Home | Be a Christian | Devotionals | Join Us! | Forums | Rules | F.A.Q.


Go Back   Christian Forums > Congregation > Christian Communities > Scripture,Tradition,Reason-Anglican & Old Catholic
Register BlogsPrayersJobsArcade Calendar Mark Forums Read

Scripture,Tradition,Reason-Anglican & Old Catholic The forum for Anglican, Anglo-Catholic and Episcopal churches.

Closed Thread
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 19th September 2007, 04:27 PM
Iosias's Avatar
reformed mystic

Married Faith: Anglican Country: Europe Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 18th July 2004
Posts: 7,474
Blessings: 126,647
Reps: 10,076,193,046,393,122 (power: 10,076,193,046,409)
Iosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond repute
Iosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond repute
A Must Read On The Trinity

Become a CF Site Supporter Today and Make These Ads Go Away!

  #2  
Old 19th September 2007, 05:24 PM
Iron Sun 254's Avatar
Insane Genius

43 Gender: Male Married Faith: Anglican Party: US-Others Country: United States Member For 5 Years Commander
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 23rd August 2004
Location: Pittsburgh, PA, USA
Posts: 11,755
Blessings: 2,284
My Mood Goofy
Reps: 4,688,865,644,866 (power: 4,688,865,664)
Iron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond repute
Iron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond reputeIron Sun 254 has a reputation beyond repute
Can you tell us a little bit about why it's an important book to read?
__________________
There's a fine line between genius and insanity....That's where I live, baby!!!


To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
  #3  
Old 20th September 2007, 12:59 PM
Iosias's Avatar
reformed mystic

Married Faith: Anglican Country: Europe Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 18th July 2004
Posts: 7,474
Blessings: 126,647
Reps: 10,076,193,046,393,122 (power: 10,076,193,046,409)
Iosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond repute
Iosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by Iron Sun 254 View Post
Can you tell us a little bit about why it's an important book to read?
I am currently reading it on my commutes to university. The author, Robert Letham (M.A.R., Th.M., Westminster Theological Seminary; Ph.D., University of Aberdeen), is senior minister of Emmanuel Orthodox Presbyterian Church, Wilmington, Delaware.

He looks at the Trinity in Scripture, he then traces the historical development of the doctrine and that is as far as I have got.

Blurb:

When it comes to the doctrine of the Trinity, evangelicals have underachieved. In The Holy Trinity Robert Letham helps to redress this shortcoming. He offers a well-researched volume about “the One who is utterly transcendent and incomprehensible.” After examining the doctrine’s biblical foundations, the author traces its historical development through the twentieth century, and engages four critical issues: the Trinity and (1) the incarnation, (2) worship and prayer, (3) creation and missions, and (4) persons.

Reviews:

“There is no hotter topic in modern theology than the Trinity, and Robert Letham has given us a comprehensive guide that will stand us all in good stead. I recommend it highly.” —Gerald Bray

“In this outstanding work, Letham points us back to God in all the mystery and glory of his triune being. With his keen theological acumen, Letham has given us a tour de force of Reformed theology.” — Sinclair B. Ferguson

“Solid and judicious, comprehensive and thorough, abreast of past wisdom and present-day debate, and doxological in tone throughout, this is far and away the best big textbook on the Trinity that you can find, and it will surely remain so for many years to come.” — J. I. Packer
  #4  
Old 20th September 2007, 01:12 PM
Mary of Bethany's Avatar
Only one thing is needful

Gender: Female Faith: Eastern-Orthodox Member For 5 Years
 
Join Date: 8th July 2004
Posts: 5,669
Blessings: 62,315
My Mood Fine
Reps: 110,509,730,416,270,384 (power: 110,509,730,416,284)
Mary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond repute
Mary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond repute
Interesting - that same author is also putting out a book that is a "critique" of Orthodoxy from the Reformed pov. I would imagine he used a lot of Orthodox sources for this book.

Have you gotten far enough to share what he says Protestantism's shortcomings re the Holy Trinity are?

I know as a Baptist, the Holy Trinity was not really emphasized or talked about much, though it was certainly a bedrock belief. I heard a lot more about the Holy Trinity as an Anglican. Liturgy probably played a big part in that.

