Terrible idea that was tried once before. The report forum was more like entertainment for many. I would wager that, if anything, it increased the frequency of reports. And then mods had to moderate a space that was, by nature, contentious.
I wouldn't rely on the member being accused of using fallacious arguments to determine whether the accusation is founded. You're never going to get someone saying "Yeah, that was a strawman. You got me." They'll always claim that the accusation was unfounded and then back to the report button we go.
https://www.google.com/webhp?tab=ww&ei=GlszU_OTIcTmyAHh9ICYCg&ved=0CBgQ1S4#q=democratic%20party%20founding&safe=off
And the modern version of the Democratic party...
Democratic Party (United States) - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia)
And the KKK was founded when?
Ku Klux Klan -...