7's Avatar
Tall73's Wife

Gender: Female Married Faith: Christian Country: United States Member For 5 Years Commander
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 24th September 2005
Posts: 11,252
Blessings: 32,905
Reps: 284,290,963,309,102,944 (power: 284,290,963,309,123)
Sophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond repute
Sophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond reputeSophia7 has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by S53 View Post
I've only recently spent 2 years around Adventists. Every time I tell my Evangelical "friends" they me I shouldn't. Why? Because apparently, the SDA church believes that the Archangel Michael IS Jesus.

I don't know if that's a better question for the Traditional Adventists....but frankly, I'm very puzzled. I e-mailed my old SDA Academy Bible teacher, but he hasn't replied yet.....and it's been about a month.
I am also a former Adventist. I was raised in the SDA Church but left last year due to disagreements with some of the 28 fundamental beliefs. To answer your question, many Traditional Adventists do believe that the Archangel Michael is Jesus. Ellen White repeatedly referred to Michael as Christ in her writings.

What you should understand, though, is that Adventism teaches that the term archangel can refer to the commander of the angels, who would not necessarily be an angel himself. Thus, Adventists today are not calling Jesus a created being by identifying Him as Michael. In Adventist thought, Michael is a title for Christ in His "great controversy" against Satan and the evil angels.

What you should also understand is that most of the Adventist pioneers were anti-trinitarian in their beliefs:
From about 1846 to 1888, the majority of Adventists rejected the concept of the Trinity—at least as they understood it. All the leading writers were antitrinitarian, although the literature contains occasional references to members who held trinitarian views. . . .

Those who rejected the traditional Trinity doctrine of the Christian creeds were devout believers in the biblical testimony regarding the eternity of God the Father, the deity of Jesus Christ "as Creator, Redeemer and Mediator," and the "importance of the Holy Spirit." While some, very early in Adventist history, held that Christ had been created, by 1888 it was widely accepted that he had preexisted from "so far back in the days of eternity that to finite comprehension" he was "practically without beginning." Whatever that beginning may have involved, it was not by "creation." Moreover, they weren't initially convinced that the Holy Spirit was an individual divine Person and not merely an expression for the divine presence, power, or influence.

"Respecting the trinity, I concluded that it was an impossible for me to believe that the Lord Jesus Christ, the Son of the Father, was also the Almighty God, the Father, one and the same being," wrote Joseph Bates regarding his conversion in 1827. He told his father, "If you can convince me that we are one in this sense, that you are my father, and I your son; and also that I am your father, and you my son, then I can believe in the trinity." Because of this difference, he chose to join the Christian Connection rather than the Congregational church of his parents. One might be tempted to dismiss Bates's assessment as simple ignorance of the meaning of Trinity, but there were then and remain today a variety of views claiming the term "Trinity." Cottrell observed in 1869 that there were "a multitude of views " on the Trinity, "all of them orthodox, I suppose, as long as they nominally assent to the doctrine." (http://www.sdanet.org/atissue/trinit...n-trinity1.htm)
The question of Ellen White's views on the Trinity is debated among Adventists:
In 1846 James White dismissed the doctrine of the Trinity as "the old unscriptural trinitarian creed." A century later, the denomination he co-founded voted its first official endorsement of a statement of "Fundamental Beliefs" that included reference to the Trinity. That a major theological shift occurred is no longer subject to debate. That most of the early leaders among Seventh-day Adventists held an antitrinitarian theology has become standard Adventist history in the forty years since E. R. Gane wrote an M.A. thesis on the topic. What is now disputed in some quarters is Gane's second hypothesis, that Adventist co-founder Ellen G. White (1827-1915) was "a trinitarian monotheist." Since the 1980s, that view has come under intense attack from some writers, mostly from outside the academic community. Nevertheless, the renewed scrutiny of the role of Ellen White in the development of the Adventist Trinity doctrine has raised enough questions to warrant a fresh examination of the issue. (http://www.sdanet.org/atissue/trinit...n-trinity2.htm)
The belief about Michael relates to the Trinity issue because many of the early Adventists had a different view of the nature of Christ than Adventists today, believing that He had a beginning of some sort. The Adventist pioneers' views were strikingly similar to what Jehovah's Witnesses teach on the Trinity, the origin of Christ, and His preincarnate identity as Michael. Adventism's views on the Trinity have evolved over time (though some would question how much), and you won't find the majority of Adventists today agreeing with JW statements on these matters (although there are still pockets of such thinking here and there within Adventism). So, while Adventists now adamantly insist that the belief in Michael as Jesus does not mean that He is a created being, the early Adventists would not have been so clear on that.