Mary
__________________
Christ is risen from the dead, trampling down death by death, and upon those in the tombs bestowing Life!
  #5  
Old 20th September 2007, 01:18 PM
Iosias's Avatar
reformed mystic

Married Faith: Anglican Country: Europe Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 18th July 2004
Posts: 7,474
Blessings: 126,647
Reps: 10,076,193,046,393,122 (power: 10,076,193,046,409)
Iosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond repute
Iosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by Mary of Bethany View Post
Interesting - that same author is also putting out a book that is a "critique" of Orthodoxy from the Reformed pov. I would imagine he used a lot of Orthodox sources for this book.

Have you gotten far enough to share what he says Protestantism's shortcomings re the Holy Trinity are?

I know as a Baptist, the Holy Trinity was not really emphasized or talked about much, though it was certainly a bedrock belief. I heard a lot more about the Holy Trinity as an Anglican. Liturgy probably played a big part in that.

Mary
He touched on it briefly but that is still to come. He points out the differences between the Western and Eastern views and concludes each chapter with a prayer and many are EO. He also looks at some EO theologians and points out that many western Christians are almost modalists which the EO view protects against. If you have the cash it is well worth the purchase, stateside best here.

You may like:
http://www.monergismbooks.com/easternorthodox2478.html - the one you refer to above
http://www.monergismbooks.com/easternorthodox.html
  #6  
Old 21st September 2007, 05:40 AM
Iosias's Avatar
reformed mystic

Married Faith: Anglican Country: Europe Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 18th July 2004
Posts: 7,474
Blessings: 126,647
Reps: 10,076,193,046,393,122 (power: 10,076,193,046,409)
Iosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond repute
Iosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond repute
FYI: Here is an online article written by Letham entitled The Trinity, Worship and Prayer.
  #7  
Old 21st September 2007, 05:46 AM
Iosias's Avatar
reformed mystic

Married Faith: Anglican Country: Europe Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 18th July 2004
Posts: 7,474
Blessings: 126,647
Reps: 10,076,193,046,393,122 (power: 10,076,193,046,409)
Iosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond repute
Iosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by Mary of Bethany View Post
...a "critique" of Orthodoxy from the Reformed pov.
Try this online article: A Calvinist Looks at Orthodoxy by Jack D. Kinneer who trained at St. Vladimir's Orthodox Theological Seminary.
  #8  
Old 21st September 2007, 01:36 PM
Mary of Bethany's Avatar
Only one thing is needful

Gender: Female Faith: Eastern-Orthodox Member For 5 Years
 
Join Date: 8th July 2004
Posts: 5,669
Blessings: 62,315
My Mood Fine
Reps: 110,509,730,416,270,384 (power: 110,509,730,416,284)
Mary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond repute
Mary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond reputeMary of Bethany has a reputation beyond repute
Thanks for all the links, AV! I don't want to turn this into an "Orthodox" thread, so I'm not going to discuss them on here, but I'll take a look when I can.

I didn't mean to hijack - I just saw the author's name and thought that was interesting.

Mary
__________________
Christ is risen from the dead, trampling down death by death, and upon those in the tombs bestowing Life!
  #9  
Old 21st September 2007, 01:42 PM
Iosias's Avatar
reformed mystic

Married Faith: Anglican Country: Europe Member For 5 Years
View Profile Pic
 
Join Date: 18th July 2004
Posts: 7,474
Blessings: 126,647
Reps: 10,076,193,046,393,122 (power: 10,076,193,046,409)
Iosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond repute
Iosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond reputeIosias has a reputation beyond repute
Originally Posted by Mary of Bethany View Post
Thanks for all the links, AV! I don't want to turn this into an "Orthodox" thread, so I'm not going to discuss them on here, but I'll take a look when I can.

I didn't mean to hijack - I just saw the author's name and thought that was interesting.

Mary
Glad to be of help
Closed Thread


Return to Scripture,Tradition,Reason-Anglican & Old Catholic

Thread Tools
Display Modes


 
Become a CF Site Supporter Today and Make These Ads Go Away!


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 07:13 PM.