Trans women may get uterus transplants in the future

grasping the after wind said:

It is silly to treat mental illness using surgery. that is why lobotomies are frowned upon.

Click to expand...

Nothing is silly if it works. For some people, surgery is the only thing that does.

Thrash Metalhead said:

Well, I think my definition of natural is correct but everyone has their own view and definition on what natural is so who knows what it is really.

I'm also not really against trans women getting it because if it makes them happy then they should go for it. I just think messing around with reproductive organs sounds a bit skeptical and I'm not too sure on how to think of it.

Click to expand...

Why should the reproductive organs be any different to any other organs?

Cute Tink said:

Gender dysphoria is still not a mental illness.

Click to expand...

Oh right, it's normal thinking now, I forgot

Mayzoo said:

Then you need to make sure that is clear in a living will. What about your heart, liver, lungs, cornea? May those go to a trans person or a homosexual?

Once setting criteria begins, it rarely stops at setting one criteria. It continues on and on and on.

Click to expand...

Yes, any vital organs are donated. Uteruses and Penises don't count

Thrash Metalhead said:

http://metro.co.uk/2015/11/22/revol...-allow-trans-women-to-carry-children-5519000/

In my opinion, I think it is totally wrong and goes against nature and all that is natural. Your opinions?

Click to expand...

Since the woman in the article is an actual woman. Do you think it's okay for woman, (that either wasn't born with a complete uterus or had their uterus taking out) to have this procedure done? I have no problem with this procedure being to any woman Transgender or not.

A clinic in Ohio recently started screening women for the ground-breaking procedure, which would allow women to transplant their uterus into a woman who doesn’t have one.

The transplant could be conducted on a woman ‘born without a uterus, or who had it removed or have uterine damage’ – this would make trans women eligible for the procedure.

After the recipient has had a child or children, the uterus could then be removed, meaning the person would no longer have to take anti-rejection medication.

Click to expand...

dp

Thrash Metalhead said:

Well, I think my definition of natural is correct but everyone has their own view and definition on what natural is so who knows what it is really.

I'm also not really against trans women getting it because if it makes them happy then they should go for it. I just think messing around with reproductive organs sounds a bit skeptical and I'm not too sure on how to think of it.

Click to expand...

Hi,

I understand that you do not think it is part of what is natural, but it is. I am talking with my science hat on, now.

Natural even as used by it's most ardent proponents is used in a short sighted manner to support their feelings, but not their theology which includes science. They are unaware, or unwilling to use science, in their definition of natural. Remember the main Religious boys were wrong about Galileo Theologically.

How can a scientist be more right, religiously, Biblically than a huge number of Theologians? I do know the answer to that. Do you?

LOVE,

Cute Tink said:

Gender dysphoria is still not a mental illness.

Click to expand...

Hi,

Whew. I am glad you are here, Dr. Tink.

(For me and everyone at work knew it, if I called a person Dr. it was because they are so accurate that I could use them in my research. It is a term of respect. That does not nor did not mean that they are or were incapable of error, it meant they tried hard never to error, and their accomplishments, like yours are long, verified, and legendary.)

I am glad you are back, representing logic, reason and science.

LOVE,

patrick jane said:

Oh right, it's normal thinking now, I forgot

Click to expand...

Hi,

It's scientific and proven thinking now.

LOVE,

katerinah1947 said:

Hi,

It's scientific and proven thinking now.

LOVE,

Click to expand...

Nah, mental illness. Abnormal

Cute Tink said:

I thought we discussed that term?

Click to expand...

OH, Cute Tink !! You're so cute

patrick jane said:

Nah, mental illness. Abnormal

Click to expand...

Hi,

And how is it, that you can say that so remorselessly? If you are wrong, it can hurt. If you don't care if you are wrong, then you are possibly a lot of things.

Other than possible lack of knowledge, why do you trump all the scientists who have the answers, and all the diagnostiicians, who were told recently that the theory of Transgender being a mental illness is not correct.

Transgender is an intersex condition, but in the esoteric sense. The common definition of intersex just means body intersexuality, sometimes it is both male and female genes all in the same person and at the same time.

CAIS, which is xy males with a ,46 chrosome abnormality, is also as normal as transgender. And you and most guys by the time you are out of High School have been attracted to one of these men in your opinion, or at least some of your male friends have done that.

If you are attracted to a CAIS, person does that make you gay because of those xy genes that all males have, Women remember are suposedly all xx, not xy, does that make you gay. Well it does not according to Science. It does not.

Look up CAIS on the inernet look at some pictures. That is natural. They look that way naturally. If anything you are heterosexual and by a lot, if you are attrcted to CAIS.

LOVE,

Hi,

A news article on a CAIS person: http://abcnews.go.com/Health/MedicalMysteries/story?id=5465752

LOVE,

As the article stated, it could also be used on other women that may have their uterus removed for medical reasons or born without one, which would include transwomen. Good for them.

patrick jane said:

Oh right, it's normal thinking now, I forgot

Click to expand...

False dichotomy.

patrick jane said:

OH, Cute Tink !! You're so cute

Click to expand...

A pat on the head is also considered rude.

patrick jane said:

Yes, any vital organs are donated. Uteruses and Penises don't count

Click to expand...

A man in Africa got a penis transplant after a botched circumcision.

So yes, penises do count. Uteruses have been donated to women already as well.

Cute Tink said:

False dichotomy.



A pat on the head is also considered rude.

Click to expand...

Quit following me around

Cute Tink said:

A man in Africa got a penis transplant after a botched circumcision.

So yes, penises do count. Uteruses have been donated to women already as well.

Click to expand...

For a trans man to get a uterus should be outlawed, that's my point, thanks for getting me banned. Not too cute I tink

patrick jane said:

For a trans man to get a uterus should be outlawed, that's my point, thanks for getting me banned. Not too cute I tink

Click to expand...

This is the theoretical equivalent of "Ewww that's yucky"...