My biggest problem with the Michael-equals-Christ theory is this text:
Daniel 10:12 Then he said to me, "Do not be afraid, Daniel, for from the first day that you set your heart on understanding this and on humbling yourself before your God, your words were heard, and I have come in response to your words.
13 "But the prince of the kingdom of Persia was withstanding me for twenty-one days; then behold, Michael, one of the chief princes, came to help me, for I had been left there with the kings of Persia. (NASB)
If Michael is only one of the chief princes, I do not believe that He could be Jesus.
__________________
Therefore we do not lose heart. Though outwardly we are wasting away, yet inwardly we are being renewed day by day. For our light and momentary troubles are achieving for us an eternal glory that far outweighs them all. So we fix our eyes not on what is seen, but on what is unseen. For what is seen is temporary, but what is unseen is eternal. (2 Corinthians 4:16-18)


Reply With Quote
  #4  
Unread 23rd October 2008, 01:19 PM
Veteran

Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 12th August 2008
Posts: 1,861
Blessings: 149,141
My Mood Cynical
Reps: 3,525,108,003 (power: 0)
S53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond repute
S53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond repute
Thanks for the replies. I understand now.
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Unread 24th October 2008, 09:16 AM
Newbie

73 Gender: Male Married Faith: Christian Member For 5 Years
 
Join Date: 8th September 2008
Posts: 1,266
Blessings: 64,696
Reps: 9,225,635,000,307,808 (power: 9,225,635,000,315)
Joe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond repute
Joe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond reputeJoe67 has a reputation beyond repute
Daniel 12:1 - Michael, the great prince, the head of princes, stands up.

He was sitting down until we who are his enemy by natural birth are made a place for his feet, his spirit, to rest/ dwell in us.

Only the first begotten from the dead, who was sent from the Father, can return to the Father as testified in Psalm 24 and Ezekiel 46 and plainly stated by Jesus, our Lord, in John 3.

Jesus is Lord of the hosts within the gates and doors. He is the king of glory. He is King of kings and Lord of lords. He is the Head of the body and we are members of His body.

Joe
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Unread 5th December 2008, 09:24 PM
Mankin's Avatar
A Strange Mixture of Random Components.

22 Gender: Male Faith: Christian Party: US-Democrat Country: United States Member For 5 Years Fisherman
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 28th April 2007
Location: In the Norse Lands
Posts: 8,637
Blessings: 102,626,737
Reps: 30,653,123,513,220,688 (power: 30,653,123,513,236)
Mankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond repute
Mankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond repute
Hello S53. I recognize you from the Teen forums. And yes many Adventists do believe that Jesus was the Archangel and I believe this is confirmed in EGW writings. I am an Progressive Adventist obviously.

As for me, I tend to think He is, but its not a position I care about all that much.
__________________

To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Unread 6th December 2008, 02:43 AM
Veteran

Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 12th August 2008
Posts: 1,861
Blessings: 149,141
My Mood Cynical
Reps: 3,525,108,003 (power: 0)
S53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond repute
S53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond repute
I believe this is confirmed in EGW writings
And I suppose I should ask another question, since I've met some that believe it.

Are White's writings considered equivalent to the Bible?

Last edited by S53; 6th December 2008 at 04:51 AM.
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Unread 6th December 2008, 11:00 AM
Senior Veteran

33 Gender: Male Faith: Seventh-Day-Adventist Party: US-Others Country: United States Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 6th June 2007
Posts: 7,196
Blessings: 176,059
Reps: 208,606,668,648,834 (power: 208,606,668,663)
JonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond repute
JonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond reputeJonMiller has a reputation beyond repute
No, and you will find few who say so but a number of traditional adventists do so in practice.

JM
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Unread 6th December 2008, 08:41 PM
Veteran

Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 12th August 2008
Posts: 1,861
Blessings: 149,141
My Mood Cynical
Reps: 3,525,108,003 (power: 0)
S53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond repute
S53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond reputeS53 has a reputation beyond repute
Ok, thanks. I didn't think it was the majority.
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Unread 7th December 2008, 05:14 PM
Mankin's Avatar
A Strange Mixture of Random Components.

22 Gender: Male Faith: Christian Party: US-Democrat Country: United States Member For 5 Years Fisherman
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 28th April 2007
Location: In the Norse Lands
Posts: 8,637
Blessings: 102,626,737
Reps: 30,653,123,513,220,688 (power: 30,653,123,513,236)
Mankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond repute
Mankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond reputeMankin has a reputation beyond repute
No of course it isn't. I was saying that the fact that Adventism teaches this was confirmed in EGW. Sorry if you misunderstood me.
__________________

To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
Reply With Quote
Reply


Return to Progressive/Moderate Adventists

Thread Tools
Display Modes


 
Become a CF Site Supporter Today and Make These Ads Go Away!


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 09:06 PM.