Creation & EvolutionForum for the discussion of this important topic. This forum is open to non-believers. There is a Christians-only forum in the Christians-only section too.
I like your handle: I'm a big fan of the singer. Your question is a good one. The answer is, only if it could be shown that they were all deposited at the same time. We see silt layers being deposited in many parts of the world all of the time today, and we know that rivers, streams and bodies of water dry up, change course, etc - so it is reasonable to take the sedimentary deposits found around the world as evidence of past events similar to the ones we see now.
__________________ Man should no more get tired of using his brain--if he is using it properly--than a fish should get tired of water.
Originally posted by Jewel Hi all, I'm new to the forum. What about the silt layers throughout the world, couldn't that be interpreted as a world wide flood?
We also see things like fossilized animal burrows in the layers, so we know that each layer took a reasonably long time to form.
And then there are varves, which are alternating layers of light and dark sediments that are deposited one pair per year. The Green River formation in Wyoming has millions of these layers.
Hi Jerry, I didn't expect a reply this quick! Jewel is actually my middle name. I guess that would be a major project testing all the silt layers. Maybe I shouldn't bring this up since I honestly can't remember where is was but I do remember seeing a show once where they found fossils of sea life in the rock formations in one of the deserts in the USA.
Jewel,
I couldn't dig up a reference to it quickly either, but it is not uncommon to find marine fossils in areas where there are no longer any seas. There was a time when much of North America was underwater. There have also been found marine fossils near the peaks of some tall mountains.
The history of the Earth is a long one, and the continents - and the plates they ride on, are constantly moving. New mountains are pushed up, Land surfaces become sea-beds, then become land surfaces again.
Fossil sea life, found on what is now dry land, follows a pattern: The deeper the rocks the fossils are found in, the more primitive they are. If they were all deposited at once by a global flood, then we would expect all the different marine fossils to be mixed together in the same-aged rock. Instead, they are sorted out by kind, with the ones most similar to modern marine creatures being nearest the "top" layer of rock.
__________________ Man should no more get tired of using his brain--if he is using it properly--than a fish should get tired of water.
Since only one person who believes in The Flood posted a reasonably thought out conjecture... I a person who doesn't believe in The Flood will offer help to those who do. Its not much, but at least its something.
And I am curious as to why this is...
How about the widespread belief in a flood? That is within different peoples spread throughout the world... a belief that the world was flooded.
__________________ Truth is steadfast.
You can fight the truth.
All your life.
And when your dead.
Nothing of substance.
The truth remains steadfast.
>>Hi LFOD, So you'r saying there is evidence of fossil life (marine) where it really shouldn't be?
Nah, I _think_ he's saying that geological/geographical features change due to natural processes, mountains rise from the collision of continents, rivers change course, earthquakes, plate techtonics(sp?), et cetera. Bringing the fosils with them in their changes.
__________________ Truth is steadfast.
You can fight the truth.
All your life.
And when your dead.
Nothing of substance.
The truth remains steadfast.
Originally posted by Jewel Hi LFOD, So you'r saying there is evidence of fossil life (marine) where it really shouldn't be?
I guess I misinterpreted your post. I meant to point out that the evidence indicates that the layers were formed very slowly over a time period much longer than the purported duration of the flood.
The marine fossils you were talking about are readily apparent in the limestone layers of the Grand Canyon. An interesting thing for you to consider also is that some of the layers represent limestone formed on the sea floor, others represent mud from coastal areas, and still others are the lithified remains of old desert sand dunes.
The rock layers of the Earth are compelling evidence -- evidence that the Earth is very old.
Last edited by LiveFreeOrDie; 28th June 2002 at 05:44 PM.
Er... I thought you were talking about Jerry till I went back and scanned Jewel. So if the above post seems like nonsense, it was simply me being sloppy in my thinking. Sorry bout that! :-D
__________________ Truth is steadfast.
You can fight the truth.
All your life.
And when your dead.
Nothing of substance.
The truth remains steadfast.