I've tried reading through this thread and it is so confused and so many points of view it made my head hurt.
So I have just one comment and if it has been stated before or sounds simplistic; so be it.
This is more to those who call them selves Christians, as the rest have made up their minds long ago. If you are a Christian; that means you believe in God; Christ and the Bible. Leaving out evolution; as there is short-tem evolution; then you must believe God created the universe; as the Bible states; That Jesus as the Word of God, was there; and all things were made by, for, and through Him, and He was God.
It takes faith that God created the universe by His infinite power; but that is easy compared to believing that the universe was made from nothing.
So those who don't want to believe in God; get Christians to debating about evolution using their rules of debate; science and pseudo-science; when we should be using the same rules as when we believe God created the universe; faith, as our understanding of this world/universe is finite; but God is infinite.